Which ex saints would you draft?

[Crossy66]

If you could draft any four ex saints from the last 30 years into today's team, based on need, who would they be? Im going with Lenny, harvey, everitt and early luke Ball.
All mids! I resisted the temptation to add my all time favourite.

[bigcarl]

Lenny, Harvey, Goddard, Riewoldt.


Course would like to grab Dal Santo, Gehrig, Milne and a few others. Sam Fisher would go close, but I’d have to pass as he will be available only for home games for the next few seasons.

[Crossy66]

I was thinking a ruck/fwd rather than pure fwd.

[Vortex]

As good as Goddard was, anyone else think he was a bit overrated in the the context of 1DP?

Was a fairly bland type of player most of the time.

[Sainter_Dad]

In no specific order

Plugger
Winmar
Leowe
Harvey

[Otiman]

Plugger, Harvs, Hayes, Riewoldt.

The only discussion is do you go for Hayes or Winmar?

Also a smokey for peak Jack Steven.

[bigcarl]

In no specific order

Plugger
Winmar
Leowe
Harvey
Hayes
Jones
Riewoldt

s***, how could I forget Plugger. Played for us until 1994, so just makes the 30-year limit. How careless of me. So, Lockett, Harvey, Hayes, Riewoldt .

[Crossy66]

I was thinking based on biggest needs right now. I.e. no midfield, rather than just the best 4 players.
Plugged might struggle with the delivery atm

[bigcarl]

I was thinking based on biggest needs right now. I.e. no midfield, rather than just the best 4 players.

But the greatest player in the game’s history would make a difference to our forward line Crossy. As would Rooey. You could move Max King to second ruck.

If it were four midfielders, I’d go Harvey, Hayes, Goddard, Winmar/Dal Santo.

[Crossy66]

You're right. Plugger only needed sky balls and he would get to them.
Ima thinking extractors as that's what we don't have, plus a great athletic tap ruckman that goes forward is something we haven't had for a while

[Otiman]

You're right. Plugger only needed sky balls and he would get to them.
Ima thinking extractors as that's what we don't have, plus a great athletic tap ruckman that goes forward is something we haven't had for a while

I had Ryder in my calculations.

[bigcarl]

You're right. Plugger only needed sky balls and he would get to them.

Yeah, plus he would make space in which to lead. No one dared get in his way

[Killa]

That Harvey had twin sons of comparable ability to him and that Lockett had a son of comparable ability to him

All playing for St Kilda under Father/Son

[SinCitySainter]

With the current collision and tackle rules Plugger would be playing one game in three. Unfortunately, the modern game has no room for players like Plugger. You would have to wonder if he would be as effective if he had to slim down to play the roving role that all forwards are expected to play.

[Josh Battle]

This is a much better thread.

Too much negativity on the forum lately. Too much focus on how we’re playing and how we’re being coached

[nostalgicsaint]

Not sure today's footy suits plugger.

Riewoldt- would help our transition immensely
Hayes- would help Steele
Kosi- Forward ruck to perfectly compliment Marshall.

Here is a smokey for you if your talking peak form versions of themselves. Jack Steven. One of the few players we've had who can explode out of a stoppage.

[Banger9798]

Reiwoldt
Harvey
Winmar
Dal Santo or Spider

And Rod Keogh

[The Fireman]

Enrico Misso

[Vortex]

Nathan Burke

Stevie Baker

Andrew Thomson

Fraser Gehrig

Aaron Hamill


Tough aggressive competitors who never gave up.

[whiskers3614]

of those that left since the Messiah's first coming-
Big Boy
Goddard
Dal Santo
Acres

[B.M]

Past 30 years would exclude plugger

I’d go
Reiwoldt
Hayes
Milne
Everitt

Very tempted by
Jack Steven - stoppage speed
Gehrig - deep forward to allow Max to higher
Dal - Ball use
Goddard - same

[SaintPav]

Winmar, Milne, Hayes, Lowe…..and of course Barks

[meher baba]

Riewoldt, Gehrig, Harves, Lenny

We could trade Max.

Dal, Kosi (2005 form) , Winmar, Hamill unlucky.

Lockett was an amazing player but the game has moved on.

[StNoodles]

BARRY HALL

We need an enforcer.

Someone who makes the rest of the team walk taller.

[SaintPav]

BARRY HALL

We need an enforcer.

Someone who makes the rest of the team walk taller.

Christian* would cite him for his facial expressions.











*Corrupt c.unt