Unpopular opinion

[iceman]

We won’t win a GF while Callum Wilkie is in the side.

- Shocking defender 1 on 1 - does everything to avoid them
- Always plays the loose but isn’t an intercept and rebound player, allowing decent transition. Instead tends to sag back, slide across and spoil sideways at best meaning we get trapped deep.
- Takes too long with the ball then kicks sideways too much. Doesn’t take ground when he can. Allows opposition to pressure and set up.
- doesn’t work hard, can’t play on the big boys but too slow to break lines, skills can’t cut up opposition in the rebound. Is happy to cruise around and pick up junk kicks
- points fingers way too much

[Otiman]

I don't know about unpopular, but just wrong.

Are you sure you don't mean Dougal Howard?

[B.M]

Very strange opinion

3rd tall asked to be a first tall defender

And does it very well

At stages tonight he was on Brown 202 Gawn 208 and Grundy 202
And he’s 191

[Banger9798]

Wilkie was in the AA squad wasn't he?
Generally in the conversation as one of the better defenders in the league, let alone our team.

[bobmurray]

Some people shouldn't post after an afternoon on the juice.

Wilkie is not the issue, it's some of his plodding teammates, you know, the ones with dire skills that keep us in no man's land.

[Ghost Like]

Unpopular is not the descriptor I'd use for this opinion.

[The Fireman]

Lol
Has to be piss take

[bigcarl]

Very strange opinion

3rd tall asked to be a first tall defender

And does it very well

At stages tonight he was on Brown 202 Gawn 208 and Grundy 202
And he’s 191

This. Very good player who shouldn’t be our first tall defender. Simply isn’t big enough,

[happy feet]

Nuts.

[Teflon]

Lol best troll and that’s saying something cause there’s some serial getting round here ….

[Sainternist]

Unpopular and also sounding like an opinion from someone who has been on the glass BBQ. But I mean, he does go
by the sobriquet “Iceman”

[cwrcyn]

Satire.....surely

[saynta]

Unpopular and also sounding like an opinion from someone who has been on the glass BBQ. But I mean, he does go
by the sobriquet “Iceman”

WTF is a glass BBQ?

[bergsone]

Wrong

[shanegrambeau]

If you want to be unpopular, ask about Josh Battle and if he’s cut out to be a key defender

[skeptic]

You lost me after unpopular opinion

[Vortex]

You lost me after unpopular opinion

with tongue firmly planted in cheek, I might add only popular and approved opinion is allowed...[humour alert]

[skeptic]

You lost me after unpopular opinion

with tongue firmly planted in cheek, I might add only popular and approved opinion is allowed...[humour alert]

Look I’m all for it… a hot take is usually pretty interesting

But like the consensus here, based on what I’ve seen, seems way off to me.

[Vortex]

You lost me after unpopular opinion

with tongue firmly planted in cheek, I might add only popular and approved opinion is allowed...[humour alert]

Look I’m all for it… a hot take is usually pretty interesting

But like the consensus here, based on what I’ve seen, seems way off to me.

funny bones come in all different shapes and sizes I suppose

[CQ SAINT]

Iceman. First post in 6.5 years? You certainly came back with a beauty. Funny bones do come in all shapes and sizes.

[Vortex]

Iceman. First post in 6.5 years? You certainly came back with a beauty. Funny bones do come in all shapes and sizes.

Some people get it.

Hey maybe we should make this a sticky thread and put all the unpopular opinions in one place?

[CQ SAINT]

Iceman. First post in 6.5 years? You certainly came back with a beauty. Funny bones do come in all shapes and sizes.

Some people get it.

Hey maybe we should make this a sticky thread and put all the unpopular opinions in one place?

I think that you are doing a fine job of making things sticky already.

Play on.

[Vortex]

Iceman. First post in 6.5 years? You certainly came back with a beauty. Funny bones do come in all shapes and sizes.

Some people get it.

Hey maybe we should make this a sticky thread and put all the unpopular opinions in one place?

I think that you are doing a fine job of making things sticky already.

Play on.

I thought it was a great suggestion, it would give those who are sensitive to unpopular opinions the option to protect themselves by avoiding the thread.

sought of like a mini animal enclosure for the main forum.

[The Fireman]

Iceman. First post in 6.5 years? You certainly came back with a beauty. Funny bones do come in all shapes and sizes.

Some people get it.

Hey maybe we should make this a sticky thread and put all the unpopular opinions in one place?

I think that you are doing a fine job of making things sticky already.

Play on.

I thought it was a great suggestion, it would give those who are sensitive to unpopular opinions the option to protect themselves by avoiding the thread.

sought of like a mini animal enclosure for the main forum.

once again directing people on how to post. Mods ?

[Vortex]

Iceman. First post in 6.5 years? You certainly came back with a beauty. Funny bones do come in all shapes and sizes.

Some people get it.

Hey maybe we should make this a sticky thread and put all the unpopular opinions in one place?

I think that you are doing a fine job of making things sticky already.

Play on.

I thought it was a great suggestion, it would give those who are sensitive to unpopular opinions the option to protect themselves by avoiding the thread.

sought of like a mini animal enclosure for the main forum.

once again directing people on how to post. Mods ?

Not at all, it's my attempt at humour.