Judd- are we any chance?

[cwrcyn]

A scenario that's almost plausible:


Goddard to Carlton for pick 3.


Picks 3 & 9 on-traded to West Coast for Judd

[saintsRrising]

A scenario that's almost plausible:


Goddard to Carlton for pick 3.


Picks 3 & 9 on-traded to West Coast for Judd

Except for the MAJOR flaw that the Blues want Juddy for themselves....



Only way it could happen would be IF Judd came out and stated that the saints were the only club that he would go to.

[RooandKosi]

Both Clarke Brothers, pick 9 and 1,000,000 to get judd

Thats fair i reckon and I would go for it. Yes it suks losing what i believe is an all australian half back in the making (raph) but this is judd CHRIS JUDD!!!

The guy wins games kicks goals gets 30 possis

Imagine Hayes, Judd, Dal Santo as our centrebounce line up for the next 5 years!

I reckon he's off to ewither melbourne or collingwood.

[saintsRrising]

Both Clarke Brothers, pick 9 and 1,000,000 to get judd

Thats fair i reckon and I would go for it. Yes it suks losing what i believe is an all australian half back in the making (raph) but this is judd CHRIS JUDD!!!

The guy wins games kicks goals gets 30 possis

Imagine Hayes, Judd, Dal Santo as our centrebounce line up for the next 5 years!

I reckon he's off to ewither melbourne or collingwood.

Hypothetically...that at least has the advantage that both are not Vic boys ad that the NT is just as close to WA as to Vic....and that there is no "home" AFDL team in NT.



Then again both the Clarkes barracked for the Saints as kids...

[SaintDippa]

cwrcyn,we would want a heap more than pick 3 for BJ.

[Spinner]

1. There are heaps of topics of Judd on this forum already

2. Gilbert's a star if we trade him i will be pissed of

3. We have a chance of snaring him but i dont really see us getting him with Carlton in the way

Gilbert is a long way off being a star

had a good year just needs to keep improving and consolidate next year

Gilbert is a star thats my opinion

What is Judd then?


The term "Star" is used way too loosely.

[Spinner]

Goddard was a number 1 pick....and more of a KPP in which will obviously take more time.


Judd is not worth Goddard and Number 9.

[Behind Play]

I realise Judd is a champion and would love to have him at our club, but why are we trying to eat our own. BJ is one of ours and I believe is an intricate part of the saints moving forward with Judd.

[SaintDippa]

Inclined to keep out of the Judd chase. Two shoulder ops by 18 and dodgy groin will be tested on the flint hard Telstra Dome.

Too risky to give up #9 and any top 22 player.

[wildgoose]

A scenario that's almost plausible:


Goddard to Carlton for pick 3.


Picks 3 & 9 on-traded to West Coast for Judd

As much as I would hate losing BJ, having one of the best players in the game would ease that hurt. The next few weeks will be interesting.

[St Igmata]

Realistically people,
Roo on 1.2 million.
Judd on 1.2 million.
Hamill on 500k +

36 other players on the list- aboiut 3.4 million.
Thats about 100k a man.

I think wishful .

[Saints43]

Surely all that needs to happen is for Judd to say "I want to play for St Kilda".

WC then decide wether to accept pick 9 or lose him for nothing. I can only remember Port doing this with Stevens. Hall, Lockett, Black have all told St Kilda who to deal with.

We then pay him Gehrig's wages, half of Max's (vetrans list) which should come somewhere close to making him happy... and a job at wherever as a wages collector.

[n1ck]

Roo is on 800 i thought, Judd would be on about the same.

[Saints94]

Roo is on 800 i thought, Judd would be on about the same.

around that area nick

[fonz_#15]

Roo is on 800 i thought, Judd would be on about the same.

seems a more realistic figure.

[Spinner]

Realistically people,
Roo on 1.2 million.
Judd on 1.2 million.
Hamill on 500k +

36 other players on the list- aboiut 3.4 million.
Thats about 100k a man.

I think wishful .

Exactly. No player is woprth 1 million....Until the salary cap increaese by more than 300%.


It would be pretty tough standing next to teammates earning that figure, when it is cutting deep into their pockets.

[Spinner]

Surely all that needs to happen is for Judd to say "I want to play for St Kilda".

WC then decide wether to accept pick 9 or lose him for nothing. I can only remember Port doing this with Stevens. Hall, Lockett, Black have all told St Kilda who to deal with.

We then pay him Gehrig's wages, half of Max's (vetrans list) which should come somewhere close to making him happy... and a job at wherever as a wages collector.

EXACTLY


All this bulls*** about the front runners......Carlton Collingwood.....blah blah.


The front runners will be the team Judd nominates.

[St Igmata]

Roo is on 800 i thought, Judd would be on about the same.

Including promotional and marketing he is on 1.2 million.
Judd will be on the same with any club he joins.
They dont care if its inside the TPP or outside (Promotion and marketing ) but it will have to be 1.2 mill.
On memory promotion and marketing is under 400k.

[Spinner]

Roo is on 800 i thought, Judd would be on about the same.

Including promotional and marketing he is on 1.2 million.
Judd will be on the same with any club he joins.
They dont care if its inside the TPP or outside (Promotion and marketing ) but it will have to be 1.2 mill.
On memory promotion and marketing is under 400k.

Only the salary cap figure is of importance.


They can earn a trillion in Marketing for all I care.

[St Igmata]

Surely all that needs to happen is for Judd to say "I want to play for St Kilda".

WC then decide wether to accept pick 9 or lose him for nothing. I can only remember Port doing this with Stevens. Hall, Lockett, Black have all told St Kilda who to deal with.

We then pay him Gehrig's wages, half of Max's (vetrans list) which should come somewhere close to making him happy... and a job at wherever as a wages collector.

EXACTLY


All this bulls*** about the front runners......Carlton Collingwood.....blah blah.


The front runners will be the team Judd nominates.

Spinner,
Collingwood is first preference with Carlton being second.
The others are not relevant unless a deal cannot be facilitated.
Essendon and Melbourne are non issues as far as Judd is concerened. Its an exercise.

[Spinner]

Surely all that needs to happen is for Judd to say "I want to play for St Kilda".

WC then decide wether to accept pick 9 or lose him for nothing. I can only remember Port doing this with Stevens. Hall, Lockett, Black have all told St Kilda who to deal with.

We then pay him Gehrig's wages, half of Max's (vetrans list) which should come somewhere close to making him happy... and a job at wherever as a wages collector.

EXACTLY


All this bulls*** about the front runners......Carlton Collingwood.....blah blah.


The front runners will be the team Judd nominates.

Spinner,
Collingwood is first preference with Carlton being second.
The others are not relevant unless a deal cannot be facilitated.
Essendon and Melbourne are non issues as far as Judd is concerened. Its an exercise.

Has Judd sat down with those clubs and decided already?

Oh OK. He hasnt.

Judd will nominate his team. Or teams. WCE will trade accordingly.

And if it becomes extremely messey (and i mean extremely, cos Judd will try his best not to f*** over WCE) he will go into the draft to Richmond.

[St Igmata]

Roo is on 800 i thought, Judd would be on about the same.

Including promotional and marketing he is on 1.2 million.
Judd will be on the same with any club he joins.
They dont care if its inside the TPP or outside (Promotion and marketing ) but it will have to be 1.2 mill.
On memory promotion and marketing is under 400k.

Only the salary cap figure is of importance.


They can earn a trillion in Marketing for all I care.

You should care!
The TPP have a component which is bolted on for promotion and marketing. Its around 300k.
That has already been engaged. Totally!
Any further payments are inside the cap.

[n1ck]

And you know this how, exactly?

Judd has said he wants to go to a club with a chance of success.

Tell me how Carlton would therefore be his second choice?

Collingwood I can understand. They have the money and a side in the last 4 of the competition. They dont have draft picks.

Carlton have the draft picks and the money, but not a good side.

[St Igmata]

Surely all that needs to happen is for Judd to say "I want to play for St Kilda".

WC then decide wether to accept pick 9 or lose him for nothing. I can only remember Port doing this with Stevens. Hall, Lockett, Black have all told St Kilda who to deal with.

We then pay him Gehrig's wages, half of Max's (vetrans list) which should come somewhere close to making him happy... and a job at wherever as a wages collector.

EXACTLY


All this bulls*** about the front runners......Carlton Collingwood.....blah blah.


The front runners will be the team Judd nominates.

Spinner,
Collingwood is first preference with Carlton being second.
The others are not relevant unless a deal cannot be facilitated.
Essendon and Melbourne are non issues as far as Judd is concerened. Its an exercise.

Has Judd sat down with those clubs and decided already?

Oh OK. He hasnt.

Judd will nominate his team. Or teams. WCE will trade accordingly.

And if it becomes extremely messey (and i mean extremely, cos Judd will try his best not to f*** over WCE) he will go into the draft to Richmond.

May i ask how old you are?
Judd has nominated his preferences to his manager and to WC.
His club would prefer to deal with Carlton because they have the picks WC need.

[n1ck]

Again - I ask how you know his preference is Collingwood.