key position player

Saints58 · Post: # 1879409Post **Saints58** » Fri 23 Oct 2020 8:36pm

I think we should go after a player like josh Schache from bulldogs I know he hasn't played much but he is 23 199cm 94kg 56 games can play forward and back he would be great as a replacement for Carlile who is 30 next season if he even stays with us.
If the bulldogs wont a small from us like a hind or Sinclair we should make a deal.

Joffa Burns · Fri 23 Oct 2020 10:18pm

If we go a fringe KPP I'd rather trade for Peter Wright.

Genuine ruckman key forward size and has the hunger for another crack.
Undoubted talent and knows where he has gone wrong and desperate to show he can play.

Could be a dud but gut feel tells me he could also be a steal.

Ghost Like · Fri 23 Oct 2020 10:39pm

Yep, Two Metre for me.

Ironically both players suffer from the same negative, a lack of urgency, an inability to get the most from themselves.

Schache has now failed this at two clubs, suggesting he may never realise his potential.

Let's see if a change of scenery can draw the necessary vigour from Wright - he can ruck, mark & kick. Three up on Longer already!

Fri 23 Oct 2020 10:54pm

Tom McDonald from Melbourne for me.

Was a great key back before being moved forward.

Not a terrible forward either.

Could be CHB and swing forward if needed.

Being able to have Battle and McDonald would give us options.

I really liked 2 Metre Peter in his draft year and if he agreed to learn ruck craft for a year then I would happily give him a 3 year contract.

saintbob · Post: # 1879440Post **saintbob** » Fri 23 Oct 2020 11:48pm

I reckon we start poking around the Lions, with the imminent arrival of Daniher they maybe looking to off load a tall.

Payne, McStay, or Gardiner

Moods · Post: # 1879441Post **Moods** » Sat 24 Oct 2020 12:10am

BackFromUSA wrote: ↑Fri 23 Oct 2020 10:54pm Tom McDonald from Melbourne for me.

Was a great key back before being moved forward.

Not a terrible forward either.

Could be CHB and swing forward if needed.

Being able to have Battle and McDonald would give us options.

Absolutely. He had a terrible year but let's remember, this guy can play. And he's not a drop kick either. Comes from a great family. Read an article the other day in which he admitted he bulked up too much this year when in actuality he's an aerobic beast. Bulked up on advice from certain ppl within the club who believed he needed to get stronger to be able to take more contested marks. He plans to trim down and get his running game back next year. Would be a sensational get and a perfect replacement for Carlisle, even if Carlisle does stay - would make him work for the position. Means that Battles could play 3rd tall fwd or play on the 3rd tall fwd down back. Gives real flexibility and strength

bigcarl · Post: # 1879442Post **bigcarl** » Sat 24 Oct 2020 12:11am

I’d like another class ruckman to help Ryder out and allow Marshall to make CHF his own. Is two-metre Peter up to it as a ruckman?

Saints58 · Post: # 1879516Post **Saints58** » Sat 24 Oct 2020 2:44pm

well some very good suggestions i like the McDonald one he has been there before and would be great back battle could be anything and it does allow us to be flexible where we play battle.
We still need a ruckman I don't think McKernan is the answer Brisbane might be an idea as they do have a lot of bigs at both ends of the ground and we really got shown up in that department against them and west coast.

Saints58 · Post: # 1879517Post **Saints58** » Sat 24 Oct 2020 2:47pm

how about his brother Oscar he is 24 as well we are great at making deals with clubs would be a good fit.

saynta · Post: # 1879519Post **saynta** » Sat 24 Oct 2020 3:06pm

Chill out people. The club knows what it is doing.

Ghost Like · Sat 24 Oct 2020 3:26pm

Saints58 wrote: ↑Sat 24 Oct 2020 2:47pm how about his brother Oscar he is 24 as well we are great at making deals with clubs would be a good fit.

If it's the Sesame Street character, maybe. If it's the Melbourne player, definitely not!

saynta · Post: # 1879526Post **saynta** » Sat 24 Oct 2020 3:39pm

Ghost Like wrote: ↑Sat 24 Oct 2020 3:26pm
Saints58 wrote: ↑Sat 24 Oct 2020 2:47pm how about his brother Oscar he is 24 as well we are great at making deals with clubs would be a good fit.
If it's the Sesame Street character, maybe. If it's the Melbourne player, definitely not!

Sanctorum · Post: # 1879528Post **Sanctorum** » Sat 24 Oct 2020 3:39pm

saynta wrote: ↑Sat 24 Oct 2020 3:06pm Chill out people. The club knows what it is doing.

That's right saynta, though initially a bit surprised, I was impressed with the move on Brad Crouch, a player who is going to improve the team immediately, he would easily walk into any of the other clubs.

With the stated objective by the club to bring in players who will have an immediate impact, as with the "Fabulous Five" this time last year, I have no doubt that the others on their radar will be of high quality.

Which is why I'd be surprised if they select McKernan because he's hardly going to be in the "list improvement" category, unlike 2 metre Peter who most definitely would, given his age (24) and potential replacement for Paddy Ryder.

The upcoming trade and drafts windows will be fascinating, exciting times!

Saintmike65 · Sat 24 Oct 2020 4:05pm

The need is for a strong bodied tall defender that can compete physically one on one with the key forwards like Lynch and Hawkins...needs to fit the right age demographic so McStay or Payne from Brisbane would be a good fit!

saint6709 · Post: # 1879549Post **saint6709** » Sat 24 Oct 2020 5:31pm

Saintmike65 wrote: ↑Sat 24 Oct 2020 4:05pm The need is for a strong bodied tall defender that can compete physically one on one with the key forwards like Lynch and Hawkins...needs to fit the right age demographic so McStay or Payne from Brisbane would be a good fit!

I like the idea of turning Schache into a defender - may be dreaming that he can turn into a defender - but has the size and supposedly the athleticism

Saints58 · Post: # 1879906Post **Saints58** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 10:06am

What about Ratugolea now that Geelong is getting Cameron Ratugolea playing time will be reduced he would be a good fit age at 22 197cm

saynta · Post: # 1879935Post **saynta** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 12:05pm

Saints58 wrote: ↑Mon 26 Oct 2020 10:06am What about Ratugolea now that Geelong is getting Cameron Ratugolea playing time will be reduced he would be a good fit age at 22 197cm

From the age.com.au

""(McKernan) is one of a few guys," St Kilda list manager James Gallagher told Trade Radio.

"He's obviously finished up at Essendon. There are a few marking forward types that are either out of contract or finishing up at their current clubs and we've made a number of phone calls to their managers over the past few weeks.

"I reckon we are a little bit exposed if we get the wrong injury in the wrong spot. That's not necessarily just with Max King."

Gershwin · Post: # 1879941Post **Gershwin** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 1:13pm

saynta wrote: ↑Sat 24 Oct 2020 3:06pm Chill out people. The club knows what it is doing.

We are helping.

Beno88 · Post: # 1879945Post **Beno88** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 1:15pm

Saints58 wrote: ↑Sat 24 Oct 2020 2:47pm how about his brother Oscar he is 24 as well we are great at making deals with clubs would be a good fit.

Quite possibly the worst player in the AFL.

Saint 58 · Post: # 1879971Post **Saint 58** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 4:22pm

Jarrod Brander is the one we should be chasing
I think he's going to develop in a excellent key defender

Wet Toast owe us big time
We drafted Cripps at 16, a clear best 22 player
He requested a trade back west & has played about 150 games, kicked 200 goals for them
We got peanuts for him (40's draft pick I think)

Vortex · Post: # 1879972Post **Vortex** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 4:32pm

Gershwin wrote: ↑Mon 26 Oct 2020 1:13pm
saynta wrote: ↑Sat 24 Oct 2020 3:06pm Chill out people. The club knows what it is doing.
We are helping.

How can we not be, if Gags isn't logging into SS on an hourly basis during this time of year then he should give himself an uppercut.

Iansaint · Post: # 1879974Post **Iansaint** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 4:34pm

Bailey Williams (WCE).....great leap, good grab, athletic, skillful & peninsula boy. (his dad was StK reserves player late 80's/early 90's?)
Perfect future pairing with Marshall alternating ruck/key fwd. Played a few games in 2nd year at eagles in 2020. Get!

maverick · Post: # 1879976Post **maverick** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 4:35pm

Would we swap pick 15 for Gunston?
Borderline IMO

Impatient Sainter · Mon 26 Oct 2020 5:21pm

Saint 58 wrote: ↑Mon 26 Oct 2020 4:22pm Jarrod Brander is the one we should be chasing
I think he's going to develop in a excellent key defender

Wet Toast owe us big time
We drafted Cripps at 16, a clear best 22 player
He requested a trade back west & has played about 150 games, kicked 200 goals for them
We got peanuts for him (40's draft pick I think)

You are onto something - according to a BF intk the club has held some discussions with Brander. The boy from Bendigo/Mildura I think we see him as a tall who can play forward or back - be an interesting addition.

Saint 58 · Post: # 1880043Post **Saint 58** » Mon 26 Oct 2020 10:06pm

Impatient Sainter wrote: ↑Mon 26 Oct 2020 5:21pm
Saint 58 wrote: ↑Mon 26 Oct 2020 4:22pm Jarrod Brander is the one we should be chasing
I think he's going to develop in a excellent key defender

Wet Toast owe us big time
We drafted Cripps at 16, a clear best 22 player
He requested a trade back west & has played about 150 games, kicked 200 goals for them
We got peanuts for him (40's draft pick I think)
You are onto something - according to a BF intk the club has held some discussions with Brander. The boy from Bendigo/Mildura I think we see him as a tall who can play forward or back - be an interesting addition.

I won’t say that I know something

Hoping it happens !
I think he plays a bit like Carlisle

key position player

key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player

Re: key position player