Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
Well you did say I was funny?maverick wrote:Surely you jestTeflon wrote: I'll get serious footy discussion with those who actually dont have an agenda...
No agenda eh, I think you actually believe thatTeflon wrote:Well you did say I was funny?maverick wrote:Surely you jestTeflon wrote: I'll get serious footy discussion with those who actually dont have an agenda...
But yeah Ive no agenda - if the coach warrants sacking then fair enough. 1.5 yrs in and him having 1 draft is to early to make that call. If that an agenda so be it.
You shoot early dont you?
BigMart wrote:Robert Harvey - Always a dodgy selection with a calf at 37yo......NO!
Sam Gilbert - Has not played in 8 weeks, looked like 10..........NO!
Should......
David Armitage played instead of Banger.........YES!
Shane Birss played instead of Gilbert..........YES!
Should.......
Charlie Gardner have come in for Ferguson......YES! (like for like)
Should.......
Jarred Allen or Ben McEvoy have come in for Kosi......Maybe (like for like)
Should......
McQualter have been in the original side after 4 BOG in the VFL.......YES!
Should......
Milne or Schnieder have been dropped for McQualter to give us a more defensive fwd crumber, who can go into the midfield.......... or Gwilt should have made way as we had Dempster, Goddard, S.Fisher, Blake already a tall utilities......Maybe!
As usual some real selection FOPARS by Ross......ones that armchair experts could see on Friday.....not in hindsight...
Well at least Greg Hutchinson would have been happy on Thursday....
well your the wise old 52 yr old who knows our coach is shyte and our medical staff is hopeless....so you MUST know what my agendas.....maverick wrote:No agenda eh, I think you actually believe thatTeflon wrote:Well you did say I was funny?maverick wrote:Surely you jestTeflon wrote: I'll get serious footy discussion with those who actually dont have an agenda...
But yeah Ive no agenda - if the coach warrants sacking then fair enough. 1.5 yrs in and him having 1 draft is to early to make that call. If that an agenda so be it.
You shoot early dont you?
Wasting your time in here Otiman.........its allOtiman wrote:BigMart wrote:Robert Harvey - Always a dodgy selection with a calf at 37yo......NO!
Sam Gilbert - Has not played in 8 weeks, looked like 10..........NO!
Should......
David Armitage played instead of Banger.........YES!
Shane Birss played instead of Gilbert..........YES!
Should.......
Charlie Gardner have come in for Ferguson......YES! (like for like)
Should.......
Jarred Allen or Ben McEvoy have come in for Kosi......Maybe (like for like)
Should......
McQualter have been in the original side after 4 BOG in the VFL.......YES!
Should......
Milne or Schnieder have been dropped for McQualter to give us a more defensive fwd crumber, who can go into the midfield.......... or Gwilt should have made way as we had Dempster, Goddard, S.Fisher, Blake already a tall utilities......Maybe!
As usual some real selection FOPARS by Ross......ones that armchair experts could see on Friday.....not in hindsight...
Well at least Greg Hutchinson would have been happy on Thursday....
Game was lost on the field, not the selection table.
Look at the performances of Ball and Dal Santo.
We played a decent team tonight with great defensive pressure, so Dal Santo was always going to have a quiet one. He had his one o.k game against good opposition for the year last week against the dogs, dont expect too many moreOtiman wrote:BigMart wrote:Robert Harvey - Always a dodgy selection with a calf at 37yo......NO!
Sam Gilbert - Has not played in 8 weeks, looked like 10..........NO!
Should......
David Armitage played instead of Banger.........YES!
Shane Birss played instead of Gilbert..........YES!
Should.......
Charlie Gardner have come in for Ferguson......YES! (like for like)
Should.......
Jarred Allen or Ben McEvoy have come in for Kosi......Maybe (like for like)
Should......
McQualter have been in the original side after 4 BOG in the VFL.......YES!
Should......
Milne or Schnieder have been dropped for McQualter to give us a more defensive fwd crumber, who can go into the midfield.......... or Gwilt should have made way as we had Dempster, Goddard, S.Fisher, Blake already a tall utilities......Maybe!
As usual some real selection FOPARS by Ross......ones that armchair experts could see on Friday.....not in hindsight...
Well at least Greg Hutchinson would have been happy on Thursday....
Game was lost on the field, not the selection table.
Look at the performances of Ball and Dal Santo.
Teflon wrote:Didnt see you calling for Harvs to be left out before the game?BigMart wrote:Robert Harvey - Always a dodgy selection with a calf at 37yo......NO!
Sam Gilbert - Has not played in 8 weeks, looked like 10..........NO!
Should......
David Armitage played instead of Banger.........YES!
Shane Birss played instead of Gilbert..........YES!
You always this good with hindsight?
FACTS are we have a mediacl staff. IF they clear Rob Harvey to play - he plays. Get a grip FFS.
