Patrick Naish

[B.M]

Why have Richmond let go

Butler
Higgins
Chol

Can’t keep them all, when you’re a gun side. Sign players like Tom Lynch on 800+ When Dusty is on 800 and they have to pay Bolton, Prestia, Reiwoldt, Edwards, Cotchin, Nankervis, Lambert, Rioli, Vlaustin, Grimes

Something has to give at the other end

Question Teflon
Crouch wins his own ball

Should we have 8 Mids like him?

You have inside Mids
Crouch, Steele, Bytel
You have inside/Outside Mids
Jones, Gresham, Hannebery, Ross, Clark
Outside Mids
Billings, Hill, McKenzie

[realdeal]

Why have Richmond let go

Butler
Higgins
Chol

Can’t keep them all, when you’re a gun side. Sign players like Tom Lynch on 800+ When Dusty is on 800 and they have to pay Bolton, Prestia, Reiwoldt, Edwards, Cotchin, Nankervis, Lambert, Rioli, Vlaustin, Grimes

Something has to give at the other end

Question Teflon
Crouch wins his own ball

Should we have 8 Mids like him?

You have inside Mids
Crouch, Steele, Bytel
You have inside/Outside Mids
Jones, Gresham, Hannebery, Ross, Clark
Outside Mids
Billings, Hill, McKenzie

Richmond recruits mentioned were all traded for draft picks or left as FA... This guy was not offered a contract and then delisted.. Bit different..

Doesn't look like he's leaving Adelaide but im not against getting Talia as a proven talent to fit a purpose but im still unsure why Naish is worth getting..?

[B.M]

Chol
- they wanted to keep but couldn’t offer him a good enough contract

Higgins
- they got a future second for and traded him as they thought they had 3 small forwards ahead of him

Butler
- 4th round selection and he wasn’t getting a game at Richmond


When looking at fringe players to bring in
Go to strong clubs and look at what they have a surplus of, and see if anyone decent is not getting a game
Lipinski is a prime example

Naish
Clearly behind Edwards, Lambert and Bolton as a midfield/HF runner.

Could add depth and ball use on a wing or Hf

[Mr Magic]

Is Naish more value to us (in 2022) than Dunstan?

[wally]

Was Naish getting a game in the second half of season? They recruited Parker in mid season draft and played him and recontracted him .Naish must be considered behind Parker

[DJ Higgins]

Was Naish getting a game in the second half of season? They recruited Parker in mid season draft and played him and recontracted him .Naish must be considered behind Parker

exactly what i was thinking, Dropped Naish but picked up Parker. Naish will be another Lonie, too good for VFL not good enough for AFL. Unless he came cheap and didn't take up a spot from someone else he would be back up at best but we already have enough back up players

[saynta]

Has he been heard from in recent times? I always thought Jaxons was Ameet Bains...

I have not heard from Jaxons for a long time. I hope he has not left. Saintsational is good at eating it’s own. No need to name the usual suspects.

The members of the forum obsessed with their status’s chased him off I think… just kept abusing him and carrying on as though he claimed to be a messiah

Most of those forumites have since been banned though one of the top dogs is still carrying on

It’s disappointing as guys like Jaxons made the site
All because some hate the fact people may know more than them....
Anyhow let’s hope he comes back

Yes the protected species here that can do no wrong in the eyes of the mods.

Protected species? That is pretty offensive and demeaning to BFUSA.

[B.M]

Very different player to Dunstan

If he comes it will be as a developing Wing/HF

If Ross goes, might be a wing back up

[Impatient Sainter]

He will provide outside speed not unlike Brett Peake, some players are just not contested ball winners but offer other strengths.

[older saint]

delisted free agent costs nothing and cheaper and more upside than say a Lonie or Kent surely.

[Teflon]

Why have Richmond let go

Butler
Higgins
Chol

Can’t keep them all, when you’re a gun side. Sign players like Tom Lynch on 800+ When Dusty is on 800 and they have to pay Bolton, Prestia, Reiwoldt, Edwards, Cotchin, Nankervis, Lambert, Rioli, Vlaustin, Grimes

Something has to give at the other end

Question Teflon
Crouch wins his own ball

Should we have 8 Mids like him?

You have inside Mids
Crouch, Steele, Bytel
You have inside/Outside Mids
Jones, Gresham, Hannebery, Ross, Clark
Outside Mids
Billings, Hill, McKenzie

Did Richmond delist those players????????????
BIG difference between trading
And not wanting
But your BM ..,you knew that...,

[Teflon]

Has he been heard from in recent times? I always thought Jaxons was Ameet Bains...

I have not heard from Jaxons for a long time. I hope he has not left. Saintsational is good at eating it’s own. No need to name the usual suspects.

The members of the forum obsessed with their status’s chased him off I think… just kept abusing him and carrying on as though he claimed to be a messiah

Most of those forumites have since been banned though one of the top dogs is still carrying on

It’s disappointing as guys like Jaxons made the site
All because some hate the fact people may know more than them....
Anyhow let’s hope he comes back

Yes the protected species here that can do no wrong in the eyes of the mods.

Protected species? That is pretty offensive and demeaning to BFUSA.

Well you better run along and do your usual “dobbing” on posters you’re good at that
Maybe they’ll throw you a biscuit

[Teflon]

Was Naish getting a game in the second half of season? They recruited Parker in mid season draft and played him and recontracted him .Naish must be considered behind Parker

exactly what i was thinking, Dropped Naish but picked up Parker. Naish will be another Lonie, too good for VFL not good enough for AFL. Unless he came cheap and didn't take up a spot from someone else he would be back up at best but we already have enough back up players

Correct and again from Tigers fans can not win his own ball
We can’t carry more of these types
And his decision making is ok at best
Big no for mine

[B.M]

Who are all these back up players???

Name 3 back up Mids?

[Teflon]

Who are all these back up players???

Name 3 back up Mids?

Who are you talking to?

[Teflon]

He will provide outside speed not unlike Brett Peake, some players are just not contested ball winners but offer other strengths.

His foot skills /decision making ain’t elite
He’ll be another who goes missing in gsmes

[happy feet]

Has he been heard from in recent times? I always thought Jaxons was Ameet Bains...

I have not heard from Jaxons for a long time. I hope he has not left. Saintsational is good at eating it’s own. No need to name the usual suspects.

The members of the forum obsessed with their status’s chased him off I think… just kept abusing him and carrying on as though he claimed to be a messiah

Most of those forumites have since been banned though one of the top dogs is still carrying on

It’s disappointing as guys like Jaxons made the site
All because some hate the fact people may know more than them....
Anyhow let’s hope he comes back

Yes the protected species here that can do no wrong in the eyes of the mods.

Protected species? That is pretty offensive and demeaning to BFUSA.

Well you better run along and do your usual “dobbing” on posters you’re good at that
Maybe they’ll throw you a biscuit

Oh well here comes another ban…..

[magnifisaint]

If he costs nothing then why not. Could be better than Lonie.

[wally]

So what is Byrnes actual preferred position as I haven’t seen his name mentioned in this discussion.Is he midfield rotation or forward ? Naish has a lot of blokes in front of him if we just want depth would rather they kept Clav

[Teflon]

Has he been heard from in recent times? I always thought Jaxons was Ameet Bains...

I have not heard from Jaxons for a long time. I hope he has not left. Saintsational is good at eating it’s own. No need to name the usual suspects.

The members of the forum obsessed with their status’s chased him off I think… just kept abusing him and carrying on as though he claimed to be a messiah

Most of those forumites have since been banned though one of the top dogs is still carrying on

It’s disappointing as guys like Jaxons made the site
All because some hate the fact people may know more than them....
Anyhow let’s hope he comes back

Yes the protected species here that can do no wrong in the eyes of the mods.

Protected species? That is pretty offensive and demeaning to BFUSA.

Well you better run along and do your usual “dobbing” on posters you’re good at that
Maybe they’ll throw you a biscuit

Oh well here comes another ban…..

Yes...well if I don’t see you again....all the best!!

[sainterinsydney]

My dad and I met Naish at the draft when it was up here in Sydney. We got Coffield and Clark's autograph, and my dad separately got Naish's autograph. Besides our boys, was the only other player my dad had a talk with. We both feel like it is almost fated Saints will sign him up. I think Naish is worth a punt

[saynta]

Has he been heard from in recent times? I always thought Jaxons was Ameet Bains...

I have not heard from Jaxons for a long time. I hope he has not left. Saintsational is good at eating it’s own. No need to name the usual suspects.

The members of the forum obsessed with their status’s chased him off I think… just kept abusing him and carrying on as though he claimed to be a messiah

Most of those forumites have since been banned though one of the top dogs is still carrying on

It’s disappointing as guys like Jaxons made the site
All because some hate the fact people may know more than them....
Anyhow let’s hope he comes back

Yes the protected species here that can do no wrong in the eyes of the mods.

Protected species? That is pretty offensive and demeaning to BFUSA.

Well you better run along and do your usual “dobbing” on posters you’re good at that
Maybe they’ll throw you a biscuit

Really? Should have dobbed on you for all the insults you have directed my way. Maybe I will in future.

Anyway pot kettle black. And you know what I mean by that.

See that your little buddy still has his knickers knotted too.

[terry smith rules]

Seriously I cannot believe we would be interested in Naish

When the Tigers could barely field a mid field through all the injuries he could still hardly get a game.

We don’t need another smallish lightly built player, did anyone from our club watch the grand final. It is all about big explosive players, if you were going to take a player cheaply then Hamish Hartlett (probably too old but ..) or Powell Pepper (could be available)

[B.M]

Is Tom Landon a big explosive mid?

[terry smith rules]

Is Tom Landon a big explosive mid?

I think you mean Ed Langdon!!

No. But there is one important difference Langdon can run all day. Can Naish.

Now Ross has resigned we don’t need anymore outside players.

My point re explosive mids is that is what we need ( and yes they don’t grow on trees. So let’s plant our own seeds rather than recycling)