Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
Finna wrote: ↑Thu 07 Sep 2023 7:32am
Hayes is probably the most overrated player we've had on our list for years. Sure he kicked a few goals here and there but overall he's been average in a very small sample size of games. Not to mention is always injured. Much rather have hammer and/or sharman in the lineup. Hayes wont make it...he's done
That is your opinion and you are entitled to it.
My opinion is the Club has done the right thing by the player who has yet to undertake a full pre-season and is coming into his prime age for an AFL player.
Otiman wrote: ↑Thu 07 Sep 2023 1:14pm
Sharman and Caminiti are totally different players.
Caminiti is your true 200cm power forward, a Tom Hawkins type.
Sharman is more your Bailey Fritsch, Brody Mihocek type.
The former can win you a flag off his own boot.
Different players but, if Membrey can go round for one or two more years, they’ll be competing for the same spot.
Caminiti has heaps more to offer IMO. If it were up to me, he’d play on Saturday.
I tend to agree but I suspect Doogs will come in if he’s available to insure against Cordz being exposed for speed and to strengthen up the forward line with Cordz and also provide chopout in the ruck.
Lyon will always deploy a more defensive mindset than an attacking mindset unless he’s still exploring and wants to find an attacking weapon in a final but that doesn’t sound like Lyon does it.
