Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
B.M wrote: ↑Sat 29 Apr 2023 1:51am
Pretty good career
260 goals in 150 odd games
For a dud
BTW
Stop the fkn multiple post quoting- it is ridiculous
Who said he’s a dud??
Stop fkn making up cr@p
And we can celebrate his career once it’s over
Tonight he was ordinary
Higgins had 14 disposals at a putrid 35.7% Disposal efficiency
At least Skunk went at 75% DE. Both had zero tackles and both kicked 1.1
Skunk had 4 inside50's and Snags only had 2. Both got 5 score involvements credited to them
Point is ...where is the analysis on every forward that played tonight. Why are you just blaming Tim?
Higgins is a small lead up forward
Membrey was our no 1 banana tonight who tried to play like a contested beast…only his 2 feet jumps don’t make him a success at it…he’s pushed off it way to easy ….why not lead? Move ? Do something??
Tim was ineffective tonight and most at the game acknowledged it
Think you need to compare apples..
Coach said in the presser how amazing Cordy’s selfless game for the team has been….but what would he know to you ?
Membrey in danger when Caminiti King etc all available imo …he was treacle tonight
Wrong
Cordy, according to Lyon, played a role asking him to sacrifice his game for the team
Not so Tim
Lyon was full of praise for Cordy actually…
You might want to take a listen??
B.M wrote: ↑Sat 29 Apr 2023 2:23am
12 touches, 5 marks and a goal
Contributed
Was ok
Not good, not terrible
Cordz played well though - 1 touch
You’ll need to take it up with Ross.
He said Cordy has been super at doing his job
And Tim will get better
So clearly you two aren’t on the same page
I wish you’d sort it cause I just don’t know where to go to get my in depth footy analysis from..
Scollop wrote: ↑Sat 29 Apr 2023 2:00am
Higgins had 14 disposals at a putrid 35.7% Disposal efficiency
At least Skunk went at 75% DE. Both had zero tackles and both kicked 1.1
Skunk had 4 inside50's and Snags only had 2. Both got 5 score involvements credited to them
Point is ...where is the analysis on every forward that played tonight. Why are you just blaming Tim?
Higgins is a small lead up forward
Membrey was our no 1 banana tonight who tried to play like a contested beast…only his 2 feet jumps don’t make him a success at it…he’s pushed off it way to easy ….why not lead? Move ? Do something??
Tim was ineffective tonight and most at the game acknowledged it
Think you need to compare apples..
The apple that is supposed to play like a small forward had zero tackles. That's worthy of a potato like performance
Scollop wrote: ↑Sat 29 Apr 2023 2:00am
Higgins had 14 disposals at a putrid 35.7% Disposal efficiency
At least Skunk went at 75% DE. Both had zero tackles and both kicked 1.1
Skunk had 4 inside50's and Snags only had 2. Both got 5 score involvements credited to them
Point is ...where is the analysis on every forward that played tonight. Why are you just blaming Tim?
Higgins is a small lead up forward
Membrey was our no 1 banana tonight who tried to play like a contested beast…only his 2 feet jumps don’t make him a success at it…he’s pushed off it way to easy ….why not lead? Move ? Do something??
Tim was ineffective tonight and most at the game acknowledged it
Think you need to compare apples..
The apple that is supposed to play like a small forward had zero tackles. That's worthy of a potato like performance
That apple wasn’t calling for bombs to be kicked in to him so he could be brushed aside …
That was no 1 banana….Timbo
Anyhow all a bit fruity off to nigh nigh
Wrong
Cordy, according to Lyon, played a role asking him to sacrifice his game for the team
Not so Tim
Lyon was full of praise for Cordy actually…
You might want to take a listen??
That's gold.
Most fans at the game don't believe Ross and I think the footy media don't believe what Ross is saying about Cordy, so I'm finding it difficult to understand why you do?
Don't be afraid. It's ok to question the messiah. You won't be struck by lightning
Wrong
Cordy, according to Lyon, played a role asking him to sacrifice his game for the team
Not so Tim
Lyon was full of praise for Cordy actually…
You might want to take a listen??
That's gold.
Most fans at the game don't believe Ross and I think the footy media don't believe what Ross is saying about Cordy, so I'm finding it difficult to understand why you do?
Don't be afraid. It's ok to question the messiah. You won't be struck by lightning
How odd
I just told you what he said
Are you suggesting he’s deliberately lying to the fan base for some weird reason ?
Bizarre.
B.M wrote: ↑Sat 29 Apr 2023 2:35am
If Ross says it
It must be right then.. yeah
He’s never made a poor coaching decision?!
Cordy has played a role doing what?
Not getting a fkn kick?
If Membrey got 1 touch of the footy - I’d agree with you…
Good thing we don’t need his role in fourth quarters
I’m not sure
Lyons’s an AFL coach saying he’s been super at the job he’s been doing for the team
You’re fascinated by his kick count
You must know more than you’re letting on…
Do tell us all … what’s Cordys current role within the team ?
Teflon wrote: ↑Sat 29 Apr 2023 2:27am
That apple wasn’t calling for bombs to be kicked in to him so he could be brushed aside …
That was no 1 banana….Timbo
So you're sure it wasn't the fault or partly the fault of the person booting the footy a la long bomb style?
B.M wrote: ↑Sat 29 Apr 2023 2:35am
If Ross says it
It must be right then.. yeah
He’s never made a poor coaching decision?!
Cordy has played a role doing what?
Not getting a fkn kick?
If Membrey got 1 touch of the footy - I’d agree with you…
Good thing we don’t need his role in fourth quarters
I’m not sure
Lyons’s an AFL coach saying he’s been super at the job he’s been doing for the team
You’re fascinated by his kick count
You must know more than you’re letting on…
Do tell us all … what’s Cordys current role within the team ?
Fact. Cordy has been subbed out without actually incurring any injury
Cordy is super important to the team...
but we can do without him in the last quarter when some games are up for grabs. You know it makes sense
Teflon wrote: ↑Sat 29 Apr 2023 2:27am
That apple wasn’t calling for bombs to be kicked in to him so he could be brushed aside …
That was no 1 banana….Timbo
So you're sure it wasn't the fault or partly the fault of the person booting the footy a la long bomb style?