Is Caminiti in trouble?

[Moods]

Belted Murphy in goal square off the ball. Murphy went off and wasn’t happy. Commentary team went quiet when they showed it

[bergsone]

Will be closely looked at

[The_Dud]

Didn’t see it, much in it?

[saynta]

No.

[Sainter_Dad]

Didn’t see it, much in it?

Yes

Murphy provokes him - but Hammer turns and lays a few good ones across the chest - but I believe one stray right clipped the jaw.

[Moods]

In my opinion he’ll get 2 weeks. Murphy is out Anzac Day with concussion apparently. Was behind play off the ball

[CURLY]

Off that footage no. If they guess he maybe it’s StKilda so look out.

[IluvHarvey]

2 weeks plus StKilda tax = 4 weeks with an early plea

[SaintPav]

There was footage of both players shaking hands after the siren with players surrounding them both.

Surprised about any concussion but who knows.

[Moods]

You be the judge

https://www.afl.com.au/video/907191/mur ... wsFeed:Yes

[The_Dud]

Even sillier by Caminiti is that as a fringe player, giving up your spot in the side is risky, might not get it back!

[CURLY]

Guess work

[Ghost Like]

Even sillier by Caminiti is that as a fringe player, giving up your spot in the side is risky, might not get it back!

A fringe player should play on the edge. I love his endeavour, fingers crossed he does not get cited. He's a ripper.

[Otiman]

Gave it as good as he got, should get off.

[mr six o'clock]

He plays for st kilda
So he'll definitely get weeks
Silly ......Yes
Will he learn .....hopefully
But as an up and coming player , I don't mind seeing a bit of aggression. Announcing to the league he's not a pushover.

[Trev from the Bush]

Weak as piss. Magpie started it, Caminiti barely touched him and he went to ground like he was shot, seeking a professional free that did not eventuate.

Great to see a young player stand up and be counted. Our youngsters are not to be messed with.

[Saintmatt]

Hammer’s in some definite strife. Confirmed post match that Murphy came off with concussion and can’t play Anzac Day.

His only hope is insufficient force but, it was high and off the ball.

[CURLY]

Murphy landed the first one then went in for a second crack. No vision of contact.

Guess work

[Annoyedsaint]

Gave himself away after the game too.
If the defender is giving it then bad luck.
If he cops a week so be it, but don’t bow down afterwards….look weak and sends a s*** message.

[Annoyedsaint]

Gave himself away after the game too.
If the defender is giving it then bad luck.
If he cops a week so be it, but don’t bow down afterwards….look weak and sends a s*** message.

[Impatient Sainter]

Murphy has a long history of concussions, he instigated by punching Hammer in the back and then ducked/tripped when Hammer went to hit his chest. Murphy basically caused the entire thing - hopefully Hammer is given just a warning.

[bigcarl]

Unfortunately provocation is not a defence.

I like Caminiti’s aggression and attitude, but he needs to keep it within the rules. A trap for young players.

He’s looking at a couple of weeks I reckon

[Sainternist]

Great acting by that wimp Murphy! If anything, Murphy should be penalised for staging!

Madball Caminiti wins - FLAWLESS VICTORY

P.S. My nickname for Caminiti is “Madball” because he’s a ringer for the vocalist of NYHC band Madball

[B.M]

Gone

[saintbob]

Great acting by that wimp Murphy! If anything, Murphy should be penalised for staging!

Madball Caminiti wins - FLAWLESS VICTORY

P.S. My nickname for Caminiti is “Madball” because he’s a ringer for the vocalist of NYHC band Madball

A fine at most, Murphy got a bit of a shock when the young fella come back at him.