If Battle goes Membrey stays?

[older saint]

As it looks like Battle is out the door my thinking is that will see Membrey stay with Cama becoming a CHB.

Cama looked solid in his small exposure to defence and has good size and athleticism to play that role. Membrey has been really important in the second part of the year and with King's uncertain body he is the perfect foil. Sharman has developed well this year but IMO Keeler is not ready yet, Allison likely gone and heath is a ruck who continues to need work.

Howard, Wilkie Cama is a solid tall back 3.
Shoemakers kicks a long ball but has a bit of work to do on the defensive side to his game.

thoughts

[The_Dud]

I think Membrey has earnt another go next year regardless, his late season form has been good.

I don't think Caminiti showed anything when he went back, I'd be worried if he was to replace Battle.

Losing Battle (our number 2, or even 1B) defender is going to sting next year, and for the next 5 after that.

[remboy]

Especially if Hayes is moved on. We’ll need some experience to play with the kids.

[magnifisaint]

Play King at CHB for a season. He will blossom.

[Big Max]

Heard a rumor that Tim has been offered a 3 year deal from a rival club.

Reliable source .. not exactly .. but a rumor.

[SaintPav]

That would have to be Norf.

3 years is a silly offer if true

[mad saint guy]

Kicking 14.3 in the final 6 games should get him a new contract

[Moods]

Members played great last 6 games.