Membrey on the outs!!??

[B.M]

We are getting games into them

In the VFL because they are not ready for AFL yet

They’ll get picked when they’re good enough

[Saints58]

I really want him to stay because of his height, body strength and form ....

I would love him to stay as well but he is not tall at 188cm is the smallest of the big forwards Owens 191cm sharman 193cm and Caminiti 196cm king 202cm then there are the small forwards in Butler and Higgins so Unfortunately I don't see where he fits do we drop one of the the other forwards, when they need to play. King should play CHF it would allow the forward line to be a lot more open for the the other forwards.

[SaintPav]

If Darling goes to Norf doubt they would be interested too much in Membrey.

Richo sniffing around again though.

Idiot forced Hickey to play injured.

Is he responsible for doing the same to Petracca?

[SaintPav]

[B.M]

When did AR ‘force Hickey to play injured FFS

wtf would he have had to do with Petracca going back on the ground?!

Is Richo also responsible for Climate Change and starting Covid?

I mean seriously?!

[Yorkeys]

When did AR ‘force Hickey to play injured FFS

wtf would he have had to do with Petracca going back on the ground?!

Is Richo also responsible for Climate Change and starting Covid?

I mean seriously?!

Richo is highly unlikely to survive the external/internal review Dee's are arranging and apparently no one is responsible for Petracca going back on, the line seems to be he wanted to play on, who are we to stop him, told Dr he was good to go, what can a qualified practitioner do other than respect the patient's wishes...

[B.M]

Look at the obvious symptoms and overruled him

Doctor fkd up

Should be sacked

[magnifisaint]

Look at the obvious symptoms and overruled him

Doctor fkd up

Should be sacked

Youll find that the doctors are under pressure from the coaches. Goodwin has form on this.

[MickThomas]

Look at the obvious symptoms and overruled him

Doctor fkd up

Should be sacked

Youll find that the doctors are under pressure from the coaches. Goodwin has form on this.

Joe Gutnick has publicly stated that he talks to a lot of Dees members and '100% of the supporters I've spoken to, say Goodwin should be moved on'

since when do supporters or members have enough inside knowledge of a club to be trusted with an opinion?

I watch a bit of Formula 1, but I wouldn't be qualified to say 'boot Alonso and give his seat to Ricciardo'

[TimeToShineFellas]

Reported 4 hours ago, Membrey linked to Hawthorn (2nd last player mentioned)

Can't they just leave us alone?

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/09/18/ ... -at-hawks/

[SaintWiki]

I really want him to stay because of his height, body strength and form ....

I would love him to stay as well but he is not tall at 188cm is the smallest of the big forwards Owens 191cm sharman 193cm and Caminiti 196cm king 202cm then there are the small forwards in Butler and Higgins so Unfortunately I don't see where he fits do we drop one of the the other forwards, when they need to play. King should play CHF it would allow the forward line to be a lot more open for the the other forwards.

He playes tall and I'd give him another year.

[SAINT-LEE]

There's some scuttlebutt re: Sam Frost <> Membrey trade deal.

I cant find any media sources saying this, anyone heard anything?

[Yorkeys]

Seems Norf prefer Darling.
Tim doesn't have many options.
If he stays he is likely to play mainly VFL?

[SAINT-LEE]

There's some scuttlebutt re: Sam Frost <> Membrey trade deal.

I cant find any media sources saying this, anyone heard anything?

Just found afl bit saying we are interested in Frost.

Docker set for deal, Saint signs on, Dog gets offer amid rival interest - https://www.afl.com.au/news/1223072

[Beno88]

Can't stand Frost. One of those players who always has his arms out complaining to umpires or teammates.Very average with ball in hand too.

[B.M]

What makes Tim Membrey a good leader?

Interested to know?

[SaintPav]

When did AR ‘force Hickey to play injured FFS

wtf would he have had to do with Petracca going back on the ground?!

Is Richo also responsible for Climate Change and starting Covid?

I mean seriously?!

[B.M]

Frost is fkn hopeless

[saynta]

Frost is fkn hopeless

I 100% agree with you.

[SaintPav]

Rory Atkins is available

[WellardSaint]

Frost is fkn hopeless

I 100% agree with you.

2024 average disposals 9.2
Average AF points 37.7

and he's 31 y.o.

hard pass from this old grumpy dude

[B.M]

Almost the worst (consistently played) AFL player