Votes v Giants

[George27]

5. Jack Sinclair - a great game from a wonderful player .

4. Nasiah Wanganeen- Milera. So much poise.

2. Jack Steele. Quiet early , but willed himself into the game and was fantastic in the clinches .

2. Max King. A welcome return.

1. Jade Gresham.

1. Callum Wilkie.

Until injured, Mich Owens was BOG. Great to see him up and about after the game.

Well played also by Higgins, Stocker, Clark ( especially early ) and Wood ( especially late ) .

[Otiman]

5 Sinclair (by a mile)
4 NWM
3 Steele (solid 2nd half, captains game)
2 King
1 Stocker - his best game for us

[desertsaint]

sincs
steele
roma
stocker
nasiah

[Scollop]

5 Sincs
4 Steele
2 Nas
1 Max
1 Butts
1 Stocker
1 Gresh

The captain had 10 tackles. Dan Butler had 5 and 1 crucial one with less than 2 minutes to play which iced the result

[The Fireman]

The ground -5

[Trev from the Bush]

The ground -5

5. The trainers! They were everywhere at nearly every contest.

[The_Dud]

5. Sinclair
4. NWM
3. Steele
2. Gresham
1. King

[The Fireman]

The ground -5

5. The trainers! They were everywhere at nearly every contest.

5. The crowd who booed a throw in

[saynta]

5. Sinclair.
4. NWM.
3. Stocker.
2.Gresham.
1. Steele.

[Scollop]

Jack Steele. 7 score involvements and 6 inside 50's, 4 clearances

Jack Sinclair. 7 score involvements and 6 inside 50's, 4 clearances

[Trev from the Bush]

5. Sincs. Absolutely superb. Harveyesque.
4. Wanganeen-Milera, best ever game. Will somebody please take him aside, reinforce what a beautiful kick he is and there is no need to pack his dacks whenever he is faced with the daunting task of kicking a goal.
3. Steele. Somebody on this forum said during the game he shouldn't be playing and others were in nodding agreement. Gee, feeling foolish must be enjoyable.
2. Wood. Excellent last quarter got us home.
1. MAX! Welcome back big fella, his quick hands, smarts, ability to contest mark and get the ball to ground have been sorely missed.

[The Fireman]

Who said steel shouldn’t be playing and who agreed
I can’t be stuffed going back through that thread

Is vortex here ?

[skeptic]

Who said steel shouldn’t be playing and who agreed
I can’t be stuffed going back through that thread

Is vortex here ?

Will own the egg on the face. With 10min to go in the second, he had 4 touches and hadn’t been near it for nearly a quarter of play.

Someone then showed him my post (obviously), had 8 touches in the last 10min and a huge second half. Happy to wear that I was wrong… best half he’s played since return from injury. Ton of tackles too. Hasn’t seemed right but back on track thankfully like the champ he is.

[saynta]

Who said steel shouldn’t be playing and who agreed
I can’t be stuffed going back through that thread

Is vortex here ?

Think he might be in hiding, waiting for another loss so he can heap more negative s*** on the saints using this forum.

[Banger9798]

5 Sinclair- top 10 player in the league
4 Steele - remembered that he was a contested beast
3 King - strong and confident, weights and protein
1 Wood - effort and composure
1 NWM - skill and now adding power
1 Michito - BOG until he went off to friendly fire

Apologies to Gresham

[The Fireman]

Who said steel shouldn’t be playing and who agreed
I can’t be stuffed going back through that thread

Is vortex here ?

Will own the egg on the face. With 10min to go in the second, he had 4 touches and hadn’t been near it for nearly a quarter of play.

Someone then showed him my post (obviously), had 8 touches in the last 10min and a huge second half. Happy to wear that I was wrong… best half he’s played since return from injury. Ton of tackles too. Hasn’t seemed right but back on track thankfully like the champ he is.

you owned up , well done but you really need to keep an eye on that trigger finger
You just can’t write players like Steele off at the drop of a hat
He has form

[Milne]

Sincs was BOG by far
NWM
Wilkie
Stocker
King

Not happy overall but we got the 4 points so let's move on

[skeptic]

Who said steel shouldn’t be playing and who agreed
I can’t be stuffed going back through that thread

Is vortex here ?

Will own the egg on the face. With 10min to go in the second, he had 4 touches and hadn’t been near it for nearly a quarter of play.

Someone then showed him my post (obviously), had 8 touches in the last 10min and a huge second half. Happy to wear that I was wrong… best half he’s played since return from injury. Ton of tackles too. Hasn’t seemed right but back on track thankfully like the champ he is.

you owned up , well done but you really need to keep an eye on that trigger finger
You just can’t write players like Steele off at the drop of a hat
He has form

I certainly never wrote him off…

Just suggested he came back too soon. As I said in another thread… in regular form, a 26-27 touch game from Steele is a slow day, he’s that good. Certainly since he became captain, he hasn’t churned out many games where he’s had 4 touches in a quarter and a half. Has been down since he came back and to be honest, it feels to me like it was too soon. That second half today seems like the first time he’s remotely been back to his best. Hopefully it’s that from here on out

[Banger9798]

To be fair, when Michito went down, Steele started playing with the aggression and commitment that we haven't seen all year

[meher baba]

5 Sinclair
4 Steele
3 Stocker
2 King
1 Gresham (nowhere near his best, but he kept us in it when we were really struggling).

Howard (apart from one dreadful mistake), Webster, Wilkie, Hill, Caminiti, Higgins and Butler all did a bit too.

I agree NWM did many wonderful things, but he also stuffed up a lot. So no points from me tonight.

[bigcarl]

5 Sinclair
4 Marshall
3 King
2 NWM
1 Steele

Special mention to Owens until injured and Caminiti, who is a born competitor

[bergsone]

5 Sinclair
4 Marshall
3 Butler
2 Steele
1 NWM

[B.M]

Sinclair
Wilkie
King
Wanganeen
Steele

[StPeter]

5 Sinclair
4 Wilkie
3 Marshall
2 Steele
1 NWM

[Scollop]

5 Sinclair
4 Steele
3 Stocker
2 King
1 Gresham (nowhere near his best, but he kept us in it when we were really struggling).

Howard (apart from one dreadful mistake), Webster, Wilkie, Hill, Caminiti, Higgins and Butler all did a bit too.

I agree NWM did many wonderful things, but he also stuffed up a lot. So no points from me tonight.

29 touches at 79% disposal efficiency with 19 of his disposals being kicks... and only 2 clangers for the whole day!!

Second most metres gained after Sinclair. 8 intercept possessions and an impressive 10 marks. He had 4 score involvements including 2 inside 50's (remember he's a backman)

It's ok to vote any way you want but why try justifying your votes with inaccurate information