How many ex saint players have won a premiership?

[saints66]

Good to see Stanley get a medal, Ball was the one I felt for the most who are the players that left only to win a flag somewhere else. Spida went hunting only to come up empty .Plugger, who else?

[SaintPav]

It’s 22 according to Daniel Cherny who happens to be a mad St Kilda supporter according to a mate who is friends with him.

I wonder how this compares to other teams.

[spert]

And how many premiership players and coaches have come to St Kilda only to achieve little or no success? Lots of names I can think of- Jezza, Jewell, Barrett, Blight, Timmy, Alves, Patterson..and currently or recently Lade, Hill, Roughhead, Enright, Ratts...phew.

[Killa]

The AFL Competition being what it is, players move from Club to Club.

How many on Geelong's List hail from other Clubs?

How many on St Kilda's List hail from other Clubs, including Steele and Membrey seeking opportunity?

[CURLY]

The Jack Purse one still hurts.

[Sebastian Tombs]

What a batch of sad c***s we have here, who now spend they time on this forum talking about players who played for us, who have gone on to win a flag at another club. So out of the 1300 odd players who have played for us we get a list of 20players bar Stewart who you could make the argument would of made a huge difference in 71 all the rest on that list are what the kids today would call "spuds" .Maybe to put this list in to some prospective put up the same stat for every club

[Jacks Back]

The Jack Purse one still hurts.

[B.M]

The Ian Stewart one is the one that killed us

Changed the course of history at StK

That era we should’ve won 2 or 3

[SaintPav]

What a batch of sad c***s we have here

Ouch!

[whiskers3614]

What a batch of sad c***s we have here, who now spend they time on this forum talking about players who played for us, who have gone on to win a flag at another club. So out of the 1300 odd players who have played for us we get a list of 20players bar Stewart who you could make the argument would of made a huge difference in 71 all the rest on that list are what the kids today would call "spuds" .Maybe to put this list in to some prospective put up the same stat for every club

Russell Greene and Perovic "spuds", you obviously are either very young or not a Saints fan!

[Sebastian Tombs]

What a batch of sad c***s we have here, who now spend they time on this forum talking about players who played for us, who have gone on to win a flag at another club. So out of the 1300 odd players who have played for us we get a list of 20players bar Stewart who you could make the argument would of made a huge difference in 71 all the rest on that list are what the kids today would call "spuds" .Maybe to put this list in to some prospective put up the same stat for every club

Russell Greene and Perovic "spuds", you obviously are either very young or not a Saints

Ok Greene stays instead of winning 2 games a season , what we win 4 FFS your kidding right. Stewart leaving cost us a Flag .That twitter post shows whats wrong with the so called "supporters" of this club where are the replys defending the club? Thats why tv,radio media types treat as like a joke because no one calls them out . Have a go at a player have go at the coach but always defend the club!! The list is a complete pile of crap and doesn't deserve a thread on here

[Sebastian Tombs]

I just had a look at Rory Sackville twitter He's a "lover of everything St Kilda" well Rory me old mate instead of reposting s*** like this and feeding in too the kicking of this club, maybe leave a comment calling it out ahhh just a thought

[mr six o'clock]

Pretty sure that there would be lots of ex players from one club who won a flag with another.

[D.B.Cooper]

I just had a look at Rory Sackville twitter He's a "lover of everything St Kilda" well Rory me old mate instead of reposting s*** like this and feeding in too the kicking of this club, maybe leave a comment calling it out ahhh just a thought

Rory is a former Saints employee and a Saints tragic with a long family history at the club.

If I recall correctly Rory's great grand father is Graham Huggins?

[Sebastian Tombs]

I just had a look at Rory Sackville twitter He's a "lover of everything St Kilda" well Rory me old mate instead of reposting s*** like this and feeding in too the kicking of this club, maybe leave a comment calling it out ahhh just a thought

Rory is a former Saints employee and a Saints tragic with a long family history at the club.

If I recall correctly Rory's great grand father is Graham Huggins?

If that's the case he should know better then shouldn't he.

[D.B.Cooper]

I just had a look at Rory Sackville twitter He's a "lover of everything St Kilda" well Rory me old mate instead of reposting s*** like this and feeding in too the kicking of this club, maybe leave a comment calling it out ahhh just a thought

Rory is a former Saints employee and a Saints tragic with a long family history at the club.

If I recall correctly Rory's great grand father is Graham Huggins?

If that's the case he should know better then shouldn't he.

Perhaps he should run all his input by you to approve before he posts

[Mr Magic]

I just had a look at Rory Sackville twitter He's a "lover of everything St Kilda" well Rory me old mate instead of reposting s*** like this and feeding in too the kicking of this club, maybe leave a comment calling it out ahhh just a thought

Rory is a former Saints employee and a Saints tragic with a long family history at the club.

If I recall correctly Rory's great grand father is Graham Huggins?

No, I think his ancestor was Reuben Sackville, President of the Club during the 50's.

[D.B.Cooper]

I just had a look at Rory Sackville twitter He's a "lover of everything St Kilda" well Rory me old mate instead of reposting s*** like this and feeding in too the kicking of this club, maybe leave a comment calling it out ahhh just a thought

Rory is a former Saints employee and a Saints tragic with a long family history at the club.

If I recall correctly Rory's great grand father is Graham Huggins?

No, I think his ancestor was Reuben Sackville, President of the Club during the 50's.

Makes a bit more sense, doesn't it

Reuben Sacklunch sounds like it could be served at a New York deli.

[Sebastian Tombs]

I just had a look at Rory Sackville twitter He's a "lover of everything St Kilda" well Rory me old mate instead of reposting s*** like this and feeding in too the kicking of this club, maybe leave a comment calling it out ahhh just a thought

Rory is a former Saints employee and a Saints tragic with a long family history at the club.

If I recall correctly Rory's great grand father is Graham Huggins?

If that's the case he should know better then shouldn't he.

Perhaps he should run all his input by you to approve before he posts

What he could do is not repost stuff that piss takes our club! , what he could do is reply to the post with "well in 130yrs we have had 1300 odd players play for us , so 20 seems a pretty low number I wonder how that compares with Carlton , Collingwood , Essendon even GWS" which leaves the poster of that list no where to go

[Yorkeys]

Have not a couple of our current players been in premiership teams?

[SaintPav]

How many on Geelong's List hail from other Clubs?

Err. I think someone missed the point entirely.