Crows v swans

[repta]

Saints have been robbed

Legal chellenge.

If that last shot ... hit the post ... was awarded a goal. Saints make finals.
Guaranteed

Now not so much

Didnt hit the post clearly

[repta]

Now we need things to fall right or beat Brisbane

[perfectionist]

Saints have been robbed

Legal chellenge.

If that last shot ... hit the post ... was awarded a goal. Saints make finals.
Guaranteed

Now not so much

Didnt hit the post clearly

Yep the ball missed the post by a mile.

[The_Dud]

Umpire right there seemed pretty confident…

[skeptic]

So the scenarios are:
Saints beat Lions = finals

If they lose, then in order to miss the finals…
Bulldogs need to beat Geelong in Geelong
GWS need to beat Carlton at Marvel
Sydney need to beat Melbourne at the SCG

All scenarios are against the odds

[Devilhead]

Umpire right there seemed pretty confident…

Replay showed clearly it didn't hit the post

Not sure how you can defend this one

Huge mistake by the goal ump

[saynta]

Didn't hit the post at all. Saints robbed.

Par for the course

[skeptic]

Umpire right there seemed pretty confident…

Replay showed clearly it didn't hit the post

Not sure how you can defend this one

Huge mistake by the goal ump

So weird that it didn’t go to the review panel

[The Fireman]

Didn’t they reverse the results of our game when we played Freo

[skeptic]

Didn’t they reverse the results of our game when we played Freo

Unfortunately that was a more clear cut result from memory. They argued that the game ended prior to our score to draw (or whatever).
There was still 60s in play after this

[The Fireman]

Didn’t they reverse the results of our game when we played Freo

Unfortunately that was a more clear cut result from memory. They argued that the game ended prior to our score to draw (or whatever).
There was still 60s in play after this

The goal kicked by the crows looks clear cut

[CURLY]

Umpire right there seemed pretty confident…

Well he’s either no good or a cheat.

[The_Dud]

Didn't hit the post at all. Saints robbed.

Par for the course

After just watching a game where we ‘won’ the free kick count 20-5 (!!!) you still find a way to whinge about the umpires.

Pat for the course

[happy feet]

So the scenarios are:
Saints beat Lions = finals

If they lose, then in order to miss the finals…
Bulldogs need to beat Geelong in Geelong
GWS need to beat Carlton at Marvel
Sydney need to beat Melbourne at the SCG

All scenarios are against the odds

Bulldogs are a good chance.
You would think Carlton would beat GWS
You would think Melbourne would beat Sydney, but after what happened tonight in Adelaide who would know.

[mr six o'clock]

Didn’t they reverse the results of our game when we played Freo

Unfortunately that was a more clear cut result from memory. They argued that the game ended prior to our score to draw (or whatever).
There was still 60s in play after this

The goal kicked by the crows looks clear cut

Exactly
Can't help but think that if it was the Saints instead of shitney then the Boys at head office would overturn the result.

[The Fireman]

If they use the score review during a game why can’t they use it afterwards ?

[meher baba]

Didn’t they reverse the results of our game when we played Freo

Unfortunately that was a more clear cut result from memory. They argued that the game ended prior to our score to draw (or whatever).
There was still 60s in play after this

The goal kicked by the crows looks clear cut

There will be no change to the result and nor should there be. It was clearly a dreadful mistake by the umpire, but games should always be determined on the ground. The reversal of the result against Freo in 2006 was totally wrong IMO.

[repta]

Adelaide win.
Saints cant be out of finals.

Now a long division sum with key being saints beating Brisbane in Brisbane.

I have faith

But ...

Gws smashed essendon.

Melbourne v swans is 50 - 50

Dogs will win tomorrow . They should beat a defeated tired Geelong in Geelong.

I cant believe i am going to hope Carlton win

[The_Dud]

How long before they introduce a ‘captains challenge’ like Rugby and Cricket??

[meher baba]

How long before they introduce a ‘captains challenge’ like Rugby and Cricket??

That wasn't the problem. The problem was that all the Crows players were running around celebrating, and none of them noticed it was ruled a behind. If one of them had made a fuss with the umpires, there would have been a review.

[skeptic]

Geeez, the zeroed in on it on channel 7… it definitely missed the post. Frame by frame there was a noticeable gap

[The Fireman]

Didn’t they reverse the results of our game when we played Freo

Unfortunately that was a more clear cut result from memory. They argued that the game ended prior to our score to draw (or whatever).
There was still 60s in play after this

The goal kicked by the crows looks clear cut

There will be no change to the result and nor should there be. It was clearly a dreadful mistake by the umpire, but games should always be determined on the ground. The reversal of the result against Freo in 2006 was totally wrong IMO.

I thought it was wrong as well but hey, all fair in Love and War if it happened then? Why shouldn’t it happen now? Imagine the ramifications in regards to the betting.

[meher baba]

Didn’t they reverse the results of our game when we played Freo

Unfortunately that was a more clear cut result from memory. They argued that the game ended prior to our score to draw (or whatever).
There was still 60s in play after this

The goal kicked by the crows looks clear cut

There will be no change to the result and nor should there be. It was clearly a dreadful mistake by the umpire, but games should always be determined on the ground. The reversal of the result against Freo in 2006 was totally wrong IMO.

I thought it was wrong as well but hey, all fair in Love and War if it happened then? Why shouldn’t it happen now? Imagine the ramifications in regards to the betting.

It wil be a huge controversy. But there won't be any change to the result. Well, that's my prediction, anyway.

[SaintPav]

Shocking decision.

Umpire needs new eye ware

[The_Dud]

Didn’t they reverse the results of our game when we played Freo

Unfortunately that was a more clear cut result from memory. They argued that the game ended prior to our score to draw (or whatever).
There was still 60s in play after this

The goal kicked by the crows looks clear cut

There will be no change to the result and nor should there be. It was clearly a dreadful mistake by the umpire, but games should always be determined on the ground. The reversal of the result against Freo in 2006 was totally wrong IMO.

I thought it was wrong as well but hey, all fair in Love and War if it happened then? Why shouldn’t it happen now? Imagine the ramifications in regards to the betting.

It wil be a huge controversy. But there won't be any change to the result. Well, that's my prediction, anyway.

They can’t change the result, there was still about a minute left when the goal/point happened, Sydney can just say they could have kicked another and still won the game.