Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 04 Jun 2024 8:43pm
I don't think McLuggage is anything special. He seems very similar to Dow. Is a McLuggage a Scottish suitcase?
No magnifisaint, a McLuggage is part of a new "loose change" meal deal at Ronald M's emporium of excellent food.
I would pass on McLuggage. Like the meal, hot and cold, and leaves you unsatisfied with a greasy aftertaste, tainted by disappointment. Next!
"There is only one thing in the world worse than being talked about, and that is not being talked about."
magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 04 Jun 2024 8:43pm
I don't think McLuggage is anything special. He seems very similar to Dow. Is a McLuggage a Scottish suitcase?
No magnifisaint, a McLuggage is part of a new "loose change" meal deal at Ronald M's emporium of excellent food.
I would pass on McLuggage. Like the meal, hot and cold, and leaves you unsatisfied with a greasy aftertaste, tainted by disappointment. Next!
Would you eat the meat without the condiments?
I rest my case, your honour.
Holder of unacceptable views and other thought crimes.
The saints are shite for most of their history, even the best spin doctor couldn't alter that, it'll have to be security for the player that tempts them to accept a trade. Good luck to the List management group, it's like pissing up a downpipe.
How many defenders will The Saints pick in the 2024 draft ?
magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 04 Jun 2024 8:43pm
I don't think McLuggage is anything special. He seems very similar to Dow. Is a McLuggage a Scottish suitcase?
Sorry, but this comparison is ludicrous.
Dow is somewhere between being far too good for the VFL and being a c grade AFL midfielder with questionable foot skills.
McLuggage has been top 3 in the B&F of a top 4 team for the last 5 seasons and has made the AA squad (not the team) I think 5 times.
McLuggage is not elite, but he’s A grade season after consistent season and is also durable.
Dow isn’t close to the same class and is seriously overrated on this forum. I’m still waiting to see that breakaway pace from the stoppages that he seemed to acquire when he transferred clubs.
Dow is best 22 at saints, but only because our midfield is close to the worst in the competition.
There's only one rule in the jungle! When the LYON's hungry, he eats!
D.B.Cooper wrote: ↑Thu 16 May 2024 1:35pm
Who thinks Heath will make it at AFL level?
Good competitor, hard nosed but I don't think he has it for athleticism and running capacity to be an AFL ruck.
Heath will only make it as an AFL ruckman after St Kilda delist him.
The more you know, the more you know you don't know.
When I was a young child, I knew that I knew so much about so much.
Now that I am old and know so much more, I know that I know so much about so little, and so little about so much.
If you are not engaging AI actively and aggressively, you are doing it wrong.
You are not going to lose your job to AI.
You are going lose your job to somebody who uses AI.
Your company is not going to go out of business because of AI.
Your company is going to go out of business because another company used AI.
- Jensen Huang, CEO of NVIDIA
I reckon all those A grades were looking at Saturday nights game,thinking why the f*** would we want to go and play with this lot even if they were offering $2,000,000 a year!!!
Rival clubs reportedly think they can pry Tyson Stengle out of Geelong on a big-money deal.
The Herald Sun’s Scott Gullan reports Stengle, a free agent at season’s end, could receive offers worth $800,000 plus from rival clubs, with St Kilda and Essendon touted as suitors.
The Cats meanwhile are believed to only be able to table a deal worth around $600,000 per season, meaning the 2022 All-Australian could potentially be leaving up to $200,000 on the table to remain at Geelong.
“Rival clubs believe they can get him. There’s offers being floated as $800,000, maybe more, to get him out of the Cattery,” Gullan said on Fox Footy’s The Midweek Tackle.
“He’s 25 and looking for the big lifetime deal ... he’s a bit restless down at Cat land.
“Essendon and St Kilda (are circling him) and there’s a few other clubs watching from a distance.
“The issue is Geelong isn’t going to be able to get near $800,000, they might get to $600,000, it might be $150,000 or $200,000 per year deal he could have to make a decision on.”
Gullan believes comments last month from Stengle’s guardian, Annie Scullie, the wife of Eddie Betts and acting manager of the Cats small forward, that Geelong “is quite isolating” further signals he’s “a bit restless” in the regional city.
Scullie is representing Stengle in talks in a unique management setup, having negotiated a one-year extension for the 25-year old last year.
It’s believed the relaxed, country vibe of Geelong isn’t as appealing to Stengle, who despite only playing one season with Betts at Adelaide, spends several night’s a week at the family’s Melbourne home.
“Lifestyle concerns, maybe he wants to live closer to the city,” fellow Herald Sun reporter Jay Clark said on the Midweek Tackle.
“Remember he went from Richmond to Adelaide on rookie wages and had a low salary first up at Geelong.
“If he’s getting $800,000, that’s a lifetime deal. he’s got to take that money if it’s on the table from St Kilda and Essendon.”
He's a small forward. He's also had off field issues in the past. I'd pay that money for Shai Bolton, but Stenglein is worth absolutely no more than what Geelong is willing to pay him. We'd be out of our minds to offer that kind of money
Scollop wrote: ↑Thu 13 Jun 2024 11:22pm
If Stengle can kick with his non preferred he's an upgrade on Higgins playing deep forward.
He's worth the money in my book. Higgins can impact up the ground as a high half forward and Stengle can stay closer to goal.
We have to try and bring in A grade quality and he's still quite young.
It pains me to say it but ..yes …correct
Morons look at a player and go “WTF he’s not worth that” (they didn’t say that when we paid Gresham 800k and Stengel an upgrade on him imo - he’s AA FFS)
That aside, you pay a premium to prize them out if their club - just like Hawks will have to do to get Battle (and trigger band 1 if so..)
That’s life
Next
Just get me a flag I’m over idolising players I care about the jumper
Scollop wrote: ↑Thu 13 Jun 2024 11:22pm
If Stengle can kick with his non preferred he's an upgrade on Higgins playing deep forward.
He's worth the money in my book. Higgins can impact up the ground as a high half forward and Stengle can stay closer to goal.
We have to try and bring in A grade quality and he's still quite young.
It pains me to say it but ..yes …correct
Morons look at a player and go “WTF he’s not worth that” (they didn’t say that when we paid Gresham 800k and Stengel an upgrade on him imo - he’s AA FFS)
That aside, you pay a premium to prize them out if their club - just like Hawks will have to do to get Battle (and trigger band 1 if so..)
That’s life
Next
Just get me a flag I’m over idolising players I care about the jumper
Yes... but you can take it too far.
Going to be a bit of a balancing act to try and bring in an A grader and try and retain a guy like Batts.
I think if we lose Josh Battle it rips a little hole in the fabric. I don't envy our list management
I want us to keep the core of our young players happy and to retain our good young players. If they can retain Batts and also bring in Stengle that's the perfect scenario for me
magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 04 Jun 2024 8:43pm
I don't think McLuggage is anything special. He seems very similar to Dow. Is a McLuggage a Scottish suitcase?
Sorry, but this comparison is ludicrous.
Dow is somewhere between being far too good for the VFL and being a c grade AFL midfielder with questionable foot skills.
McLuggage has been top 3 in the B&F of a top 4 team for the last 5 seasons and has made the AA squad (not the team) I think 5 times.
McLuggage is not elite, but he’s A grade season after consistent season and is also durable.
Dow isn’t close to the same class and is seriously overrated on this forum. I’m still waiting to see that breakaway pace from the stoppages that he seemed to acquire when he transferred clubs.
Dow is best 22 at saints, but only because our midfield is close to the worst in the competition.
