Camaniti vs memory.

[Rubyjo]

Tough decision but it may come down to this .

[Rubyjo]

Bloody spell check

[The_Dud]

Can’t remember seeing Membrey play a worse game.

[bigcarl]

I don’t think they are competing for the same spot.

Caminiti is a potential key-position player. Membrey is a good third forward, but not tall or strong enough to crash packs as a key forward should.

I think Membrey is more competing with Cooper Sharman.

[skeptic]

I think before we write Membrey off completely…
Dropping him and letting him build form/fitness at Sandy isn’t IMO, the kiss of death it’s often made out to be.

He’s playing a very different style to what worked for him in his glory days IMO. He used to really rely on the at leap when going back with the flight of the ball… doesn’t seem to do that so much.

I reckon bring in Caminati in his place

[axcellence]

Membrey is a great second/third forward.

This game it was just him. Hopefully, he'll be better when Caminiti and King return. He can go back to being the second forward.

[The Fireman]

Hard to isolate individual players
The whole team sucked

[B.M]

Membrey being asked to do something he shouldn’t be

Membrey 188cm
McKay 201cm

[Rubyjo]

Think he has been a warrior ..but new warriors are coming .

[stkfc1]

Honestly I'd rather see a forward line of

Billings King Sharman
Butler Callamitti Higgins
Ownes Gresh Poe rotating through.
This is the future.

[shanegrambeau]

Does Tim lack confidence? Missed that first shot last week and then just didn’t wanna seem to take responsibility then on..including today!

Real shame if so

Another option

Could he play as a winger?

[Rubyjo]

He's not cooked but he is same old same old ..old bull may need to make way for young bull..he is very one dimensional and may have his head on the chopping block ..

[Trev from the Bush]

Membrey being asked to do something he shouldn’t be

Membrey 188cm
McKay 201cm

Exactly. We have been burnt due to lack of true tall forwards the past fortnight, bugger Caminiti for being suspended. Lack of genuine talls to get first grab at the ball makes it tough for our smaller forwards, easy for tall back men to intercept. Skunk is still running into form and fitness, let him loose on a flank.

[Trev from the Bush]

Membrey being asked to do something he shouldn’t be

Membrey 188cm
McKay 201cm

Exactly. We have been burnt due to lack of true tall forwards the past fortnight, bugger Caminiti for being suspended. Lack of genuine talls to get first grab at the ball makes it tough for our smaller forwards, easy for tall back men to intercept. Skunk is still running into form and fitness, let him loose on a flank.

[saynta]

Poor game from a lot of them today. Members wasn't on his own

[SaintPav]

Tim is a good player. He’ll be ok in a few weeks.

My preferred forward line is:

King
Camaniti
Membrey

Owens and Matias also playing in there at stages as required, probably playing higher up the ground and also midfield minutes.

[Otiman]

Membrey will want to erase his last 7 quarters from the coaches memory.

I cant see him playing next week.

[MC Gusto]

Members footy brain exploded tonight. Literally chose the wrong option every time!

[nostalgicsaint]

Out: Gresham

In: King

Sub: Billings



Membrey holds his spot for now as he and King will compliment each other.



Sharman/Owens/Pou all can spend some time up the ground but could get really dangerous as the third target.



Sharmans running capacity could see him become as valuable as a Wood in some ways. Was genuinely surprised.



Billings the sort of Sub who can have a massive impact.

[saynta]

Out: Gresham

In: King

Sub: Billings



Membrey holds his spot for now as he and King will compliment each other.



Sharman/Owens/Pou all can spend some time up the ground but could get really dangerous as the third target.



Sharmans running capacity could see him become as valuable as a Wood in some ways. Was genuinely surprised.



Billings the sort of Sub who can have a massive impact.

I too was surprised by Cooper's game and I haven't joined in on the "I hate Sharman"pile on. Or the case for him.

He has a future.

[Teflon]

Out: Gresham

In: King

Sub: Billings



Membrey holds his spot for now as he and King will compliment each other.



Sharman/Owens/Pou all can spend some time up the ground but could get really dangerous as the third target.



Sharmans running capacity could see him become as valuable as a Wood in some ways. Was genuinely surprised.



Billings the sort of Sub who can have a massive impact.

That’s why Sharman takes Membreys spot
It’s not just Membreys height as some make out that’s his key issue
It’s his decision making
Slow, holds up the team
He’s also slow - the forward line since he returned looks far far less dynamic
Yes that also has to do with how ball comes in
But Membrey doesn’t get on his bike, doesn’t lead up at ball carrier…today there was times he was calling for it deep behind McKay….like WTF Tim you ain’t a contested marking beast???
Good enough for Melbourne to drop Brown cause the cia h said he needed to go back and find form
Good enough for Tim

[Teflon]

Membrey being asked to do something he shouldn’t be

Membrey 188cm
McKay 201cm

Yes cause his poor and slow decision making is cause he’s shorter than McKsy
Stop making excuses

[King Max]

Bloody spell check

It should be Caniniti vs memory. But spell check won’t help you with that.

[Scollop]

Bloody spell check

It should be Caniniti vs memory. But spell check won’t help you with that.

Caminiti ffs

[King Max]

I must have been thinking about Bill Cannon.