Judd- are we any chance?

Saints Premiers 2008 · Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:31pm

homework wrote:
Saints Premiers 2006 wrote:
homework wrote:1. There are heaps of topics of Judd on this forum already

2. Gilbert's a star if we trade him i will be pissed of

3. We have a chance of snaring him but i dont really see us getting him with Carlton in the way

4. Hamill wont retire he has another 1-2 years left in him
1. so??? he's the best playing in the comp when fit
2. no he's not...he has amazing potential...nothing near a star
3. no we don't unless we ontrade picks and get involved somehow...
4. are you a doctor???

ffs think before you post such rubbish
im aloud to post what i think

1. speak english
2. stop posting what you think...its crap

Beekay · Post: # 457937Post **Beekay** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:33pm

Judd seems like a decent bloke. He will lose his soul if he goes to Carlton or Collingwood.

Hopefully he would be happy at the Demons or the Tigers.

Roos and Dogs are fighting for survival.

Hawthorn a massive chance.

Saints94 · Post: # 457939Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:33pm

Saints Premiers 2006 wrote:
homework wrote:
Saints Premiers 2006 wrote:
homework wrote:1. There are heaps of topics of Judd on this forum already

2. Gilbert's a star if we trade him i will be pissed of

3. We have a chance of snaring him but i dont really see us getting him with Carlton in the way

4. Hamill wont retire he has another 1-2 years left in him
1. so??? he's the best playing in the comp when fit
2. no he's not...he has amazing potential...nothing near a star
3. no we don't unless we ontrade picks and get involved somehow...
4. are you a doctor???

ffs think before you post such rubbish
im aloud to post what i think
1. speak english
2. stop posting what you think...its crap

or what

stinger · Post: # 457940Post **stinger** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:34pm

homework wrote:
Saints Premiers 2006 wrote:
homework wrote:1. There are heaps of topics of Judd on this forum already

2. Gilbert's a star if we trade him i will be pissed of

3. We have a chance of snaring him but i dont really see us getting him with Carlton in the way

4. Hamill wont retire he has another 1-2 years left in him
1. so??? he's the best playing in the comp when fit
2. no he's not...he has amazing potential...nothing near a star
3. no we don't unless we ontrade picks and get involved somehow...
4. are you a doctor???

ffs think before you post such rubbish
im aloud to post what i think

that's "allowed" homework...aloud is how you do your thinking.....

Saints94 · Post: # 457941Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:37pm

stinger wrote:
homework wrote:
Saints Premiers 2006 wrote:
homework wrote:1. There are heaps of topics of Judd on this forum already

2. Gilbert's a star if we trade him i will be pissed of

3. We have a chance of snaring him but i dont really see us getting him with Carlton in the way

4. Hamill wont retire he has another 1-2 years left in him
1. so??? he's the best playing in the comp when fit
2. no he's not...he has amazing potential...nothing near a star
3. no we don't unless we ontrade picks and get involved somehow...
4. are you a doctor???

ffs think before you post such rubbish
im aloud to post what i think

that's "allowed" homework...aloud is how you do your thinking.....

thanks again for corecting me wrong!

Post: # 457947Post **n1ck** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:54pm

stinger wrote:
that's "allowed" homework...aloud is how you do your thinking.....

roffel.

Beno88 · Post: # 457974Post **Beno88** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:25pm

Judd should come to the saints, then he'll never have to play on baker again.

Saints94 · Post: # 457977Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:26pm

Beno88 wrote:Judd should come to the saints, then he'll never have to play on baker again.

and so should ablett

Mr Magic · Post: # 457978Post **Mr Magic** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:28pm

Beno88 wrote:Judd should come to the saints, then he'll never have to play on baker again.

He doesn't have to now anyway. The AFL ensure that each year he is rubbed out on some BS charge until our game against WCE has been.

Beno88 · Post: # 457979Post **Beno88** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:29pm

i guess the AFL will ensure we play Carlton inside the first 5 rounds in 08 then....

Mr Magic · Post: # 457980Post **Mr Magic** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:30pm

Beno88 wrote:i guess the AFL will ensure we play Carlton inside the first 5 rounds in 08 then....

That may be 1 side-benefit of Judd not playing for WCE anymore - no need for an early trip to Perth for us next year.

Saints94 · Post: # 457981Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:32pm

Mr Magic wrote:
Beno88 wrote:i guess the AFL will ensure we play Carlton inside the first 5 rounds in 08 then....
That may be i side-benefit of Judd not playing for WCE anymore - no need for an early trip to Perth for us next year.

lets hope that collingwood gets 2 games at perth 2 games at adelaid 1 game at launceston 1 game at carrara and in the last 6 weeks they shouldnt be all home games

GrumpyOne · Post: # 457982Post **GrumpyOne** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:34pm

homework wrote:
Mr Magic wrote:
Beno88 wrote:i guess the AFL will ensure we play Carlton inside the first 5 rounds in 08 then....
That may be i side-benefit of Judd not playing for WCE anymore - no need for an early trip to Perth for us next year.
lets hope that collingwood gets 2 games at perth 2 games at adelaid 1 game at launceston 1 game at carrara and in the last 6 weeks they shouldnt be all home games

Fat chance - proven crowd pullers.

Saints94 · Post: # 457985Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:37pm

GrumpyOne wrote:
homework wrote:
Mr Magic wrote:
Beno88 wrote:i guess the AFL will ensure we play Carlton inside the first 5 rounds in 08 then....
That may be i side-benefit of Judd not playing for WCE anymore - no need for an early trip to Perth for us next year.
lets hope that collingwood gets 2 games at perth 2 games at adelaid 1 game at launceston 1 game at carrara and in the last 6 weeks they shouldnt be all home games
Fat chance - proven crowd pullers.

Collingwood are such sooks

terry smith rules · Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:42pm

I think Judd would be a huge gamble at a ridiculous price.

He is a great player but his biggest asset is pace , and pace is what is affected by whatever injury he has. We don't know if he will ever regain that pace.

He does not have the step of a ablett or harvey or dal.

So really I hope he does get back to his best, but at the moment he is a gamble.

Saints94 · Post: # 457993Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:44pm

terry smith rules wrote:I think Judd would be a huge gamble at a ridiculous price.

He is a great player but his biggest asset is pace , and pace is what is affected by whatever injury he has. We don't know if he will ever regain that pace.

He does not have the step of a ablett or harvey or dal.

So really I hope he does get back to his best, but at the moment he is a gamble.

We dont really have a pacy midfielder like a Judd so lets bid for him take a punt!

Bevan Shorluey · Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:46pm

Quote Mark Robinson on SEN:

"Why would Judd go to a basket-case like St Kilda"

Saints94 · Post: # 457998Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:50pm

Bevan Shorluey wrote:Quote Mark Robinson on SEN:

"Why would Judd go to a basket-case like St Kilda"

He's the one thats the "Basket-case"

Beekay · Post: # 458000Post **Beekay** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 3:52pm

You tell him, homie!

Seaford_Saint · Mon 17 Sep 2007 4:35pm

HOMEWORK - your 'allowed' to do what??

Saints94 · Post: # 458047Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 4:37pm

Seaford_Saint wrote:HOMEWORK - your 'allowed' to do what??

what do u mean?

jack · Post: # 458057Post **jack** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 5:00pm

Bevan Shorluey wrote:Quote Mark Robinson on SEN:

"Why would Judd go to a basket-case like St Kilda"

He was reading an SMS message that came in from an un named listener.

Little Dozer · Mon 17 Sep 2007 5:14pm

aloud? You obviously didn't do your homework!

Gabba · Post: # 458061Post **Gabba** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 5:15pm

Beno88 wrote:Judd should come to the saints, then he'll never have to play on baker again.

Hell, if i was an opposition player i wouldn't want to play on Bakes.

Judd will not come to Saints.

If i were in his position i would be very happy with Hawthorn.

Hope to hell he doesn't go to the Filth.

Saints Premiers 2008 · Mon 17 Sep 2007 5:23pm

homework wrote:
terry smith rules wrote:I think Judd would be a huge gamble at a ridiculous price.

He is a great player but his biggest asset is pace , and pace is what is affected by whatever injury he has. We don't know if he will ever regain that pace.

He does not have the step of a ablett or harvey or dal.

So really I hope he does get back to his best, but at the moment he is a gamble.
We dont really have a pacy midfielder like a Judd so lets bid for him take a punt!

yes...lets take a 1.2 million dollar punt + our first rounder + anyone and everyone who wants to swap teams in search of immediate success

you truly are the basket case