Carlton vs. Richmond tonight

gO.SainTs · Post: # 534027Post **gO.SainTs** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 9:41am

I'm just wondering about the game tonight and who you think will win out of the two.
Also wondering how you think Judd will go in the game, as a navy blue? Pretty sure he is playing tonight's match. Your opinion?

Sobraz · Post: # 534032Post **Sobraz** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 9:46am

Judd will struggle (will never reach the high he was), and tigs will win... nice way to shut up the carlton clan for a while..

spert · Post: # 534033Post **spert** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 9:48am

Hard to pick out of two loser teams, but Tigers for me.a little more strength around the ground.

riccardo · Post: # 534034Post **riccardo** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 9:49am

The way the football media in general has been (over) reacting to this game, I plan on not watching it at all.

Though I'll probably be in the vast minority.

SaintBot · Post: # 534037Post **SaintBot** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 9:54am

on paper richmond

however my heart says carlton, judd to be respectable

markp · Post: # 534039Post **markp** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 9:57am

Go Tigers... you are shyte, but please win.

Give Judd and Fev a working over at least.

saint66au · Post: # 534041Post **saint66au** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 9:59am

I sooo want Richmond to win by 100pts..and Juddy to be sat on his bum in the first 2 mins with a nice "Welcome back to Melbourne" off the square

The Peanut · Thu 20 Mar 2008 10:02am

The AFL are bleeding Juddy dry and expectations are higher for any player than I can remember - I'll take my hat off to him if he gets best on the ground after all this.

Post: # 534059Post **n1ck** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 10:56am

Carlton will thump Richmond.

The tigers are the most pathetic team in the competition at the moment, and Wallace is the most overrated coach in the history of football.

saintsRrising · Thu 20 Mar 2008 12:59pm

I think the Tigers may surprise and win....

The_Dud · Post: # 534107Post **The_Dud** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 1:10pm

what do you mean Richmond v Carlton?

from all the promotion i've seen the game is Richmond v Judd (feat. Carlton)

hope Judd (carlton) gets spanked

Dan Warna · Post: # 534110Post **Dan Warna** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 1:29pm

carlton will smash richmond

its sad but true.

carlton should have won 8 or 9 games last year but tanked it.

and maybe 2 games they were unlucky in.

they have a formidable midfield, a rank tosser who can kick 8 or 9 goals in a game, and some talent in their defence.

IMO in 07 if carlton had have won some close games they would have pushed harder for a finals berth, but they basically tanked the back half of the season in such a ridiculously obvious effort it was more than embarrassing.

with a new season, and their talent available, carlton will win by 40 points.

Richmond are woeful.

if carlton lose, then they are after 08 draft picks again ><

Solar · Post: # 534121Post **Solar** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 2:04pm

will be a battle of the midfield, currently I would put carltons mid on top but if richmond break even 50/50 then their forwards will moster the worst backline I have seen in many many years!

amusingname · Thu 20 Mar 2008 3:13pm

Not sure we were watching the same season last year Dan. Carlton are a pretty woeful unit. Apart from a few good top liners such as Fevola and Waite, and mid-tier players such as Carrazzo and Fisher, their team is very ordinary and their backline leaks like nobodys business.

Tanking or no tanking, they would not have been anywhere near the finals last year. Where they finished is pretty indicative of their ability.

I reckon tigers to win by 20 or 30 points tonight.

yipper · Post: # 534133Post **yipper** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 3:19pm

amusingname wrote:Not sure we were watching the same season last year Dan. Carlton are a pretty woeful unit. Apart from a few good top liners such as Fevola and Waite, and mid-tier players such as Carrazzo and Fisher, their team is very ordinary and their backline leaks like nobodys business.

Tanking or no tanking, they would not have been anywhere near the finals last year. Where they finished is pretty indicative of their ability.

I reckon tigers to win by 20 or 30 points tonight.

Yep, especially if Nick Stevens is out - according to big rumour on SEN.

Dan Warna · Post: # 534134Post **Dan Warna** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 3:25pm

yipper wrote:
amusingname wrote:Not sure we were watching the same season last year Dan. Carlton are a pretty woeful unit. Apart from a few good top liners such as Fevola and Waite, and mid-tier players such as Carrazzo and Fisher, their team is very ordinary and their backline leaks like nobodys business.

Tanking or no tanking, they would not have been anywhere near the finals last year. Where they finished is pretty indicative of their ability.

I reckon tigers to win by 20 or 30 points tonight.
Yep, especially if Nick Stevens is out - according to big rumour on SEN.

lol at the lines re: if houlahan was at Melbourne, both teams would be tougher

and slagging of hackland.

sigh at the same old dribble re: st kilda.

anyway, really with a bit of luck both will be autowins.

mmm carlton were very close in a lot of games, and while they were woeful, they played us to within a few points, and the outfit we had there was far superior.

personally love to see carlton as the foundation of teh AFL ladder, propping up the other 15 teams, but I reckon now they don't have to pay to feed fat albert, they'llhave more money for the rst of the team to eat.

saintspremiers · Thu 20 Mar 2008 3:30pm

I want Carlton to win so they only need 4 more wins to prevent a priority pick.

....and Judd to get even more injured than he already is of course!!

Dan Warna · Post: # 534139Post **Dan Warna** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 3:39pm

saintspremiers wrote:I want Carlton to win so they only need 4 more wins to prevent a priority pick.

....and Judd to get even more injured than he already is of course!!

no respect for judd, but he's not really an asswhipe, and he really is a talented player.

f.ebola on the other hand is, however can't see anyone at the tigers with the balls to go toe to toe with him.

benny gale might have run through him in his prime.

Saints Premiers 2008 · Thu 20 Mar 2008 3:44pm

Dan Warna wrote:
saintspremiers wrote:I want Carlton to win so they only need 4 more wins to prevent a priority pick.

....and Judd to get even more injured than he already is of course!!
no respect for judd, but he's not really an asswhipe, and he really is a talented player.

f.ebola on the other hand is, however can't see anyone at the tigers with the balls to go toe to toe with him.

benny gale might have run through him in his prime.

get real dan...judd is a very clever man looking out for number one...chris judd

so you would never have a look at what is out there in yor employment field if it became apparent you could earn plenty more???

i think not dan

Dan Warna · Post: # 534143Post **Dan Warna** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 3:51pm

Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
Dan Warna wrote:
saintspremiers wrote:I want Carlton to win so they only need 4 more wins to prevent a priority pick.

....and Judd to get even more injured than he already is of course!!
no respect for judd, but he's not really an asswhipe, and he really is a talented player.

f.ebola on the other hand is, however can't see anyone at the tigers with the balls to go toe to toe with him.

benny gale might have run through him in his prime.
get real dan...judd is a very clever man looking out for number one...chris judd

so you would never have a look at what is out there in yor employment field if it became apparent you could earn plenty more???

i think not dan

what? Im the one saying I disagree with having judd hit, just don't respect him. Have a look at how carlton are slipping him extra cash, environmental spokesman, FFS if thats not a salary cap rort ><

I said he's NOT an asswhipe, and I inferred I wouldn't want him hit, f.ebola on the other hand I wouln't mind seeing him hit, but theres no one at richmond capable.

CURLY · Post: # 534156Post **CURLY** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 4:02pm

Youd have to wonder about Morton who left West Coast for Richmond and cant get a game. Terry Wallace wonders why he is losing all credabiltiy but to chace a guy to get him to your club and not play him is ridiculous.

Armoooo · Post: # 534165Post **Armoooo** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 4:22pm

Dan Warna wrote: f.ebola on the other hand is, however can't see anyone at the tigers with the balls to go toe to toe with him.

benny gale might have run through him in his prime.

This might sound crazy but I think King would have a crack, he's not the biggest bloke but he has a lot of grunt, an Fev is all braun no brain, he would run with his tail between his legs at the first sign of trouble...

matrix · Post: # 534198Post **matrix** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 5:05pm

lucky you lot.....i get to watch the Morons play the Cats

oh......carlton by 16 points

gO.SainTs · Post: # 534230Post **gO.SainTs** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 5:46pm

Carlton in front by 6 points atm...come on Richmond

gO.SainTs · Post: # 534233Post **gO.SainTs** » Thu 20 Mar 2008 5:54pm

Scores are level