What the hell is going on with Membury?

[Moods]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

[The_Dud]

T. Membrey - 2 weeks

[Sainter_Dad]

I dont know about Membury - but Membrey is listed as 4-5 weeks

[longtimesaint]

It never seems to get any closer!

[The Fireman]

It never seems to get any closer!

like swimming to shore against a rip

[Vortex]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

[Moods]

I dont know about Membury - but Membrey is listed as 4-5 weeks

Sorry. Voice to text

[Moods]

It was just a cleanout wasn’t it? Has he had
a set back?

its now 6 weeks

[The Fireman]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

hmmm giving out false info to confuse the opposition , are you telling us you have changed your stance on RTB and making him out a genius ?

[Vortex]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

hmmm giving out false info to confuse the opposition , are you telling us you have changed your stance on RTB and making him out a genius ?

Firey, Firey, Firey...me love Ross long time.

stop putting words in my internet.

[The Fireman]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

hmmm giving out false info to confuse the opposition , are you telling us you have changed your stance on RTB and making him out a genius ?

Firey, Firey, Firey...me love Ross long time.

stop putting words in my internet.

your words are already there for all to see. thankfully your inconsiderable input is limited to a couple of small forums.
everyone can be a clown be hind a keyboard just try and be a good one

[Vortex]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

hmmm giving out false info to confuse the opposition , are you telling us you have changed your stance on RTB and making him out a genius ?

Firey, Firey, Firey...me love Ross long time.

stop putting words in my internet.

your words are already there for all to see. thankfully your inconsiderable input is limited to a couple of small forums.
everyone can be a clown be hind a keyboard just try and be a good one

be and hind are one word

[The Fireman]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

hmmm giving out false info to confuse the opposition , are you telling us you have changed your stance on RTB and making him out a genius ?

Firey, Firey, Firey...me love Ross long time.

stop putting words in my internet.

your words are already there for all to see. thankfully your inconsiderable input is limited to a couple of small forums.
everyone can be a clown be hind a keyboard just try and be a good one

be and hind are one word

yep forgot i was up against a PHD .. anyway glad to see you paying attention ..i saw it but let it go..can we pretend that didnt happen and respond ?

[Vortex]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

hmmm giving out false info to confuse the opposition , are you telling us you have changed your stance on RTB and making him out a genius ?

Firey, Firey, Firey...me love Ross long time.

stop putting words in my internet.

your words are already there for all to see. thankfully your inconsiderable input is limited to a couple of small forums.
everyone can be a clown be hind a keyboard just try and be a good one

be and hind are one word

yep forgot i was up against a PHD .. anyway glad to see you paying attention ..i saw it but let it go..can we pretend that didnt happen and respond ?

It's PhD FFS

[The Fireman]

why is the h lower case ?
either way I'm impressed you have one.

[Killa]

Assuming the contributor referred to has “one”

The question is can the contributor count to 99 such that hands can be changed?

It appears not!!

On a positive note we have kids building on their experience gained last year plus we have added others now gaining experience including at VFL level where all contributed today

Gold Coast will be a further test - noting the evenness of the Competition hence you book wins as and when you can

King’s recovery has been impacted by a further injury restricting his ability to maintain fitness - with his shoulder alone he could maintain a fitness regime

We see Coffield off a knee procedure then compromised by a soft tissue injury

We don’t want them coming back underdone then out with further injuries

You would assume they will return when ready and not before

[Impatient Sainter]

Hamill 2 weeks.

[ace]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

By conspiracy theory you must be referring to "boosting membership sales".

[Vortex]

About a month ago harves is talking on the TV telling us that he expected him to be right for round one. Now who knows when he’s going to be right. Does anyone know what happened and when he’s actually expected to come back?

my conspiracy theory is that his return was never R1 but it was spun that way to keep a positive spin on things leading into the season opener.

Same goes King, he's now listed as 6-9 weeks away.

And I don't believe Steely will be back in 3 weeks time..

By conspiracy theory you must be referring to "boosting membership sales".

Exactly!

[MC Gusto]

You can’t rely on the weeks away on the injury list until they are ‘test’

This is the same for most, if not all, clubs

Max has been 6-9 since he first injured the shoulder

[saynta]

why is the h lower case ?
either way I'm impressed you have one.

Sure. On the internet, a nobody can be anything, a professor, an astronaut, a doctor even.

[Vortex]

You can’t rely on the weeks away on the injury list until they are ‘test’

This is the same for most, if not all, clubs

Max has been 6-9 since he first injured the shoulder

The injury happened in the first week of Xmas, 9 weeks from there means he would have been available at the end of January.

The best way to determine the turn around is a Google search for the average return at AFL level for the specific injury, then from there you can apply a variation depending on how well the rehabilitation has progressed, some can return a little earlier, some can return a little later, even a lot later if there is a complication.

Take Steely's injury for example, a broken color bone is 8-12 weeks, last year Steely came back within 5 weeks and so the fact a fairly innocuous impact event obliterated the area of the original repair I wouldn't mind betting the doctors will be a little more conservative this time around, I'm guessing at least 8 weeks out this time around, at least. Why risk his long term career when a flag is not a realistic possibility this year.

[WellardSaint]

You can’t rely on the weeks away on the injury list until they are ‘test’

This is the same for most, if not all, clubs

Max has been 6-9 since he first injured the shoulder

The injury happened in the first week of Xmas, 9 weeks from there means he would have been available at the end of January.

The best way to determine the turn around is a Google search for the average return at AFL level for the specific injury, then from there you can apply a variation depending on how well the rehabilitation has progressed, some can return a little earlier, some can return a little later, even a lot later if there is a complication.

Take Steely's injury for example, a broken color bone is 8-12 weeks, last year Steely came back within 5 weeks and so the fact a fairly innocuous impact event obliterated the area of the original repair I wouldn't mind betting the doctors will be a little more conservative this time around, I'm guessing at least 8 weeks out this time around, at least. Why risk his long term career when a flag is not a realistic possibility this year.

There's already a plate there from last time, another plate going in. I hope they hold him back an extra week or 2 for his own sake

[Scollop]

You can’t rely on the weeks away on the injury list until they are ‘test’

This is the same for most, if not all, clubs

Max has been 6-9 since he first injured the shoulder

The injury happened in the first week of Xmas, 9 weeks from there means he would have been available at the end of January.

The best way to determine the turn around is a Google search for the average return at AFL level for the specific injury, then from there you can apply a variation depending on how well the rehabilitation has progressed, some can return a little earlier, some can return a little later, even a lot later if there is a complication.

Take Steely's injury for example, a broken color bone is 8-12 weeks, last year Steely came back within 5 weeks and so the fact a fairly innocuous impact event obliterated the area of the original repair I wouldn't mind betting the doctors will be a little more conservative this time around, I'm guessing at least 8 weeks out this time around, at least. Why risk his long term career when a flag is not a realistic possibility this year.

There's already a plate there from last time, another plate going in. I hope they hold him back an extra week or 2 for his own sake

They need more flexible plates

..maybe the fact that plates are metal alloys that puts pressure on other bones and joints when there's impact.

...similarly...I remember hearing that they stopped taping up all players ankles because it created more risk of an acl injury

[mad saint guy]

I'm guessing that they sent him in for a simple arthroscope and when digging around in there they found more damage than anticipated. Some clearer communication from the club would be great though.