Carlisle

[footynut]

Why do we play him forward at times? I realise he wants to play down back, but some times you have to do what's best for the team.

Proved at the Bommers he can play Forward.

We could give Maxie a rest, play Carlisle forward and Battle down back or bring in Clavarino or Robertson.

[skeptic]

Either way, needs to come back in IMO

[longtimesaint]

He will come back in.
He was only left out as there wasn’t a third tall forward and to get more run for the Alice ground.

[The Fireman]

I would have him in everytime.

[Gershwin]

Our best CHB at the moment but hopeless up forward.

[johnearljames]

I think he will get traded at the end of the year. Gut feel.

[Gershwin]

I think he will get traded at the end of the year. Gut feel.

There won't be a skerrick of interest from other clubs.

[johnearljames]

I think he will get traded at the end of the year. Gut feel.

There won't be a skerrick of interest from other clubs.

You reckon?
A ready made CHB with 3-4 years left?

[saynta]

no we will keep him

[shanegrambeau]

I would have him in everytime.

Yep
Leaving him out was a disaster. Mind you, our defence has been overwhelmed with him too.

Sorely missed as a pinch hitter in the forward line last week. Would have given May and Goodwin something more to think about than Hind or Kent for sure.

[samuraisaint]

He probably needed a rest - I know he also missed against Essendon - but the guy had a very major, major operation on his back last year, and came back underdone.

Week off would have done him a power of good - probably cost us the four points last week, but can't change that now.

Let's hope he plays a blinder and we win by ten goals Sunday.

[Trev from the Bush]

I think he will get traded at the end of the year. Gut feel.

Get some antacids into you.

The bunion on my left foot is telling me he stays.

[johnearljames]

I think he will get traded at the end of the year. Gut feel.

Get some antacids into you.

The bunion on my left foot is telling me he stays.

Hmm. We will see.

[BadRossco]

Undoubtedly a reasonable player, but very petulant will not put in if moved forward and quick to put up the shutters if things start to go down hill, other clubs are most likely aware of this so I guess he is a keeper.

[Trev from the Bush]

I think he will get traded at the end of the year. Gut feel.

Get some antacids into you.

The bunion on my left foot is telling me he stays.

Hmm. We will see.

Got any inside info Ted?

[SunnyErnest]

According to Bigfooty Carlisle is on the Trade Table.....

[skeptic]

It’s popped up on Facebook too

Apparently it’s attitude related

[SaintPav]

How would anyone really know?

They probably don't have a match up for him this week.

[Teflon]

Can’t defend 1 on 1 doesn’t apply any body and if his attitude is shyte no probs trade away
We can cover Carlisle- time to blood some other tall defenders in our list
And if it lands us a very handy mid or 2 ....I’m in

[Secret Kiel]

Carlisle is incredibly important to our side, it is no coincidence that we lose when he doesn't play.

Howard has been a liability at times and so without Jake down back our backline is vulnerable and with Kingy being a work in progress Battle has to go forward often further exposing Howard.

[Harves Man]

Our best CHB at the moment but hopeless up forward.

I'm genuinely unsure why it is you think this, Gershwin?

[asiu]

i’m in the ... see ya later ya sook , camp.

i’m not into his petulance
and or his piss poor body language

feed him to the pigs

10 pounds in one minute they can eat

[Secret Kiel]

Our best CHB at the moment but hopeless up forward.

I'm genuinely unsure why it is you think this, Gershwin?

Umm...because he is.

[shanegrambeau]

Something must be up, that we are not aware of.
Wasn't his Mrs having a kid?

Something family or some non-footy thing. Dsicipline? Training miss? Something must be up.

[Winmar]

My recollection a couple of weeks ago was that his wife/partner was going to have a kid in NSW