Harley Reid karate chop on Windy's throat

[Scollop]

One of the last stoppages on the boundary . Less than 30 seconds left on the clock until the final siren

Reid and Windhager. Push and shove.

Reid hits Windy with a karate chop to the throat. It's not easy to see because the camera is panning from a distance.

No close up. No commentators saw it or made mention of it but you can clearly see Windy was affected

If he doesn't get suspended for the sling tackle he should go for this punch

[bigcarl]

One of the last stoppages on the boundary . Less than 30 seconds left on the clock until the final siren

Reid and Windhager. Push and shove.

Reid hits Windy with a karate chop to the throat. It's not easy to see because the camera is panning from a distance.

No close up. No commentators saw it or made mention of it but you can clearly see Windy was affected

If he doesn't get suspended for the sling tackle he should go for this punch

He got two weeks for the sling. He’s a rare talent, but Windy has his measure

[loris]

One of the last stoppages on the boundary . Less than 30 seconds left on the clock until the final siren

Reid and Windhager. Push and shove.

Reid hits Windy with a karate chop to the throat. It's not easy to see because the camera is panning from a distance.

No close up. No commentators saw it or made mention of it but you can clearly see Windy was affected

If he doesn't get suspended for the sling tackle he should go for this punch

I think I read that Harley has a Marshall Arts training background - that’s the reason he is so strong with his fend offs. It’s a skill that’s trained in Marshall arts. I guess a chop is to? If so he’s a naughty boy using that technique - could be lethal.
If the commentators saw it - they wouldn’t mention it. Don’t want to destroy the image they are building up.
As good as the kid is - it gets a bit sickening here in the West. The media have labeled him The Prince of Perth. It’s a wonder he hasn’t been given the keys of the city .
I just hope they are not building him up that much that it will destroy him in some way.

[Scollop]

It was a cheap dirty shot and you can cause a lot of damage doing that. Did you see how Windy was gasping?

I'm thinking BEFORE the corrupt AFL and West Coast somehow get Reid off the charge, he should be cited for the karate chop

[Waltzing St Kilda]

"Marshall Arts" is a new one, Loris. Is Rowan the instructor? My all-time-favourite from this side remains "a hare's breath away" though.

[loris]

"Marshall Arts" is a new one, Loris. Is Rowan the instructor? My all-time-favourite from this side remains "a hare's breath away" though.

Is it called marshall arts - all that Kung Fooey type stuff - or have I invented the name?
I’m only familiar with tai chi - a little more refined
I wouldn’t mind Roma being my instructor in that - such a lovely smile

[Scollop]

[saynta]

Sorry Loris but it's Martial Arts. In any event the young guy has anger management issues and is a would be thug.

[saynta]

The angry turd has been given two weeks with Sinclair and Dow fined for maggot contact plus Marshall find for tripping a weagle

[Sainter_Dad]

It was a fend off that went high - not a chop:


But it went high and Windy felt it for a second


I also think you guys are jumping at shadows - this was just a fend off - not a chop - it was not an intentional act to hurt.

[loris]

Sorry Loris but it's Martial Arts. In any event the young guy has anger management issues and is a would be thug.

Thanks saynta. At least I got the pronunciation right eh?
I think he showed his frustrations, when he couldn’t control his game output. Lot to learn, only young, still has pimples on his face!!!

[bigcarl]

Sorry Loris but it's Martial Arts. In any event the young guy has anger management issues and is a would be thug.

Thanks saynta. At least I got the pronunciation right eh?
I think he showed his frustrations, when he couldn’t control his game output. Lot to learn, only young, still has pimples on his face!!!

And is a dead ringer for Greta Thunberg

[Scollop]

[Dis Believer]

One of the last stoppages on the boundary . Less than 30 seconds left on the clock until the final siren

Reid and Windhager. Push and shove.

Reid hits Windy with a karate chop to the throat. It's not easy to see because the camera is panning from a distance.

No close up. No commentators saw it or made mention of it but you can clearly see Windy was affected

If he doesn't get suspended for the sling tackle he should go for this punch

I think I read that Harley has a Marshall Arts training background - that’s the reason he is so strong with his fend offs. It’s a skill that’s trained in Marshall arts. I guess a chop is to? If so he’s a naughty boy using that technique - could be lethal.
If the commentators saw it - they wouldn’t mention it. Don’t want to destroy the image they are building up.
As good as the kid is - it gets a bit sickening here in the West. The media have labeled him The Prince of Perth. It’s a wonder he hasn’t been given the keys of the city .
I just hope they are not building him up that much that it will destroy him in some way.

I think everything will be OK Loris. After all, Perth doesn't have a history of placing young men on a pedestal to their ultimate detriment due to their footballing exploits - does it?

[ace]

Sorry Loris but it's Martial Arts. In any event the young guy has anger management issues and is a would be thug.

Thanks saynta. At least I got the pronunciation right eh?
I think he showed his frustrations, when he couldn’t control his game output. Lot to learn, only young, still has pimples on his face!!!

And is a dead ringer for Greta Thunberg

But clearly nowhere near as stupid.

[SaintPav]

This guy is an excitement machine, and I look forward to watching him play over the next 15 years or so, but unfortunately it won't be in our colors.

However, some of the opportunistic media commentary around Reid's actions leaves a lot to be desired.

Don't hang the guy out to dry, but don't just excuse it either.

I thought we were trying to protect the head.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

[SaintPav]

Sorry Loris but it's Martial Arts. In any event the young guy has anger management issues and is a would be thug.

Thanks saynta. At least I got the pronunciation right eh?
I think he showed his frustrations, when he couldn’t control his game output. Lot to learn, only young, still has pimples on his face!!!

And is a dead ringer for Greta Thunberg

But clearly nowhere near as stupid.

Stupid isn’t the right word..I would describe her as a tool.

[Yorkeys]

If it was Harley campaigning rather than Greta climate change issues would now be resolved. And everyone would have to look happy.

[Devilhead]

Good chance that Harley is going to give away a few free kicks in his career with that fend off

Great tagging job by Marcus

[Bernard Shakey]

Harley doesn't have a tank yet, and gets frustrated when he fades in second halves. Happens every week.
Watch out when he does develop one though!

[Sainter_Dad]

Harley doesn't have a tank yet, and gets frustrated when he fades in second halves. Happens every week.
Watch out when he does develop one though!

No - last quarters - they put up stats that showed something like
1st - 4.5
2nd - 4.8
3rd - 5.5
4th - 3.8

Not exactly a fade out