Trade Week (Updated - Mattner to Swans 4:40pm Tues)

SaintBot · Post: # 471609Post **SaintBot** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:05am

All articles and rumours here.

Confirmed trades or official rumours involving St Kilda deserve their own thread.

Started 5 minutes ago.

super dooper · Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:09am

Couldnt imagine much happening today, never does, prob just more rumours

Cant wait till thursday however when it all happens in the last hour before 2pm, i have a 2 hour break between classes then, so i think ill have one eye on a computer in that time

SaintBot · Post: # 471614Post **SaintBot** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:10am

super dooper wrote:Couldnt imagine much happening today, never does, prob just more rumours

rumour has is it that the Judd deal will be finalised today or tomorrow

fisher_fan · Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:13am

waiting with baited breath to see who we make a play for, if anyone....

B W and R all over · Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:13am

SaintBot wrote:
super dooper wrote:Couldnt imagine much happening today, never does, prob just more rumours
rumour has is it that the Judd deal will be finalised today or tomorrow

I'd be surprised since West Coast and Carlton seem to have very different ideas about what is appropriate compensation.

But they may just steer through the bullsh1t and realise it is best for all concerned to get it over and done with asap.

SaintBot · Post: # 471619Post **SaintBot** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:15am

B W and R all over wrote:
SaintBot wrote:
super dooper wrote:Couldnt imagine much happening today, never does, prob just more rumours
rumour has is it that the Judd deal will be finalised today or tomorrow
I'd be surprised since West Coast and Carlton seem to have very different ideas about what is appropriate compensation.

But they may just steer through the bullsh1t and realise it is best for all concerned to get it over and done with asap.

im pretty sure west coast are going to be more lenient. carlton wouldve reminded them of a deal they could do with richmond.

also i expect to see Brad Miller end up a Swan before Wednesday.

Carl Mynott · Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:16am

I think there has been a public stance and a much different private stance between the Weagles and the paper baggers regarding Judd's trade.....

That's why the Judd deal will go through quicker than expected......

fisher_fan · Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:22am

hudson will be a dog before the end of the day, maybe damon white aswell. mcmahon may end up at port for white.

i would think swans, dogs and demons will be the most active this week. maybe the tigers....carlton would be to if they dont drag out the judd trade.

claystreet · Mon 08 Oct 2007 11:30am

Wonder what Juddy thinks of Dicks big fine for dishonesty and fixing prices

yup Carlscum the honest family club

Armoooo · Post: # 471684Post **Armoooo** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 1:29pm

fisher_fan wrote:hudson will be a dog before the end of the day

He's walking out on the club that gave him a chance he probably didn't deserve, he already is a dog

Oh When the Saints · Mon 08 Oct 2007 2:41pm

The only-father son bid was for Darcy Daniher by North, who offered their 3rd round pick.

The Bombers chose to match this offer, and are now committed to taking him with their 3rd round pick.

Oh When the Saints · Mon 08 Oct 2007 3:12pm

Tim Boyle from the Hawks is attracting a lot of interest, and it looks like they might trade him for the right deal.

Hudson will go to the Dogs, and it looks like Damon White will shift across to the Dogs too, with Jordan McMahon and possibly Steven Tiller going the other way.

Saints interested in Steven King apparently

Judd deal could be announced tomorrow morning and involve Essendon.

All rumours though!!

Dan Warna · Post: # 471715Post **Dan Warna** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 3:21pm

Oh When the Saints wrote:
Saints interested in Steven King apparently

All rumours though!!

thats a worry if there is truth in the rumour.

going for 1 season players ...

SaintBot · Post: # 471717Post **SaintBot** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 3:23pm

Dan Warna wrote:
Oh When the Saints wrote:
Saints interested in Steven King apparently

All rumours though!!
thats a worry if there is truth in the rumour.

going for 1 season players ...

gee i hope if we get him its for absouletely nothing...if we give up a third or earlier pick for him we are a disgrace

Oh When the Saints · Mon 08 Oct 2007 3:25pm

Don't think we will ... John Peake (our recruiting mananger) summed up our list well when he said we are at the stage where drafting is the way to go, not trading or recruiting.

Fresh Prince · Mon 08 Oct 2007 3:57pm

how is esendon involved in a trade with west coast for judd? are they giving up their pick 6?

saintsRrising · Mon 08 Oct 2007 3:58pm

Oh When the Saints wrote:

Judd deal could be announced tomorrow morning and involve Essendon.

All rumours though!!

Looks like someone been ready BigFooty

But with the funeral in WA today it was never likely that any deal involving WC would be announced today...that would just be tacky.

plugger66 · Post: # 471736Post **plugger66** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 4:12pm

I have heard that Schnieder is on the table. Would be a good fit for the saints. I think a second round would be a good swap.

i_luv_nick_riewoldt · Mon 08 Oct 2007 4:14pm

any ideas y schnieder would be wanting to come to victoria?
yea i think he sounds like a good pik up if we were able to snag him!

Oh When the Saints · Mon 08 Oct 2007 4:14pm

Agree, Schneider would be a good fit. Only 23 years old and has played 100 games. Would give us pace and pressure through the forwardline.

I'm sure Rossy knows him well ... would be surprised if the Swans let him go cheaply though. Had his best season this year.

Would give up pick #26 + Barry Brooks.

Fresh Prince · Mon 08 Oct 2007 4:29pm

Getting sneider would be great but as if sydney would want brookes. He can't even get a game with St Kilda let alone the Swans. I still don't understand how he manages to stay on our list

Little Dozer · Mon 08 Oct 2007 4:30pm

Oh When the Saints wrote:Agree, Schneider would be a good fit. Only 23 years old and has played 100 games. Would give us pace and pressure through the forwardline.

I'm sure Rossy knows him well ... would be surprised if the Swans let him go cheaply though. Had his best season this year.

Would give up pick #26 + Barry Brooks.

How generous of you!

evertonfc · Post: # 471753Post **evertonfc** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 4:30pm

Just a heads up on Schneider - he's very very highly valued.

Sydney have an abundance of what we need - the one who is on the market will be Buchanon. They'll be looking for a good second round pick.

With Malceski, Kennelly, O'Keefe and Schneider on their list already, there's definitely scope for Sydney to trade one of them away. Buchanon is probably the one most likely to leave given a) he's a Victorian, b) he's been in and out of the team and c) he did a few things this year which saw him drop in the pecking order discipline wise.

However, he just needs a club to play him as a first-choice flanker with the capacity to play up forward or down back with time on the ball. He can do it, and he can do it well. I'm certain he'd blossom with us.

If we can use our Pick 26 to get him, I'd be delighted.

Armoooo · Post: # 471754Post **Armoooo** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 4:31pm

Fresh Prince wrote:Getting sneider would be great but as if sydney would want brookes. He can't even get a game with St Kilda let alone the Swans. I still don't understand how he manages to stay on our list

Yeah and Sydney have always had a bad record with recruiting their FFs from St.Kilda aswell....

SaintBot · Post: # 471758Post **SaintBot** » Mon 08 Oct 2007 4:34pm

everton if we managed to lure Amon Buchanan to St Kilda that would be a terrific get for us as long as we can hold onto pick 9.

He would fit right into our 1st 22.

Trade Week (Updated - Mattner to Swans 4:40pm Tues)

Trade Week (Updated - Mattner to Swans 4:40pm Tues)

essendon

brooks

Re: brooks