Expectations of 08
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
Expectations of 08
Where do you see us finishing in 08?
IMO I see us as a serious top 4 side, we finished the year as one of the better sides in the league and teams like the Roos, Hawks and Power should level out a bit, I'd be pretty dissapointed if we weren't a serious finals contender and even worse if we were to miss out all together.
IMO I see us as a serious top 4 side, we finished the year as one of the better sides in the league and teams like the Roos, Hawks and Power should level out a bit, I'd be pretty dissapointed if we weren't a serious finals contender and even worse if we were to miss out all together.
So you see us as having a strong enough side to win the cup?fonz_#15 wrote:premiership. i demand we do not tolerate mediocrity, nor settle for 2nd best anymore, We need to get serious and stop being content with playing in a finals series. lift your game saints.
I think we'll be a fair chance providing Gardiner realises some of the talent he is capable of, same with King, he had a decent grand final but we'll need him to play consistently in that vein.
Most of all we need hunger, something our team has been missing since 05
- Oh When the Saints
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 5621
- Joined: Wed 29 Mar 2006 4:25pm
- Location: QLD
- Contact:
We were ranked #3 last year after Round 11, and the only major change to the team is the loss of Gehrig (60 goals).
Schneider will cover 30 of those goals, and Kosi should add another 40 at least.
We also gain King in the ruck, which is an improvement to the team.
We also gain Goddard, which is a massive improvement to the team.
Ball will be fitter, and Hayes will improve.
Add to that some natural improvement from Gilbert and Armitage, and give Maxy a proper pre-season under his belt ...
There are no excuses not to be a top four side in 2008.
Schneider will cover 30 of those goals, and Kosi should add another 40 at least.
We also gain King in the ruck, which is an improvement to the team.
We also gain Goddard, which is a massive improvement to the team.
Ball will be fitter, and Hayes will improve.
Add to that some natural improvement from Gilbert and Armitage, and give Maxy a proper pre-season under his belt ...
There are no excuses not to be a top four side in 2008.
They should only play AFL games now when it's raining. Slow games of footy are so much better to watch.
- Armoooo
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 7281
- Joined: Sun 26 Nov 2006 2:28pm
- Location: The Great South East
- Contact:
The premiership!! we HAVE to do it for Harvey.
Winning the flag without him would seem hollow otherwise...
I think this year we are a lot less predictable and we have a lot more midfield options throughout the ground, we've got more quality in the ruck division which means we will no longer have to carry Rix.
It should be a good year with Goddard coming back and the continued improvement of Gram, Montagna, Dal, Gilbert and all of our other 23 and under players...
Winning the flag without him would seem hollow otherwise...
I think this year we are a lot less predictable and we have a lot more midfield options throughout the ground, we've got more quality in the ruck division which means we will no longer have to carry Rix.
It should be a good year with Goddard coming back and the continued improvement of Gram, Montagna, Dal, Gilbert and all of our other 23 and under players...
ROBERT HARVEY A.K.A The Great Man, Banger, Harves, Ol' Man River...
384 games, 4 B&F's, 3 EJ Whitten Medals, St.Kilda Captain, 2 Time Brownlow Medalist, 8 Time All Australian, 2nd Highest Brownlow votes poller.... The greatest of ALL TIME!!
384 games, 4 B&F's, 3 EJ Whitten Medals, St.Kilda Captain, 2 Time Brownlow Medalist, 8 Time All Australian, 2nd Highest Brownlow votes poller.... The greatest of ALL TIME!!
-
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2190
- Joined: Sun 28 Mar 2004 1:59pm
- Location: by the seaside..
- Has thanked: 36 times
- Been thanked: 187 times
Geelong still clearly the standout.
I personally still rate the Eagles - although losing Judd and Cousins will move them from the top rung to the 2nd rung. Collingwood probably the other team whose youngsters will continue to mature and join the Eagles on the 2nd rung.
Throw a blanket over a group fo teams for the 3rd rung - Hawthorn, Power, Swans, Saints.
The 4th rung is Bulldogs, Kangaroos, Crows, Freo, Brisbane and maybe Carlton sneaks in on the back of Judd and further maturity of Walker, Gibbs, Murphy etc.
then the final group is Essendon, Melbourne and richmond.
So, I'd be expecting a finish somewhere between 4 - 7, happy if we finished 1 -3, dissappointed in we finished 8th, and outright pi55ed off if we finish outside the 8
I personally still rate the Eagles - although losing Judd and Cousins will move them from the top rung to the 2nd rung. Collingwood probably the other team whose youngsters will continue to mature and join the Eagles on the 2nd rung.
Throw a blanket over a group fo teams for the 3rd rung - Hawthorn, Power, Swans, Saints.
The 4th rung is Bulldogs, Kangaroos, Crows, Freo, Brisbane and maybe Carlton sneaks in on the back of Judd and further maturity of Walker, Gibbs, Murphy etc.
then the final group is Essendon, Melbourne and richmond.
So, I'd be expecting a finish somewhere between 4 - 7, happy if we finished 1 -3, dissappointed in we finished 8th, and outright pi55ed off if we finish outside the 8
-
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3804
- Joined: Tue 30 May 2006 7:34pm
- Location: the new home of the saints :)
yes i do see us as a strog enough side. There is no reason that a team with the likes of Hayes, Riewoldt, Dal Santo, etc can't win a flag. We don't have any obvious weaknesses (attitude and application a possile exception), and with a year under the new coach, the side have had time to adapt to thr RL model.ben_fff wrote:So you see us as having a strong enough side to win the cup?fonz_#15 wrote:premiership. i demand we do not tolerate mediocrity, nor settle for 2nd best anymore, We need to get serious and stop being content with playing in a finals series. lift your game saints.
I think we'll be a fair chance providing Gardiner realises some of the talent he is capable of, same with King, he had a decent grand final but we'll need him to play consistently in that vein.
Most of all we need hunger, something our team has been missing since 05
it is important we focus on development of our youngsters without throwing them into the deep end at the wrong time. It is important that gilbert doesn't bulk up too much, as his pace is an asset that cannot be lost, also he lays a mean tackle so strength isn't an issue despite being skinny. I would like to see Allen, Geary, Armitage and Howard push hard for a spot this year.
We have plenty of depth, and if maxi can stay injury free, our defence is more than formiddable, with Goose and chips who can play tall also.
Kosi will be good cover for fraser at FF. he takes a great overhead mark and is good on the lead. Schneider boosts our forward stocks as well.
Gram, Fiora, Montagna are three men with pace and driving kicks that break lines, these three men need to take their game to another level in 2008.
Also there is a guy called Goddard coming back who can play a bit, however expectations need to be low in the first 8-11 rounds as it is a long road back from such a severe injury lay off.
we have a good mix of class, depth and a little bit of youth coming through, and this competition is all about having a good even mix. If the team can stay fit and decrease injuries, we should make top 4 and go on to play in a prelim at the very least.. anything else is a fail for mine.
Robert Harvey- Simply the best
- Otiman
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8780
- Joined: Thu 28 Jul 2005 11:09pm
- Location: Elsewhere
- Has thanked: 203 times
- Been thanked: 660 times
The mindset of the coaching staff, players, and everyone involved will be for a premiership. This is definitely doable from our current situation.
It will come down to a few things, such as our gamble with topping up, and some young players coming through - hopefully one of Geary, Armitage or Allen can be in our best 22. Other players such as Raph Clarke, Clint Jones, and Matt Ferguson's level of success will impact greatly on our team.
It's all about "raising the bar" from every selection from #1 to #22 on the field.
It will come down to a few things, such as our gamble with topping up, and some young players coming through - hopefully one of Geary, Armitage or Allen can be in our best 22. Other players such as Raph Clarke, Clint Jones, and Matt Ferguson's level of success will impact greatly on our team.
It's all about "raising the bar" from every selection from #1 to #22 on the field.
- yipper
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3967
- Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 8:18am
- Location: Gippsland
- Been thanked: 10 times
I am expecting a pretty exciting season in 08. We will actually be fit going into the new season - and guided by what could only be described as state of the art training / fitness team. We have bolstered the team without giving up much. The loss of Gehrig will hurt - but can be covered by a fit, confident Kossi at FF.
Several palyers would be on make or break seasons and others are expected to step up. Reckon memberships will soar on the back of another good draw and rejuvenated club administration. So- look out, I reckon we will kick some butt big time in 08.
Several palyers would be on make or break seasons and others are expected to step up. Reckon memberships will soar on the back of another good draw and rejuvenated club administration. So- look out, I reckon we will kick some butt big time in 08.
I want to stand for something. I'm a loyal person and I think at the end of my career it will be great to look back and know that I'm a St Kilda person for life.
- Nick Riewoldt. May 19th 2009.
- Nick Riewoldt. May 19th 2009.
- Gilbert The Great
- Club Player
- Posts: 330
- Joined: Sat 26 May 2007 12:34am
- Location: Melbourne
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 1636
- Joined: Wed 29 Mar 2006 5:24pm
- Location: Sunshine, Vic
We will make top four provided we stay relatively injury free. With Goddard back, the players getting more accustomed to the game plan, a decent ruck combination for a change, a 100% Ball and Lenny as well as Kosi tearing it up at FF which I'm confident he will, we are capable of returning to our 04/05 form.
Trust the Midas Touch
"My heart is at St.Kilda, I've been here seven years, I only wanted to play for them." (Fraser Gehrig, 27/11/2007)
"My heart is at St.Kilda, I've been here seven years, I only wanted to play for them." (Fraser Gehrig, 27/11/2007)
- mad saint guy
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 7087
- Joined: Tue 26 Jul 2005 9:44pm
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 52 times
- Been thanked: 367 times
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 18653
- Joined: Thu 11 Mar 2004 1:36am
- Has thanked: 1994 times
- Been thanked: 872 times
- Ghost Like
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 6562
- Joined: Wed 19 Sep 2007 10:04pm
- Has thanked: 5786 times
- Been thanked: 1909 times
I'm expecting a St Kilda side with a harder edge, one that has Ross Lyon stamped all over it. I expect the players to be all on the same page, inspired by Riewoldt, Hayes and Ball and focused on working together to achieve Lton's plan. I expect them to be more accountable, to run harder and to back each other up.
I expect them to play off in the 2008 Grand Final and I expect them to win it.
I expect them to play off in the 2008 Grand Final and I expect them to win it.
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 23247
- Joined: Sat 13 Mar 2004 11:44pm
- Has thanked: 741 times
- Been thanked: 1800 times
Top 4 - injuries will decide.
IF we get 10 to 15 games out of Gardiner/King we will be super competitive. IMO we need another 2 mids to step in this year (Harvs is the cream - NOT the saviour at 36). Dal, Lenny, Ball, Monty all up and going are class BUT for us to genuinely challenge the next rung need to step in. Gram? X Clarke? ....even a few good showings from Armo would go a long way. Guys like Jones, Sneider occasionally etc etc must inject some depth if we are to go anywhere near it.
IF we get 10 to 15 games out of Gardiner/King we will be super competitive. IMO we need another 2 mids to step in this year (Harvs is the cream - NOT the saviour at 36). Dal, Lenny, Ball, Monty all up and going are class BUT for us to genuinely challenge the next rung need to step in. Gram? X Clarke? ....even a few good showings from Armo would go a long way. Guys like Jones, Sneider occasionally etc etc must inject some depth if we are to go anywhere near it.
“Yeah….nah””
- Saints Premiers 2008
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 4335
- Joined: Thu 27 Oct 2005 11:21pm
- Location: Brisbane
- saintsRrising
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 30098
- Joined: Mon 15 Mar 2004 11:07am
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 711 times
- Been thanked: 1235 times
Current Expectations: Well bouyant at present!!!
However we have some very serious player unknowns yet that will be key on how well we can go in 2008....and this will no doubt impact on "My expectations" in say the final lead up to Round 1.
King and Gardiner
Need at least one of them to play most the year. Is Kings body right at last after being treated with cotton wool for most of 2007 withe Ctas just making sure that he would be ready for the finals.
Gardiners feet....stilla huge unknown. Will gardi ever play for the Saints??
Ball
After wanting to have at least one of Kor G...the next biggest player influence is Ball. Will his abuctor release operation restore him back to bea somewhat near his level delivereda few years back???
BJ
I am content for him to slow start and then build up late in the year. Anything more is a bonus.
Overall Injury rate
Hopefully no worse in 2007 than AFL average or thereabouts. The recent swag of new expertise in this area in securing Misson through to the AIS guys gives great hope. By the end of the pre-season competition we should have some inkling of how our injury season may unfold.
Back to now!!!
Right now my expecatations are high because even though we have lost a number of players the only one that had significant positive impact in 2007 was GTrain...and he was also the only likely player of those that have left that would have been likely to have had positive impact in 2008.
However outweighing this I would view that GTrain has been more than offset by gaining Schneider and King.....and also remember that the GTrain had been playing injured for several seasons. Kosi also presents a good ready made option fora replacement power forward.
Heading into 2008 yes BJ will most likely havea slow start......but again more than offsetting this is that Hayes, Kosi and Goose will all be 100% and firing. we saw late in the year that hayes got back to his best...anda full year from Hayes in 2008 will be very good for the Saints.
Kosi is fit....and perhaps in many ways in 2008 he will feel more at home because he will have his position. Since his first season Kosi has been basically used as a filler...playing where we had a hole.
In 2008 I think he will know from the outset that he will be given the role of being one of our two key forwards along with Roo....and so he will be able to settle into it.....to build on HIS position.
Stucture
With our recruits.....in my mind our team balance and structure just looks and feels a lot better.
King asa ruckman (Gardi would be a bonus)
Schneider to play with Milne as one of TWO small/medium forwards should help to free up Milne and create more opportunities.
One negative is that with Attard out for the year and Baker for the first 25% makes us light on for taggers.....though we have L Fisher, Dempster & Birss as good options.
The midfield is still a concern....but hopefully Ball will effectively be a new recruit. We need one of Armo, Geary or Eddie to stand up and play some good support games to help ease the load........PLUS the X-man to find a bit better polish to finish the ball off better. Harvey needs to only be playing a support role in 2008....and to not have try and carry the midfield like he did in 2007. I am expecting Joey and Fiora to continue on with their 2007 form.
raph I am just ignoring...if he can play some good consitent football then that will just bea bonus. In 2007 hedid not havea pre-season or a first hal-season....so in many ways you can not judge him on 2007 form. 2008 he will be fully fit.....so it will be up to him to deliver.
However we have some very serious player unknowns yet that will be key on how well we can go in 2008....and this will no doubt impact on "My expectations" in say the final lead up to Round 1.
King and Gardiner
Need at least one of them to play most the year. Is Kings body right at last after being treated with cotton wool for most of 2007 withe Ctas just making sure that he would be ready for the finals.
Gardiners feet....stilla huge unknown. Will gardi ever play for the Saints??
Ball
After wanting to have at least one of Kor G...the next biggest player influence is Ball. Will his abuctor release operation restore him back to bea somewhat near his level delivereda few years back???
BJ
I am content for him to slow start and then build up late in the year. Anything more is a bonus.
Overall Injury rate
Hopefully no worse in 2007 than AFL average or thereabouts. The recent swag of new expertise in this area in securing Misson through to the AIS guys gives great hope. By the end of the pre-season competition we should have some inkling of how our injury season may unfold.
Back to now!!!
Right now my expecatations are high because even though we have lost a number of players the only one that had significant positive impact in 2007 was GTrain...and he was also the only likely player of those that have left that would have been likely to have had positive impact in 2008.
However outweighing this I would view that GTrain has been more than offset by gaining Schneider and King.....and also remember that the GTrain had been playing injured for several seasons. Kosi also presents a good ready made option fora replacement power forward.
Heading into 2008 yes BJ will most likely havea slow start......but again more than offsetting this is that Hayes, Kosi and Goose will all be 100% and firing. we saw late in the year that hayes got back to his best...anda full year from Hayes in 2008 will be very good for the Saints.
Kosi is fit....and perhaps in many ways in 2008 he will feel more at home because he will have his position. Since his first season Kosi has been basically used as a filler...playing where we had a hole.
In 2008 I think he will know from the outset that he will be given the role of being one of our two key forwards along with Roo....and so he will be able to settle into it.....to build on HIS position.
Stucture
With our recruits.....in my mind our team balance and structure just looks and feels a lot better.
King asa ruckman (Gardi would be a bonus)
Schneider to play with Milne as one of TWO small/medium forwards should help to free up Milne and create more opportunities.
One negative is that with Attard out for the year and Baker for the first 25% makes us light on for taggers.....though we have L Fisher, Dempster & Birss as good options.
The midfield is still a concern....but hopefully Ball will effectively be a new recruit. We need one of Armo, Geary or Eddie to stand up and play some good support games to help ease the load........PLUS the X-man to find a bit better polish to finish the ball off better. Harvey needs to only be playing a support role in 2008....and to not have try and carry the midfield like he did in 2007. I am expecting Joey and Fiora to continue on with their 2007 form.
raph I am just ignoring...if he can play some good consitent football then that will just bea bonus. In 2007 hedid not havea pre-season or a first hal-season....so in many ways you can not judge him on 2007 form. 2008 he will be fully fit.....so it will be up to him to deliver.
Flying the World in comfort thanks to FF Points....
you never know your luck in a big city, especially with the league being pretty even these daysriccardo wrote:I think 6th.
Be realistic, we are rebuilding slightly and will probably struggle to adapt to life without Fraser, who has tended to kick the bulk of our score.
We will improve on '07 effort but if anything honestly believes we are a shot at the Flag they are too one eyed for thier own good.
however I tend to agree, Fraser, though maligned on here at times, will be a big loss, he kicks key goals, and has kept us alive in many games.
Kosi hasn't put together a four quarter game in the forward line, from memory. although 2-3 good quarters from a full forward is probably enough. his kicking at goal seemed to improve this year, and he'll need to keep that up if we are to rely on him at FF. extra pressure, extra misses?
with the right attitude in the playing group and an ok run with injuries we could go anywhere, just look at Geelong. it's really down to the playing group to play total team footy. we have the key talent, just need an even effort for a whole season (injuries a big factor in that).
my tip 6-7th but with some luck 3-5th
- BAM! (shhhh)
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2134
- Joined: Thu 24 May 2007 5:23pm
- Location: The little voice inside your head
Expectations for the Saints remain tough for me to guage. It centres around the same thing it has for the last few years.
Injuries.
While some regard this as an excuse, it will dictate the Saints final position on the ladder. Given a totally healthy list, I believe the Saints remain top 4 talent, though there are other things that could prevent them getting there - i.e. while Lyon get's benefit of the doubt in year 1, were he to have a healthy list in year 2, the pressure will be on to deliver. Should individual players dissapoint with no offsetting increase from others (like, say, age catching up with Harvey after all these years) then again the Saints are vulnerable.
Overall, with a healthy list, there's enough players to expect improvement from (Hayes - just about definate. Ball - hopefully. Maguire - just about definate. The Clarke's - hopeful. Schneider - new. King/Gardiner - new. Goddard - definate, though probably not his best) on '07 to think '08 will be a much better season. A couple of extras like an Armitage or new draftee and we're sitting pretty.
However, if there's one major strike against the Saints, it's injury prone. Kosi, King, Gardiner, the entire defense bar Fisher, Ball, and the Clarkes, that it's optomistic to say we'll finally be healthy. Then there's the general run of the mill freak injuries. The question is who, for how long, and when. And on that, the Saints will probably finish between 5th and 8th.
And from there, the question will be who's healthy for finals.
Injuries.
While some regard this as an excuse, it will dictate the Saints final position on the ladder. Given a totally healthy list, I believe the Saints remain top 4 talent, though there are other things that could prevent them getting there - i.e. while Lyon get's benefit of the doubt in year 1, were he to have a healthy list in year 2, the pressure will be on to deliver. Should individual players dissapoint with no offsetting increase from others (like, say, age catching up with Harvey after all these years) then again the Saints are vulnerable.
Overall, with a healthy list, there's enough players to expect improvement from (Hayes - just about definate. Ball - hopefully. Maguire - just about definate. The Clarke's - hopeful. Schneider - new. King/Gardiner - new. Goddard - definate, though probably not his best) on '07 to think '08 will be a much better season. A couple of extras like an Armitage or new draftee and we're sitting pretty.
However, if there's one major strike against the Saints, it's injury prone. Kosi, King, Gardiner, the entire defense bar Fisher, Ball, and the Clarkes, that it's optomistic to say we'll finally be healthy. Then there's the general run of the mill freak injuries. The question is who, for how long, and when. And on that, the Saints will probably finish between 5th and 8th.
And from there, the question will be who's healthy for finals.
"Everything comes to he who hustles while he waits"
- Henry Ford
- Henry Ford