Out Membrey In Campbell

[nostalgicsaint]

Would be my change next week.

Marshall to spend more time forward and let Campbell go h2h with the Big O.

Takes heat of King. He was best when he had Ryder/Marshall there too.

[B.M]

Nope

[B.M]

Take an A Grader out of the ruck and bring in a D Grader

And put Marshall forward where he’s average at best

Next

[nostalgicsaint]

Take an A Grader out of the ruck and bring in a D Grader

And put Marshall forward where he’s average at best

Next

Wouldn't expect you to understand.

Campbell is a great match up for the Big O.

Our forward line is struggling to win 1 on 1 marking contests.

If it isn't working you sub Campbell off and revert to a more traditional structure.

[The_Dud]

I think Membrey is done unfortunately.

[spert]

Would be my change next week.

Marshall to spend more time forward and let Campbell go h2h with the Big O.

Takes heat of King. He was best when he had Ryder/Marshall there too.

King played better under Ratts, but he has to pull his finger out- got lead to the ball tonight.

[George27]

Out Howard
In Cordy

[nostalgicsaint]

Out Howard
In Cordy

This too. Or Shoenmakers and have Battle play taller.

[B.M]

I don’t understand

Because it’s a ridiculous suggestion

[shmic_s]

I think Membrey is done unfortunately.

He is looking a step slow, dropping the marks he should take, taking the wrong options. Hope he finds it, as he is important and one of my favourites.

[nostalgicsaint]

I don’t understand

Because it’s a ridiculous suggestion

Open your mind.

[ROLS-LEE]

Take an A Grader out of the ruck and bring in a D Grader

And put Marshall forward where he’s average at best

Next

Wouldn't expect you to understand.

Campbell is a great match up for the Big O.

Our forward line is struggling to win 1 on 1 marking contests.

If it isn't working you sub Campbell off and revert to a more traditional structure.

Agreed.

[ROLS-LEE]

I think Membrey is done unfortunately.

He is looking a step slow, dropping the marks he should take, taking the wrong options. Hope he finds it, as he is important and one of my favourites.

He can find it in the seconds. Cooper must play and leave him deep forward.

[SAINT-LEE]

Shoenmakers has been in recovery. Not sure how serious, he was running a bit.

[repta]

Campbell is a one dimensional dinosaur ruckman. Can't afford.to carry him.
Saints need.to put.more.time into Caminiti to make him at least competitive when he is in the ruck.

Membrey is done. Saints need someone to put more pressure on to keep the ball in. Caminiti and King get rebounded against faster than a superbounce ball on concrete.

[bigcarl]

If we had two Marshalls, I wouldn’t hesitate to play one of them forward. Our opponents wouldn’t be able to put so much scragging work into King. Sadly we have only one, so we’ll have to find other solutions.

[Killa]

The problem with King leading into space is the reason he got that Q4 free kick.

There was plenty of space which Higgins was running free into.

And King was subjected to what he was subjected to to prevent him from presenting.

The ball some 60 metres away with a Membrey mark - so what is the rule these days?

[saintbob]

Would be my change next week.

Marshall to spend more time forward and let Campbell go h2h with the Big O.

Takes heat of King. He was best when he had Ryder/Marshall there too.

Tom Campbell would be a great step forward, NOT!

All due respect to Campbell, but we need to give Heath a crack.

[Vortex]

This is pure guess work but I would imagine that even if our injury list was so bad and Campbell and Collard were the only available options to get selected in the ruck, Collard would get picked.

[nostalgicsaint]

Nope

Yep

[Scollop]

Nope

Yep

That's ridiculous.

Obviously Campbell is replacing Webster

[magnifisaint]

Campbell is playing well.

[B.M]

Campbell
6 HOs

[B.M]

Caminiti nearly got Marshall killed then

He is fkn dumb

[nostalgicsaint]

I'd have Campbell in every week.

Well ahead of Jones, Ross and Bonner.

Like to see Marshall spend more time at CHF using his tank as a link in the riewoldt mode.