Votes v Swans

[Scollop]

4 Wilkie - amazing job. Impossible task. zero goals and almost zero marks against you.
3 Steele - does everything
2 Sinclair - does many things
2 Highmore - does the right thing
2 Webster - ony lost your feet twice today. Well done Jimmy that's why you are in the votes
2 Membrey - team player

See reply to bangaulegend

[Scollop]

5. Marshall. That Hickey bloke goes alright, but bid Roh was outstanding around the ground, despite a couple of brain fades.
4. Steele. Stating the bleeding obvious.
3. Wilkie. The league's longest serving rookie? Gave Buddy a huge start in height, weight and reputation and towelled him up!
2. Sinclair. No longer the one trick pony, one of the game's best rebounding defenders.
1. Kent. Could have gone to plenty of others but Dean gets it just to ram it up the numerous posters that blatantly ignore forum rules by badmouthing him. Tonight he displayed the qualities he was recruited for.

Sainter_Dad won’t be happy

[CarlD]

5 Steele
4 Marshall
3 Sinclair
2 Higgins
1 Wilkie

[Sainter_Dad]

5. Jack Steele is a machine
2 Wilke what more can I say
2 Higgins a breath of fresh air
2. Marshall worked his arse off
2.Sinclair the most improved player on our list IMO
1. Mc Kenzie Clean & tough
1.Coffield back to what he does best
Apologies to the rest but great team effort

Sainter_Dad needs to copy votes onto a spreadsheet and I think he’s asked quite a few times that people don’t add comments next to their votes because it makes it too hard to transfer them directly. Try and keep the commentary separate.

Comments are okay - it is quoting other peoples votes ad nauseum when commenting on them that means that I do not know if people are quoting to agree or to disparage. Particularly when two posters get into a Slanging match and the thread ends up 50 posts long - but only 20are legitimate votes

[Scollop]

5. Jack Steele is a machine
2 Wilke what more can I say
2 Higgins a breath of fresh air
2. Marshall worked his arse off
2.Sinclair the most improved player on our list IMO
1. Mc Kenzie Clean & tough
1.Coffield back to what he does best
Apologies to the rest but great team effort

Sainter_Dad needs to copy votes onto a spreadsheet and I think he’s asked quite a few times that people don’t add comments next to their votes because it makes it too hard to transfer them directly. Try and keep the commentary separate.

Comments are okay - it is quoting other peoples votes ad nauseum when commenting on them that means that I do not know if people are quoting to agree or to disparage.

Are you doing it manually

[Sainter_Dad]

Sainter_Dad needs to copy votes onto a spreadsheet and I think he’s asked quite a few times that people don’t add comments next to their votes because it makes it too hard to transfer them directly. Try and keep the commentary separate.

Comments are okay - it is quoting other peoples votes ad nauseum when commenting on them that means that I do not know if people are quoting to agree or to disparage.

Are you doing it manually

LOL - to give away trade secrets - yes - kind of!

I have a spreadsheet that has all the rounds.
I copy each legitimate post and paste as text in Column A
Add a column and number it from 1 to X
Re-sort by the new column B
Find and replace "-" and "."
Re-sort by column B
Replace the incorrectly spelled names
Add 5-4-3-2-1 to the people who have listed 5 players but no votes
Re-sort back to original order
Copy the entire column of name
Re-sort the new column
Remove duplicates
Check there are no incorrect names in the new list
Use =sumif(function)
Total Votes
Copy the results
Paste as Values
Resort the list by votes - Highest to Lowest
Copy the top 5 and renumber 5-4-3-2-1
Post the results

Then use the BBC coding as below to create a table
|Player|1|2|3|4|5|6|7|8|9|10|11|12|13|15|16|17|18|19|20|21|22|23|Behinds|Total|
....
Max King||2|1|5|1||2|1|1|||1|2|2|2|3|1|6|4||||26|34|

And post that to the tally thread

[Scollop]

Sainter_Dad needs to copy votes onto a spreadsheet and I think he’s asked quite a few times that people don’t add comments next to their votes because it makes it too hard to transfer them directly. Try and keep the commentary separate.

Comments are okay - it is quoting other peoples votes ad nauseum when commenting on them that means that I do not know if people are quoting to agree or to disparage.

Are you doing it manually

LOL - to give away trade secrets - yes - kind of!

I have a spreadsheet that has all the rounds.
I copy each legitimate post and paste as text in Column A
Add a column and number it from 1 to X
Re-sort by the new column B
Find and replace "-" and "."
Re-sort by column B
Replace the incorrectly spelled names
Add 5-4-3-2-1 to the people who have listed 5 players but no votes
Re-sort back to original order
Copy the entire column of name
Re-sort the new column
Remove duplicates
Check there are no incorrect names in the new list
Use =sumif(function)
Total Votes
Copy the results
Paste as Values
Resort the list by votes - Highest to Lowest
Copy the top 5 and renumber 5-4-3-2-1
Post the results

Then use the BBC coding as below to create a table
|Player|1|2|3|4|5|6|7|8|9|10|11|12|13|15|16|17|18|19|20|21|22|23|Behinds|Total|
....
Max King||2|1|5|1||2|1|1|||1|2|2|2|3|1|6|4||||26|34|

And post that to the tally thread

Love it

Thanks for your work SD

[bangaulegend]

5. Jack Steele is a machine
2 Wilke what more can I say
2 Higgins a breath of fresh air
2. Marshall worked his arse off
2.Sinclair the most improved player on our list IMO
1. Mc Kenzie Clean & tough
1.Coffield back to what he does best
Apologies to the rest but great team effort

Sainter_Dad needs to copy votes onto a spreadsheet and I think he’s asked quite a few times that people don’t add comments next to their votes because it makes it too hard to transfer them directly. Try and keep the commentary separate.

Sorry I didn't know we had the vote police patrolling this site.

[Sanctorum]

5. Jack Steele
4. Rowan Marshall
3. Zak Jones
2. Callum Wilkie
1.Jack Sinclair

[Banger9798]

Yep great work Sainter Dad

[Scollop]

5 Steele
3 McKenzie
2 Sinclair
2 Hill
1 Webster
1 Higgins
1 Marshall

Apologies to Wilkie, Coff, Dunny, Seb, Skunk and the Kent. I thought Leo, Ronnie and Cooper were all good contributors

Everyone played their part and no passengers, which is what we want to see every week

[Gershwin]

5. Steele
4. Sinclair
3. Wilkie
2. Higgins
1. Highmore

[MCG-Unit]

5 - Steele
4 - Marshall
1 - McKenzie
1 - Kent
1 - Sinclair
1 - Higgins
1 - Jones
1 - Wilkie

[George27]

5. Steele
3. Sinclair
2. Wilkie
2. Higgins
2. Marshall
1. McKenzie

Kudos also to Highmore and Coffield who were part of an excellent defence.

[6621104]

5. Steele
4. Sinclair
3. Higgins
2.Highmore
1. Coffield

with apologies to pretty much everyone else (even Seb and Butler)

[minneapolis]

4 Wilkie - amazing job. Impossible task. zero goals and almost zero marks against you.
3 Steele - does everything
2 Sinclair - does many things
2 Highmore - does the right thing
2 Webster - ony lost your feet twice today. Well done Jimmy that's why you are in the votes
2 Membrey - team player

See reply to bangaulegend

Hi. I have never seen any request to not include comments.

And SD just said that comments are OK.

Guess you are just trying to keep things tidy.

[terry smith rules]

5 Steele
3 Wilkie
2 Coffield
2 Higgins
2 Marshall
1 Sinclair

[skeptic]

5. Steele
4. Wilkie
3. Marshall
2. Higgins
1. Sinclair

[SemperFidelis]

5. Man of Steele
4. Snags
3. Wilkie
1. Tim
1. Hill
1. Zak

[Sainter_Dad]

156 Steele
73.5 Marshall
66 Higgins
63 Wilkie
60 Sinclair
16 McKenzie
8 Webster
7 Coffield
7 Highmore
6 Jones
6 Kent
5.5 Hill
3 Membrey
3 Sharman

Therefore:
5 Steele
4 Marshall
3 Higgins
2 Wilkie
1 Sinclair