Team v Eagles

[kosifantutti]

IN: Hind, King, Membrey
OUT: Abbott (omitted), Marsh (omitted), Phillips (omitted)

[saintsRrising]

So the Carlisle mystery continues

[BackFromUSA]

And Coffield doubtful. Emergencies are?

[samuraisaint]

Who's going to play on Kennedy and Darling?

[bangaulegend]

No Jake the snake ?

[saintsRrising]

EMERG: Dylan Roberton Shane Savage Jonathon Marsh Jake Carlisle

Well that is an emergencies list full of defenders. 3 of them tall. Late change anyone?

[kosifantutti]

And Coffield doubtful. Emergencies are?

Roberton, Savage, Marsh, Carlisle

[saintsRrising]

Rain is forecast, but closer to the game if the rain does not look too bad I would expect one more tall defender to play.

Hawks game was meant to wet, but was dry.

[Impatient Sainter]

EMERG: Dylan Roberton Shane Savage Jonathon Marsh Jake Carlisle

Well that is an emergencies list full of defenders. 3 of them tall. Late change anyone?

Think you are on the money!

[bangaulegend]

And Coffield doubtful. Emergencies are?

Roberton, Savage, Marsh, Carlisle

Sounds like Coffs won't get up so probably a late withdrawal . Savage IMO to come in if Coff is out

[saintsRrising]

ST KILDA
In: M.King, T.Membrey, N.Hind
Out: R.Abbott (omitted), J.Marsh (omitted), E.Phillips (omitted)

WEST COAST
In: W.Schofield, S.Hurn, J.Brander, J.Petruccelle, N.Naitanui, H.Brayshaw
Out: T.Hickey (omitted), L.Jetta (calf), D.Sheed (hamstring), M.Hutchings (hamstring), J.Redden (thumb), B.Ah Chee (finger)
New: Hamish Brayshaw

[George27]

The part I do not understand is that Butler, Kent, Lonie and Hind are all in. With King, Battle, Membrey and ( for at least part of the game ) Marshall/Ryder up there, it will be very crowded !

I wonder if Hind will play on the wing . Or is Battle playing in defence ? Or both of the above !

[Secret Kiel]

If Coff doesn't come up it will be Marsh who gets the nod. Savage and Robbo are listed to comply with AFL rules.

Marsh to the forward line and Battle to take Coffs spot is how it will roll.

[Bowey Boy]

I see “Love Bite” is out for the Eagles.

[The_Dud]

Would really love to know what Carlisle has/hasn’t done.

We caught a break in the ruck with Hickey our and NicNat in!

[kosifantutti]

[skeptic]

The part I do not understand is that Butler, Kent, Lonie and Hind are all in. With King, Battle, Membrey and ( for at least part of the game ) Marshall/Ryder up there, it will be very crowded !

I wonder if Hind will play on the wing . Or is Battle playing in defence ? Or both of the above !

One has to imagine that Battle goes back.

Selection has been a mystery for me for a while. My concern is that the all signs point to a bomb it forward to King and let the small feast on the crumbs strategy.

Not one that I’m particularly found of

[terry smith rules]

Really concerned with our backline

WCE have the obvious Darling and Kennedy, but add Allen and Waterman and I think we are 1 short (literally) in defence

Maybe they are banking on a wet slippery track and if not late changes

[stevie]

Kennedy didn’t play v bullfrogs He’s not playing tomorrow night either So no need to plan for him

[Secret Kiel]

Really concerned with our backline

WCE have the obvious Darling and Kennedy, but add Allen and Waterman and I think we are 1 short (literally) in defence

Maybe they are banking on a wet slippery track and if not late changes

As always it will be the midfield that gets the job done and never a better time to take the win. Gaff and Kelly versus Steele and Ross so that contest could go either way. If we can get one more midfilder to stand up then things could swing in our favour. Enter Sincs. Time for him to be that player. He's been going ok and building to something so he should be excited about a Thursday showtime slot.

[bigcarl]

Kennedy didn’t play v bullfrogs He’s not playing tomorrow night either So no need to plan for him

I don’t know where you got that from. He’s a worry and probably the man most likely to kick a bag. Needs a strong contested player on him. Maybe Battle

[stevie]

Sorry my bad Didn’t realise he played last game carry on lol

[ace]

So the Carlisle mystery continues

No mystery, he is an emergency, which means he is capable to play, but not wanted in the team.
That with having to handle both Kennedy & Darling.
Howard gets one, Wilkie gets the other with maybe Battle as replacement if one is getting slaughtered.

[samuraisaint]

Maybe his back issue has flared up again?

Would be nice to find out? Tony74?

[ace]

Damn, why can't Nic Nat wait another game, it would have been nice to monster Hickey.