Is Caminiti in trouble?

[Templar]

[D.B.Cooper]

Why do you think you're so honourable. The Collingwood player started it and got his right whack. Stop trying to defend an idiot.

I do not think I am so honorable, and I agree with you that the Collingwood player was the instigator and got his right whack in this instance.
I am not defending the behavior of a Collingwood player or anything in relation to the events of that match, quite the contrary.

My point is very clear, that old anonymous, vitriolic trolls referring to an AFL player who shows enormous on-field courage as:

- Gutless
- Poof ta
- Coward
- Cream Puff
- Dog
- Coward
- Cowardly filth pig
- F****** gutless clown
- Creep
- dropkick
- Pussie
- etc, etc, etc



Should not be tolerated, accepted as fans being fans or defended on this site or any other online forum.

If you disagree with that, and your opinion is that that type of trolling by keyboard warriors is acceptable

, then you are welcome to it.
I will gladly stick with my opinion.

Would the same posters now suggest Alex Pereira now a f****** a F****cking gutless clown because he bit off more than he could chew?

Gee you are full of it. The garbage you spew is endless. Does not take"enormous onfield courage" to punch an opponent in the back of the head when he is not looking.

I will give the coward the benifit of the doubt on the racial abuse because to me there is no proof.

For the record I don't have a f****** clue who Pereira is and I care even less.

You need a good lie down and give your keyboard a rest.

I won't be saying sorry for comments I made on the actions of a thug.

Making a comment to fans on a football forum is hardly trolling FFS.

Your ageist comments are like water off a ducks back.

No sure this post was directed to you saynta, but happy for you to reply.

I can tell you Pereira is a warrior, but not of the keyboard variety, probably why you don't know of him

[chook23]

Seems like some of hammers answers are at odds with st kilda submission.....

Hammers answers like he has had no advice

Amazing

We seem unprofessional

[chook23]

The AFL says Caminiti is "retaliating" to Murphy, which Caminiti has denied in his evidence.

Amazing answers

[Mr Magic]

The AFL says Caminiti is "retaliating" to Murphy, which Caminiti has denied in his evidence.

Amazing answers

So the AFL is claiming Caminiti is retaliating but the AFL MRO said Murphy had no case to answer?

[chook23]

Poor answers

Poor questioning by saints representative

Why???

[bigcarl]

The AFL says Caminiti is "retaliating" to Murphy, which Caminiti has denied in his evidence.

Amazing answers

Maybe he’s sticking to the player code, don’t be a dobber etc.

But agree, of course he was retaliating. That should be a key factor in mitigating the sentence. That and the fact that he is just a young teenage boy trying to hold his own against men.

[saynta]

Why do you think you're so honourable. The Collingwood player started it and got his right whack. Stop trying to defend an idiot.

I do not think I am so honorable, and I agree with you that the Collingwood player was the instigator and got his right whack in this instance.
I am not defending the behavior of a Collingwood player or anything in relation to the events of that match, quite the contrary.

My point is very clear, that old anonymous, vitriolic trolls referring to an AFL player who shows enormous on-field courage as:

- Gutless
- Poof ta
- Coward
- Cream Puff
- Dog
- Coward
- Cowardly filth pig
- F****** gutless clown
- Creep
- dropkick
- Pussie
- etc, etc, etc



Should not be tolerated, accepted as fans being fans or defended on this site or any other online forum.

If you disagree with that, and your opinion is that that type of trolling by keyboard warriors is acceptable

, then you are welcome to it.
I will gladly stick with my opinion.

Would the same posters now suggest Alex Pereira now a f****** a F****cking gutless clown because he bit off more than he could chew?

Gee you are full of it. The garbage you spew is endless. Does not take"enormous onfield courage" to punch an opponent in the back of the head when he is not looking.

I will give the coward the benifit of the doubt on the racial abuse because to me there is no proof.

For the record I don't have a f****** clue who Pereira is and I care even less.

You need a good lie down and give your keyboard a rest.

I won't be saying sorry for comments I made on the actions of a thug.

Making a comment to fans on a football forum is hardly trolling FFS.

Your ageist comments are like water off a ducks back.

No sure this post was directed to you saynta, but happy for you to reply.

I can tell you Pereira is a warrior, but not of the keyboard variety, probably why you don't know of him

More insults. Keep it up champ and Im sure St Byron will notice.

"that old anonymous, vitriolic trolls referring to an AFL player who shows enormous on-field courage."

That statement takes the cake as the biggest load of horse s*** posted on this subject.

[chook23]

Argue not a strike but

then say 3 weeks would be appropriate if downgraded

THIS IS ST KILDA REP Saying THIS

[asiu]

if
he didn't hit him
had no intent to hit him

then ipso facto
there can be no film of a non existent hit
(u know what i mean)

actual or surmised

how can they possibly c**k that up

[chook23]

if
he didn't hit him
had no intent to hit him

then ipso facto
there can be no film of a non existent hit

actual or surmised

how can they possibly c**k that up

Hammer admitted hitting him to the head with forearm

Read through the Twitter of David zita

[asiu]

just running back to thread
waiting to hear
in between other priorities at the mo

(i will , later)

[Templar]

AFL and AFLW Tribunals / Appeals Board

Tribunal Chair: Jeffrey Gleeson KC.
Tribunal Deputy Chair: Renee Enbom KC.
Tribunal Jury Members: Michelle Dench, Wayne Henwood, Jason Johnson, Stephen Jurica, Richard Loveridge, Stewart Loewe, Shannon McFerran, David Neitz, Paul Williams and Shane Wakelin.

Appeal Board Chairs: Murray Kellam KC, John Middleton.
Appeal Board Panel Members: Wayne Henwood, Stephen Jurica, Richard Loveridge

AFL Tribunal Counsel: Georgina Coghlan KC, Nick Pane KC, Andrew Woods
Tribunal Secretary: Matthew Whitaker
Match Review Officer - Michael Christian
Match Review Secretary – Hamish Anderson

[chook23]

AFL and AFLW Tribunals / Appeals Board

Tribunal Chair: Jeffrey Gleeson KC.
Tribunal Deputy Chair: Renee Enbom KC.
Tribunal Jury Members: Michelle Dench, Wayne Henwood, Jason Johnson, Stephen Jurica, Richard Loveridge, Stewart Loewe, Shannon McFerran, David Neitz, Paul Williams and Shane Wakelin.

Appeal Board Chairs: Murray Kellam KC, John Middleton.
Appeal Board Panel Members: Wayne Henwood, Stephen Jurica, Richard Loveridge

AFL Tribunal Counsel: Georgina Coghlan KC, Nick Pane KC, Andrew Woods
Tribunal Secretary: Matthew Whitaker
Match Review Officer - Michael Christian
Match Review Secretary – Hamish Anderson

Who is on jury tonight from that total panel?

[Templar]

Hopefully Stewie and not Wakelin and Williams. Taking long enough deliberating..

[Templar]

Three matches

[chook23]

3 weeks

[magnifisaint]

I reckon the Kangaroo court will give him 5 weeks. It's beyond ridiculous.

[chook23]

I reckon the Kangaroo court will give him 5 weeks. It's beyond ridiculous.

3 confirmed

Should have been 2 at the most

[chook23]

I reckon the Kangaroo court will give him 5 weeks. It's beyond ridiculous.

3 confirmed

Should have been 2 at the most

[D.B.Cooper]

Why do you think you're so honourable. The Collingwood player started it and got his right whack. Stop trying to defend an idiot.

I do not think I am so honorable, and I agree with you that the Collingwood player was the instigator and got his right whack in this instance.
I am not defending the behavior of a Collingwood player or anything in relation to the events of that match, quite the contrary.

My point is very clear, that old anonymous, vitriolic trolls referring to an AFL player who shows enormous on-field courage as:

- Gutless
- Poof ta
- Coward
- Cream Puff
- Dog
- Coward
- Cowardly filth pig
- F****** gutless clown
- Creep
- dropkick
- Pussie
- etc, etc, etc



Should not be tolerated, accepted as fans being fans or defended on this site or any other online forum.

If you disagree with that, and your opinion is that that type of trolling by keyboard warriors is acceptable

, then you are welcome to it.
I will gladly stick with my opinion.

Would the same posters now suggest Alex Pereira now a f****** a F****cking gutless clown because he bit off more than he could chew?

Gee you are full of it. The garbage you spew is endless. Does not take"enormous onfield courage" to punch an opponent in the back of the head when he is not looking.

I will give the coward the benifit of the doubt on the racial abuse because to me there is no proof.

For the record I don't have a f****** clue who Pereira is and I care even less.

You need a good lie down and give your keyboard a rest.

I won't be saying sorry for comments I made on the actions of a thug.

Making a comment to fans on a football forum is hardly trolling FFS.

Your ageist comments are like water off a ducks back.

No sure this post was directed to you saynta, but happy for you to reply.

I can tell you Pereira is a warrior, but not of the keyboard variety, probably why you don't know of him

More insults. Keep it up champ and Im sure St Byron will notice.

"that old anonymous, vitriolic trolls referring to an AFL player who shows enormous on-field courage."

That statement takes the cake as the biggest load of horse s*** posted on this subject.

I think there maybe an issue with your comprehension saynta. Are you a little confused?
Do you find yourself forgetting who you are and what you are doing?

Perhaps you could refer the moderator to the posts where I have insulted you. You on the other hand have done so on numerous occasions, but I neither care nor do I bother whining to the moderator as I am not bothered by internet trolls or keyboard warriors. BTW I love the champ line Hilarious!

If you identify as an vitriolic old troll, or any of the standard troll profile listed identifiers such as dry blower, shriveled testicles, short on self esteem & testosterone, slovenly, poor hygiene or any other well that is your issue, because for the record, I am not directing any of these generic terms at you or any other forum member.

Have a pleasant evening and let’s hope Anthony gets a good result at the tribunal.

[chook23]

Given video

If argued a certain way I think he may have got a better result

[WellardSaint]

3 matches.
Downgraded by tribunal to 'careless'

[Impatient Sainter]

3 weeks is a fair result...

[D.B.Cooper]

I reckon the Kangaroo court will give him 5 weeks. It's beyond ridiculous.

3 confirmed

Should have been 2 at the most

Agreed, 2 fair but 3 a decent result given I was expecting 4-5.

I think the Club will be happy with that.