Changes vs Carlton

[nostalgicsaint]

Out: Hill (inj), Cammaniti (inj)
In: Pou, Heath/Keeler

Dow to sub.

[skeptic]

Out: Hill (inj), Cammaniti (inj)
In: Pou, Heath/Keeler

Dow to sub.

I give that a big like but has to be Keeler at this stage

[B.M]

Love to see Keels debut

[Killa]

OUT Caminiti (injured)

IN Phillipou (Recovered)

No one at VFL level today put their hand up.

The opportunity was there but it was not taken.

[The Fireman]

If we lose to Carlton that should keep the skunks out of the finals

I will enjoy some solace either way

[nostalgicsaint]

OUT Caminiti (injured)

IN Phillipou (Recovered)

No one at VFL level today put their hand up.

The opportunity was there but it was not taken.

Given Hill is likely to miss it will be someone.

Perhaps Hastie.

[skeptic]

I get that no one has put there hand up today…
But Keeler has steadily improved and is now in a position to play as a rotating ruck predominant forward with Marshall.

Let’s get a look at it

[bakes]

Yes it has to be Keeler for Caminiti. Time to get a look at the boy.

Philipou or Hastie come in for B Hill.

[chook23]

If we lose to Carlton that should keep the skunks out of the finals

I will enjoy some solace either way

Skunks CAN NOT make it now

[The Fireman]

If we lose to Carlton that should keep the skunks out of the finals

I will enjoy some solace either way

Skunks CAN NOT make it now

Cool now we can smash the cheats

But what if we do and the skunks beat melb by a big margin ?

[silverhalo]

And can we please finally give our boy Hugo a full game!

[Bin Chicken]

It would be awesome to beat the scum and Freo win, thus knocking the Scum out of the finals. The filth have to hope we win, Freo lose and they flog Dee’s by a truckload to get in.

Actually just checked - filth would need to win by 200 points lol

But seeing Carlscum miss would be sublime!!

[spert]

Apart from two injury outs, the same team, so who comes in? Looking at Sandy yesterday, practically nobody put their hand up for selection, in fact the only Sandy Saint who really played their guts out was Campbell, and a reasonable effort from McLennan who will probably come back in. I don't think Lyon would have been over the moon at what he saw.

[Beno88]

In : Campbell, Phillipou

Out : Caminiti, Hill

Garcia in the 22, Dow sub.

[Bernard Shakey]

Out: Hill (inj), Cammaniti (inj)
In: Pou, Heath/Keeler

Dow to sub.

I give that a big like but has to be Keeler at this stage

Keeler did nothing at Sandy yesterday.

[skeptic]

Out: Hill (inj), Cammaniti (inj)
In: Pou, Heath/Keeler

Dow to sub.

I give that a big like but has to be Keeler at this stage

Keeler did nothing at Sandy yesterday.

I get that but overall he’s been improving considerably and had been in decent form prior to this match.

We’ve now lost a tall forward that acted as the relief ruck that is the exact role that we’re pbly wanting from Keeler and we’re playing in a game that means nothing to us.

Personally I’d role the dice here and have a look at the Marshall/Keeler combo that we’re hoping for

[magnifisaint]

Dow will not be sub but Garcia will play a full game.

[SAINT-LEE]

Out: Hill (inj), Cammaniti (inj)
In: Pou, Heath/Keeler

Dow to sub.

I give that a big like but has to be Keeler at this stage

Mate based on his last 2 games I wouldnt give Keeler the time of day let alone a game.

Like 6 disposals and zero effort given on Sunday. Weak as.

[older saint]

Poo for Cama
If Hill injured Garcia into starting 22 and perhaps Hastie as sub

[Moods]

Out: Hill (inj), Cammaniti (inj)
In: Pou, Heath/Keeler

Dow to sub.

I give that a big like but has to be Keeler at this stage

Keeler did nothing at Sandy yesterday.

I get that but overall he’s been improving considerably and had been in decent form prior to this match.

We’ve now lost a tall forward that acted as the relief ruck that is the exact role that we’re pbly wanting from Keeler and we’re playing in a game that means nothing to us.

Personally I’d role the dice here and have a look at the Marshall/Keeler combo that we’re hoping for

I won’t pretend to know how good Keeler is, but let’s give the kid a go. Campbell has been an incredible stalwart for our vfl team but he doesn’t have the qualities we need at AFL level. Let’s see how he goes and cross our fingers that Weitering doesn’t go to him…..

[Killa]

The game is at Docklands, so a “fast surface”

Noting we have played Campbell there once this season which I would not have done

[1965 Saint]

If we lose to Carlton that should keep the skunks out of the finals

Collingwood would have to win by 100 points and we would have to beat Carlton by a similar margin for Collingwood to displace Carlton

[B.M]

Keeler had a massive chance to impress RTB Sunday - was poor
Heath the same

Campbell was typically dominant- deserves selection- if there is selection integrity - probably a thank you and farewell game too

Out
Caminiti, Hill, Dow
In
Ross (Sub)
Campbell
Phillipou
Both Farewell Games

Garcia into the starting 22

Wilkie - Howard - Webster
Nas - Battle - Sincs
Wood - Clark - Wilson
Butler - Sharman - Owens
Higgins - Membrey - Marshall

Campbell - Steele - Jones

Garcia - Byrnes - Stocker - Phillipou

Sub
Ross

Emerg
Schoenmaker - Paton - Dow

[nostalgicsaint]

Keeler had a massive chance to impress RTB Sunday - was poor
Heath the same

Campbell was typically dominant- deserves selection- if there is selection integrity - probably a thank you and farewell game too

Out
Caminiti, Hill, Dow
In
Ross (Sub)
Campbell
Phillipou
Both Farewell Games

Garcia into the starting 22

Wilkie - Howard - Webster
Nas - Battle - Sincs
Wood - Clark - Wilson
Butler - Sharman - Owens
Higgins - Membrey - Marshall

Campbell - Steele - Jones

Garcia - Byrnes - Stocker - Phillipou

Sub
Ross

Emerg
Schoenmaker - Paton - Dow

I'm surprised you believe in farewell games.

Personally if you know they aren't playing next year and they're not in your best side/the season is over I'm playing the future.

Any of those emergencies ahead of a farewell game imo.


That said- I'd give Campbell another year.

[B.M]

Absolutely believe in Farewell games

When there’s nothing to play for

Seb Ross has been at StK for 13 seasons
Played 200+ games
Won two B&Fs

Tom Campbell has been a great clubman since coming to StK

I was there in 2014 when we sent off 3 club greats
Blake, Kosi and Milney - great memory - honoured 3 great servants!!!
Blake was no longer best 22, Kosi limped to the line and Milney was still a gun