Luke Ball or Chris Judd

[insidesource]

Who would you rather?

[Mr Magic]

What criterai?

At their best

or

Both with OP/Groin problems?

At their best you would have to say Judd

With OP/Groin problems you would have to say Ball.

[Riewoldting]

Who would you rather?

This post is so May 2006.

[Otiman]

Also, at current salaries?

[saintsrule]

bally

[i_luv_nick_riewoldt]

pfft juddy, not after the comotion from his trade and his "money issues"

Bally for me by a mile!

[super dooper]

Well we have never seen Bally's peak unfortunately and prob never will, however we have seen Judd hit the highs of performance at all levels.

So with no injuries id take Judd, we cannot kidd ourselves, he is a gun.

BUT

Bal seems to have more of a pain tolerance and still is more than effective in a team (05 B&F and all aust with the begginings of OP). Ball wouldnt sit on the bench of a final, REGARDLESS. Ball has the heart of an ox, which i admire and he plays for the jumper and the love of the club, which gets all my respect, so in my eyes i see him as a champion player, perhaps shouldnt be compared to judd considering the circumstances.

It will be interesting to see in 2 years time when Judd and Carlton has seen the long term effects of OP i think then we can have a better judge as we can see what Judd has become and what he could potentially turn into through the demise caused by OP.

[buzfromgronggrong]

Who would you rather?

In what capacity?

as a father?

as a lover?

mowing your lawn?

cutting your hair?

dating your son?

unblocking your dunny?

giving you colonic irrigation?

what??

[satchmo]

Luke Ball, he can't be bought like pratts girlfriends.

[saint66au]

You, Mr inside source, are just ITCHING to start a war about how Judd will be a gun for your precious Blues this year and Bally will limp along with OP..arent you?? Why else would you come onto a St Kilda website and ask that question??

Well heres some advice...dont...OK???

[F_Q_F]

Who would you rather?

In what capacity?

as a lover?

Bally cause he'd like the tough stuff

[saintsRrising]

Who would you rather?

Stupid question froma stupid poster.

Well isn't obvious... Ball....

For if you are not wearing the Red , White and Black....you just do not matter.

[The_Dud]

the supporters of 15 clubs will say Judd hands down, the supporters of the one other club will be torn by their alligance to Ball

Judd is a better player than Ball, no doubt about it

[stinger]

Who would you rather?

as i said on another post a few days ago, you carscum troll.....the original draft order was absolutely correct...hodge, ball, judd....there is no contest as far as the saints are concerned....judd is an arrogant, mercenary prick...ball is a fine young man...all three are fantastic footballers.....

[plugger66]

Who would you rather?

as i said on another post a few days ago, you carscum troll.....the original draft order was absolutely correct...hodge, ball, judd....there is no contest as far as the saints are concerned....judd is an arrogant, mercenary prick...ball is a fine young man...all three are fantastic footballers.....

If we had drafted Judd we would have won a flag but who cares we got the better person.

[stinger]

Who would you rather?

as i said on another post a few days ago, you carscum troll.....the original draft order was absolutely correct...hodge, ball, judd....there is no contest as far as the saints are concerned....judd is an arrogant, mercenary prick...ball is a fine young man...all three are fantastic footballers.....

If we had drafted Judd we would have won a flag but who cares we got the better person.

geez...that crystal ball of yours must really be something.....

[satchmo]

Who would you rather?

as i said on another post a few days ago, you carscum troll.....the original draft order was absolutely correct...hodge, ball, judd....there is no contest as far as the saints are concerned....judd is an arrogant, mercenary prick...ball is a fine young man...all three are fantastic footballers.....

If we had drafted Judd we would have won a flag but who cares we got the better person.

So carlton just bought the flag oh well no point in buying a membership next year thanks for your input.

[plugger66]

Who would you rather?

as i said on another post a few days ago, you carscum troll.....the original draft order was absolutely correct...hodge, ball, judd....there is no contest as far as the saints are concerned....judd is an arrogant, mercenary prick...ball is a fine young man...all three are fantastic footballers.....

If we had drafted Judd we would have won a flag but who cares we got the better person.

So carlton just bought the flag oh well no point in buying a membership next year thanks for your input.

Thats right Carlton finished 3rd 2 years in row didnt they.

[stinger]

i forgot to ask......which year would we have won that premiership....


...bahahahahahahahah.........

[satchmo]

Who would you rather?

as i said on another post a few days ago, you carscum troll.....the original draft order was absolutely correct...hodge, ball, judd....there is no contest as far as the saints are concerned....judd is an arrogant, mercenary prick...ball is a fine young man...all three are fantastic footballers.....

If we had drafted Judd we would have won a flag but who cares we got the better person.

So carlton just bought the flag oh well no point in buying a membership next year thanks for your input.

Thats right Carlton finished 3rd 2 years in row didnt they.

Well you wouldn't say it if it wasnt true would you.

[F_Q_F]

Hindsight is 20/20, however I have no problem with the choice the Saints made. Luke Ball is a quality player, leader and person.

Comparing players like this is just pointless, it doesn't change anything and its not just the Judd-Ball-Hodge argument it could relate to any players in the draft. You can't tell what will happen to a player 5 years down the track, you have to take a chance and hope it pays off.

[plugger66]

Hindsight is 20/20, however I have no problem with the choice the Saints made. Luke Ball is a quality player, leader and person.

Comparing players like this is just pointless, it doesn't change anything and its not just the Judd-Ball-Hodge argument it could relate to any players in the draft. You can't tell what will happen to a player 5 years down the track, you have to take a chance and hope it pays off.

I agree completely. But when the question is asked I think we need to be honest. But I am with you. We have Bally. A great guy and a very good player.

[satchmo]

We have Bally. A great guy and a very good player.

Hooray, we agree !

[Ball_Breaker]

Bluebagger, who would YOU prefer - Brendon Goddard or Daniel Wells?

[stinger]

Bluebagger, who would YOU prefer - Brendon Goddard or Daniel Wells?

lmfao......