Saints players you never really took a shine too

Dan Warna · Post: # 541446Post **Dan Warna** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 4:06pm

PLEASE NO CURRENT PLAYERS.

for me it was tony delany, tony francis, damien monkhorst, also went off russel morris very quickly, glen nugent was another one.

Robie neill and Brett Cook were not my faves either.

spert · Post: # 541451Post **spert** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 4:12pm

Never keen on Craig OBrien, though he kicked a few goals for us, Brian Wilson, Jacko!

rodgerfox · Post: # 541452Post **rodgerfox** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 4:13pm

Grant Thomas.

sackers5 · Post: # 541455Post **sackers5** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 4:17pm

Daniel Wulf, Robert Powell, Justin Plapp, Glen Coghlan, Gordon Fode

On the other hand players who I liked for no particular reason: jason Trianidis, Damen Shaw, Lazar Vidovic

Dan Warna · Post: # 541466Post **Dan Warna** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 4:36pm

sackers5 wrote:Daniel Wulf, Robert Powell, Justin Plapp, Glen Coghlan, Gordon Fode

On the other hand players who I liked for no particular reason: jason Trianidis, Damen Shaw, Lazar Vidovic

fair call

I really coghlan (turned out i was off base according to those who met him)

robert Powell I liked also because of the way he played.

fode I got rapt in his 3:5 and thought her we go!!!!

damen shaw and vidovic I liked also.

Otiman · Post: # 541468Post **Otiman** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 4:37pm

The Wakelin Brothers.

SaintPM · Post: # 541475Post **SaintPM** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 4:59pm

Rod Owen, talent wasted.

Gabba · Post: # 541480Post **Gabba** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 5:06pm

Plapp

Wulf

cuz60 · Post: # 541488Post **cuz60** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 5:21pm

Have a couple, Tim Elliott, had no decision making skills. Cant say I was a big fan of Kristian Bardsley, remember being down at Geelong the day he wore Ablett's elbow. Good effort to play footy again at the elite level after that.

Another one from the Timid years, Fred Campbell. All 60 odd kgs of him, really was never a chance to make it.

Then from the Ken Sheldon era could never take to Sean Ralph-Smith, seen worse footballer's but never took to him at all.

Ghost Like · Post: # 541493Post **Ghost Like** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 5:29pm

Craig Davenport

Francis and Monkhurst as well

David Sierakowski

joffaboy · Post: # 541495Post **joffaboy** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 5:30pm

Kain Taylor, Brad Gotch, Jodie Arnol, David Strooper.

Ghost Like · Post: # 541497Post **Ghost Like** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 5:36pm

joffaboy wrote:Kain Taylor, Brad Gotch, Jodie Arnol, David Strooper.

Kain the Toad Taylor, yes, there's another.

steph · Post: # 541501Post **steph** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 5:43pm

jason daniels - tried hard but really was just terrible

caydn beetham

Devilhead · Post: # 541503Post **Devilhead** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 5:54pm

Ghost Like wrote:
joffaboy wrote:Kain Taylor, Brad Gotch, Jodie Arnol, David Strooper.
Kain the Toad Taylor, yes, there's another.

sorry fellas but gotta disagree with this one - Kain Taylor whilst struggled early in his career actually became a fairly decent footballer - played as tagger and by the end of career had a few gun scalps to his name - he showed courage, passion and tried his heart out for the rbw - also had a pretty good mullet

and also how can anyone not like Jayson Daniels

Me and mate also used to go early and watch the reserves just to see Anthony "Skills" Evans put on a magic show

st_Trav_ofWA · Thu 03 Apr 2008 5:54pm

Ghost Like wrote:Craig Davenport

Francis and Monkhurst as well

David Sierakowski

i didnt mind Siera i met him after he joined the eagles and he still held the saints close to his heart

for me i never liked Barry Brooks (no suprise there )

Wulf and Moyle never really set my world on fire and Plapp was forgettable as was Delaney

a few who i liked for no apparent reason would have to be Craig Callahagn, Gavin Mitchell & Fergus Watts

Dal_Santos_Gal · Thu 03 Apr 2008 6:10pm

Justin Plapp
Tim Elliot
Troy Schwarze (Ready to cop it, but I never rated him) nice bloke
Sean Charles
Alan Murray (it was Alan yeah)
Nick Stone

can't think of any more at this stage.

sackers5 · Post: # 541509Post **sackers5** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 6:13pm

st_Trav_ofWA wrote:
Ghost Like wrote:
a few who i liked for no apparent reason ..... Gavin Mitchell

The moustache was reason enough

yipper · Post: # 541510Post **yipper** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 6:19pm

For me - Rene Kink. Doug Booth. Paul Morwood (never embraced the club).

st_Trav_ofWA · Thu 03 Apr 2008 6:21pm

sackers5 wrote:
st_Trav_ofWA wrote:
Ghost Like wrote:
a few who i liked for no apparent reason ..... Gavin Mitchell
The moustache was reason enough

it was a quallity MO

terry smith rules · Thu 03 Apr 2008 6:41pm

boy how you can name david siera, yeah sure did not have the all the skills but had an enormous passion for the club

and played his heart out every time he ran out

poor call

fqf

st_Trav_ofWA · Thu 03 Apr 2008 6:49pm

terry smith rules wrote:boy how you can name david siera, yeah sure did not have the all the skills but had an enormous passion for the club

and played his heart out every time he ran out

poor call

fqf

really nice bloke as well (from the one time ive met him) is a bit of a recluse now days never shows up to any of the WA functions same with the old man once they finnished footy they dont look back

yipper · Post: # 541527Post **yipper** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 6:49pm

terry smith rules wrote:boy how you can name david siera, yeah sure did not have the all the skills but had an enormous passion for the club

and played his heart out every time he ran out

poor call

fqf

Agree. Very harsh call - bloke was a passionate sainter even when he played for WCE. Gave his all - every time he went out there.

Goose is king · Thu 03 Apr 2008 7:23pm

Murry.

maverick · Post: # 541547Post **maverick** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 7:36pm

Agree on Glen Coghlan not one fof my favs....
Never embraced Frankie either, although i know many loved him, his kicking just frustrated me so much....
Another was Pekin, always ran to the wrong spots for mine....

ausfatcat · Post: # 541549Post **ausfatcat** » Thu 03 Apr 2008 7:39pm

tony brown

and

Jason Daniels would cringe whenever he got the ball and there was no one for him to hand ball to so just waiting for his god awful kick.