Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
point taken - I still think he's run out of chances to be anything more than an erratic minor goalkicking contributor - he's not nick davis... certainly not phil matera - Ball would double Milne's tally from the same position, plus lay some tackles
yeah, it was a good article, especially for a herald-sun article.
I have an idea - let's complete swap backline and forward line - tonnes of forward pressure then
I feel vindicated even though I was abused by a bunch of 12 years olds when I suggested that Gehrig and Milne should not play Geelong, In Another Opinion. Before the game.
I just thought Kosi would be a much better Foyle for Scarlet. The only way I can see Gehrig getting another Game is if he stops making ugly faces at his opponents, and start running through them. He has the body to do some legal damage. If he is so smart why not?
I'm looking forward to seeing how the two inclusions go tonight.
Both have toiled hard in the magoos to ensure a senior call up.
I really hope Gardiner has a good one to further vindicate he's move from the rampant cats!! Tonight could be he's first step in establishing himself as an AFL footballer.
groupie1 wrote:point taken - I still think he's run out of chances to be anything more than an erratic minor goalkicking contributor - he's not nick davis...
You're right, he's better.
Career averages
Davis 12.6 disposals, 1.4 goals, 1.2 tackles
Milne 10.5 disposals, 1.9 goals, 1.4 tackles
groupie1 wrote:point taken - I still think he's run out of chances to be anything more than an erratic minor goalkicking contributor - he's not nick davis... certainly not phil matera - Ball would double Milne's tally from the same position, plus lay some tackles
um, have you seen Ball try kick a goal....?
take your blinkers off, and you'll see that Milne does all those things that he is accused of not. He chases. He tackles. He passes off to team mates in better position. And, he kicks GOALS.....
i don't think it matters how much he does, some "supporters" just have it in for him......
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.
groupie1 wrote:point taken - I still think he's run out of chances to be anything more than an erratic minor goalkicking contributor - he's not nick davis... certainly not phil matera - Ball would double Milne's tally from the same position, plus lay some tackles
um, have you seen Ball try kick a goal....?
take your blinkers off, and you'll see that Milne does all those things that he is accused of not. He chases. He tackles. He passes off to team mates in better position. And, he kicks GOALS.....
i don't think it matters how much he does, some "supporters" just have it in for him......
exactly yapper just seems to be the scapegoat for not winning games!
Hell he is a crumber not a KPP and at the moment those KPP in the team have been way below par!
The_Dud wrote:take your blinkers off, and you'll see that Milne does all those things that he is accused of not. He chases. He tackles. He passes off to team mates in better position. And, he kicks GOALS.....
He tries to do these things, but he's slow, and can't make a tackle stick. Some of his passes to team mates should have been shots at goal, and his set shots from 40+ out are shocking.
The_Dud wrote:take your blinkers off, and you'll see that Milne does all those things that he is accused of not. He chases. He tackles. He passes off to team mates in better position. And, he kicks GOALS.....
He tries to do these things, but he's slow, and can't make a tackle stick. Some of his passes to team mates should have been shots at goal, and his set shots from 40+ out are shocking.
So because Milne tries to do the team things by trying to pass the ball to someone who he may think is in a better position he isn't good enough. People were having a go at him for being too selfish now its the opposite?
His set shots are a hell of alot better than some of the players!
I agree Mike, Ive loved Fraser and was shatered when he retired but I think we are better off with out him. He will be back up latter this year if injuries occur and when the games slow down latter in the year
The_Dud wrote:take your blinkers off, and you'll see that Milne does all those things that he is accused of not. He chases. He tackles. He passes off to team mates in better position. And, he kicks GOALS.....
He tries to do these things, but he's slow, and can't make a tackle stick. Some of his passes to team mates should have been shots at goal, and his set shots from 40+ out are shocking.
i hope you were watching tonight.....
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.
