Why I want James Gwilt to win the Best & Fairest 2008

farquhar · Post: # 532628Post **farquhar** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 7:45pm

I want James Gwilt to win the 2008 Best & Fairest because if he did so then that would mean that one of our lesser-lights would have had an incredible season. And if a lesser-light could have an amazing season and go from the last man picked to the best player then the impact on the rest of the team could be enough to land that flag.

Why? If an unknown could have a bigger season than Reiwoldt, Hayes, Ball or Kosi, then we would have unearthed another gun player. If Reiwoldt wins his fifth B&F, then it doesn't tell us anything new, we already know he is a brilliant player. This team needs more brilliant players on deck for a full season to win that flag.

Then again, he could win it because every else has done hamstrings and we need to investigate new training and conditioning methods, again.

The_Dud · Post: # 532632Post **The_Dud** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 7:51pm

don't you have to get a game to win the B&F...?

plugger66 · Post: # 532637Post **plugger66** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 8:05pm

I want james dean to live.

jonesy · Post: # 532638Post **jonesy** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 8:09pm

If Gwilt wins our B&F it means the bird flu went through the remaining list...I don't want James Gwilt to win our B&F

Ralphy · Post: # 532641Post **Ralphy** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 8:25pm

i also want kurt cobain to live

But i do not want James gwilt to win our B&F

Gabba · Post: # 532665Post **Gabba** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 9:33pm

i want Pink Floyd to reunite and do a world tour but it ain't gonna happen either...

Unforgiven · Post: # 532675Post **Unforgiven** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 9:46pm

I want Dal Santo to win it. I beleive who ever wins our B and F this year will have on hell of a year. We as a team are primed for a good year, and so are many individuals like Ball, Kosi, Schneider, Xman etc. Who ever takes home the Best n Fairest this year would have had one great year.

Quixote · Post: # 532688Post **Quixote** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 10:35pm

Edited by mods.

Iceman234 · Post: # 532689Post **Iceman234** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 10:39pm

If Gwilt wins our B&F then it means we will probably finish below the Boos, who will have to rely on Ackland and Kreuzer as their ruck division. Fair dinkum if they rely on that then .... well....

That's the comparison I draw...

Was gonna quote ruck stats but there are none for the Blues No. 1 ruck stocks......

Ralphy · Post: # 532690Post **Ralphy** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 10:39pm

Gabba wrote:i want Pink Floyd to reunite and do a world tour but it ain't gonna happen either...

umm.... i think they are reunited

dont abuse me if im wrong but im sure they are

Quixote · Post: # 532693Post **Quixote** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 10:44pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:
Gabba wrote:i want Pink Floyd to reunite and do a world tour but it ain't gonna happen either...
umm.... i think they are reunited

dont abuse me if im wrong but im sure they are

Ralph I will give you just one tip.

Your myspace page is rude.

That's all.

houseofvictor · Sun 16 Mar 2008 10:54pm

Here Here farquhar - It would be great for a fringe player to step up to that sort of level. He may even remain a tad under the Radar without the 'fro too.
Regarding Pink Floyd. Has anyone heard about the "Pink Floyd Curse"? I know a tour would be the Bee's Knees, but I'm sure their album releases coinside with stock market crashes... Perhaps an album is secretly being recorded...

Huzzad · Post: # 532695Post **Huzzad** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 10:55pm

I'm all for Gwilty winning a Trevor Barker, whether list is depleted or full. It would sure put alot of people in their places if he did. But at the end of the day, I really do not think it is going to happen.

bobmurray · Post: # 532703Post **bobmurray** » Sun 16 Mar 2008 11:43pm

Who's Eva Green...What position does she play best in....

Pwoit · Post: # 532709Post **Pwoit** » Mon 17 Mar 2008 2:47am

bobmurray wrote:Who's Eva Green...What position does she play best in....

He may have something there.....Click

riccardo · Post: # 532720Post **riccardo** » Mon 17 Mar 2008 8:48am

I certainly hope he does NOT, because that will mean all our good players will have had horrible seasons and we'll likley be 14th-16th.

Remember 2000 - I loved Thommo, but, really, do you want a repeat of that season, because thats what ity will take for Gwilt to win the B&F.

He's on wafer thin ice this year as it is.

spert · Post: # 532774Post **spert** » Mon 17 Mar 2008 11:46am

If Gwilt wins the B&F, then that means that we are not relying on the same few big names to carry the team all year..that's been our big problem, the big gap to our second rung players.

riccardo · Post: # 532787Post **riccardo** » Mon 17 Mar 2008 12:05pm

It would be good if a player on our second rung won the B&F, but Gwilt is on about the 5th rung.

A second rung player I would think would be one of the Clarkes, Montagna maybe Fiora, Birss, players like that.

Gabba · Post: # 532863Post **Gabba** » Mon 17 Mar 2008 3:41pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:
Gabba wrote:i want Pink Floyd to reunite and do a world tour but it ain't gonna happen either...
umm.... i think they are reunited

dont abuse me if im wrong but im sure they are

Sadly, they are not. They did, however, breifly reunite for Live 8 but they have no performed since as the Rogers, Gilmour, Mason, Wright setup.

It would be great for Gwilt to step up like that but it just ain't gonna happen.