Who would you pick?

[B.M]

B: Wilkie - Cordy - Stocker
HB: Wanganeen Milera- Battle - Bonner

Foll: Marshall - Steele - Sinclair
C: Hill - Windhager - Ross

HF: Garcia - Membrey - Wilson
F: Owens - King - Higgins

Int: Collard - Campbell - Schoenmaker - Phillipou
Sub: Byrnes

E: Sharman - Dow - Jones

f*** it, we are on a hiding to nothing anyway

[Otiman]

Apologies if i've missed anyone - i'll edit if i've made a major.

Wilkie Howard Stocker
NWM Cordy Sinclair
Hill Windhager Wood
Owens King Philippou
Garcia Caminiti Higgins

Marshall Steele Dow

Bench: Ross Wilson Battle Collard Byrnes(Sub)

Notable omissions: Bonner, Membrey, Sharman

[wally]

Personally I’d like to see King at chf, Membrey leading out of ff and Caminiti/Sharman playing 3rd tall.
Having said that I think the experts seem to say Collingwood’s small mobile forward line was a bit part to beating PA last week.

[spert]

Pretty obvious now that our forward half is too slow, has practically no defensive system and can easily be run off. I would think about putting Steele in the forward half for a bit more hunger at the ball and opposition, and play Owen exclusively at FF.

[Yorkeys]

Not Tim Membrey,
unless, on Friday,
Tim executes a run down tackle
Prevents his marker taking several intercepts, and
kicks a goal before half time, I.e. while the result is still in question or earlier if result is foregone before then.
Is that too much to ask.

[B.M]

Membrey 188cm
Liam Jones 197cm

Jones in AA form

Big ask

[Life Long Saint]

B: Wilkie - Howard - Stocker
HB: Wanganeen Milera- Battle - Sinclair
C: Hill - Windhager - Ross
HF: Garcia - Membrey - Wilson
F: Owens - King - Higgins
Foll: Marshall - Steele - Dow

Int: Bonner - Hayes - Schoenmaker - Phillipou
Sub: Byrnes
E: Sharman - Caminiti - Collard


King, Howard, Hayes, and Dow simply must come in for Caminiti, Jones, Cordy, and Butler.
And it's time to give Schoenmaker a go (he's killing it in the VFL)...Probably in place of Sharman.

King and Howard are no-brainers, really.
Hayes coming in allows Owens to focus on everything other than ruckwork. He's a more mature, and better defensive forward than Caminiti to boot.
And Dow is the logical clearance player we need to replace Jones.

[Banger9798]

If he's fit, Dow goes in

He is the one I wanted to see play the most of our recruits.

[Banger9798]

And I'd give Pou a run in the two's

Bring in Schoenmaker

[Yorkeys]

Membrey 188cm
Liam Jones 197cm

Jones in AA form

Big ask

OK forget the goal. How about an effective tackle, maybe a chest mark, if that's not too big an ask.

[nobhead]

Bonner howard wilkie
Nwm battle sinclair
Hill steele wilson
Owens king pou
Higgins hayes collard
Marshall windy dow
Stocker ross clark garcia membrey

[Yorkeys]

Are we going to tag Horne--Francis and Rozee & maybe Butters? Jobs for Steele, Windy and Ross or just go head to head?
Either way bench will need aerobic capacity plus. Maybe Darcy could run with Rozee for a bit?
Obvously selection this week is going to be tough looking at possible match ups, although you'd think Marshall wouldn't have too much trouble with Soldo, but how to exploit.