Has Carlisle Given Clavarino His Chance

[shanegrambeau]

Poor form from Carlisle - but I would be risking the $250.00 to call Rampe out for his hitting [of King etc] and draw attention to it. [And it is a cheap one to make a stand and not be pushed over - especially after we rolled over on the Murphy issue]

Mnnn...
A conscious calculated risk?

Fair enough.
Carlisle must have some confidence, which is good to see.
1) he knows he is January Picture on the “wayward boy St Kilda calendar” already
2) he knows that the Scott brothers and big Nick really started this thing way back..
3) he knows he will he looked down upon but

Yes
Rampe does get called out a bit
Umpires will now know that King is getting picked on, as it were, and this does have an effect. So the gambit is, King being young, has more to gain, and thus St Kilda, than Carlisle has to lose?

Interesting but maybe right?

[CURLY]

How do people like Wilson still have a job talking about sport? Why is she still ‘relevant’?

Wilson backed up by Hutchy what a pair of arse clowns

[Secret Kiel]

Football fans are fickle.

It feels like Saints supporters have never really got around Jake, and the club possibly didn't help with the way the Murphy bruhaha was handled/perceived. But the bottom line is he is invested and waves the flag the ole fashioned way.

I've never got the chatter about possible trades. Ludicrous. Possibly the same knuckleheads that carry on about Hanners and Sebby. And talk about who was the first big fish landed, it was Jakey waaay before Hanners, so maybe Jake is a visionary too and could see the club was going places long before the short sighted crew ever did.

Happy he plays for us.

[The_Dud]

It was the wrong thing to do, was never going to end well, everyone (including Jake) knows that.

If it was an opposition player doing it to one of ours most of you would be blowing up about it.

Cop the tiny fine, could have been worse, and move on, hopefully learning a lesson.

[kosifantutti]

Even worse according to Caro, was that Jake did not give the ball back to the boundary umpire a few minutes later. Rub him out for life!

[saintsRrising]

Even worse according to Caro, was that Jake did not give the ball back to the boundary umpire a few minutes later. Rub him out for life!

Yes I saw that too. I have never done the stats, but I would imagine off the top off my head that most players do not give the ball back to the umpire.

[CURLY]

Even worse according to Caro, was that Jake did not give the ball back to the boundary umpire a few minutes later. Rub him out for life!

He nearly had to kick it back from the crowd the ball was that far out of bounds.

[kosifantutti]

Even worse according to Caro, was that Jake did not give the ball back to the boundary umpire a few minutes later. Rub him out for life!

Yes I saw that too. I have never done the stats, but I would imagine off the top off my head that most players do not give the ball back to the umpire.

Rampe at about 9:30 to go in the first quarter. But he had a sore hand after belting Max King.

[Mr Magic]

Even worse according to Caro, was that Jake did not give the ball back to the boundary umpire a few minutes later. Rub him out for life!

Yes I saw that too. I have never done the stats, but I would imagine off the top off my head that most players do not give the ball back to the umpire.

Rampe at about 9:30 to go in the first quarter. But he had a sore hand after belting Max King.

That's my issue with this whole thing
I didn't like what I saw Carlisle doing.
BUT where is the consistency in outrage? Rampe, with his injured hand, was caught on vision using that same ínjured' hand to punch Max King off the ball - probably learned how to do it from Barry Hall

Where is the outrage of the blatant dive Papley took to try and milk a free?
I

[johnearljames]

Carlisle will keep doing silly things. Just who he is it seems. Like tossing the ball away from the boundary ump. Grow up Jake. Saints are better than that.

[Scollop]

It’s not an issue in anyone else’s mind except Caroline Wilson and....yours. He’s not obligated to hand the ball to the boundary umpire. When there is a stoppage, some players pick up the footy and hand it back to the ump and some players leave it on the ground

Speaking of players taking a dive...that reminds me of that softy ex-captain that plays for Carlton.

Carlisle had a go at Murphy and according to Carro, Jake made ‘misogynistic’ slurs. Therefore Carro can never forgive Jake and she’ll be seeking revenge at every opportunity on behalf of all women.

[saynta]

It’s not an issue in anyone else’s mind except Caroline Wilson and....yours. He’s not obligated to hand the ball to the boundary umpire. When there is a stoppage, some players pick up the footy and hand it back to the ump and some players leave it on the ground

Speaking of players taking a dive...that reminds me of that softy ex-captain that plays for Carlton.

Carlisle had a go at Murphy and according to Carro, Jake made ‘misogynistic’ slurs. Therefore Carro can never forgive Jake and she’ll be seeking revenge at every opportunity on behalf of all women.

f****** Caroline Wilson. Spare me. Her facial expression leaves one wondering if she continually is sucking on a lemon. Near the top of my ladder of hate fwiw.

And that fat f*** Hutchy runs a close second.

[CURLY]

It’s not an issue in anyone else’s mind except Caroline Wilson and....yours. He’s not obligated to hand the ball to the boundary umpire. When there is a stoppage, some players pick up the footy and hand it back to the ump and some players leave it on the ground

Speaking of players taking a dive...that reminds me of that softy ex-captain that plays for Carlton.

Carlisle had a go at Murphy and according to Carro, Jake made ‘misogynistic’ slurs. Therefore Carro can never forgive Jake and she’ll be seeking revenge at every opportunity on behalf of all women.

Got no issue with what Carlisle did would have been better if Ranpe had to stay off. Risk you take playing vulnerable players. Caro can get f***ed she’s caused more harm with her vile comments than anything Carslisles done.

[skeptic]

It’s not an issue in anyone else’s mind except Caroline Wilson and....yours. He’s not obligated to hand the ball to the boundary umpire. When there is a stoppage, some players pick up the footy and hand it back to the ump and some players leave it on the ground

Speaking of players taking a dive...that reminds me of that softy ex-captain that plays for Carlton.

Carlisle had a go at Murphy and according to Carro, Jake made ‘misogynistic’ slurs. Therefore Carro can never forgive Jake and she’ll be seeking revenge at every opportunity on behalf of all women.

f****** Caroline Wilson. Spare me. Her facial expression leaves one wondering if she continually is sucking on a lemon. Near the top of my ladder of hate fwiw.

And that fat f*** Hutchy runs a close second.

Does Hutchinson still write for the Herald Sun?

[Toy Saint]

Football fans are fickle.

It feels like Saints supporters have never really got around Jake, and the club possibly didn't help with the way the Murphy bruhaha was handled/perceived. But the bottom line is he is invested and waves the flag the ole fashioned way.

I've never got the chatter about possible trades. Ludicrous. Possibly the same knuckleheads that carry on about Hanners and Sebby. And talk about who was the first big fish landed, it was Jakey waaay before Hanners, so maybe Jake is a visionary too and could see the club was going places long before the short sighted crew ever did.

Happy he plays for us.

As I seem to recall, at about the same time we recruited Carlisle he was exposed for white powder in Las Vegas. Plenty of us must have been thinking, oh no not another Lovet deadshit problem child from Essendon.

Jake is also a tad laconic, and often looks disinterested. Despite this, it was disgraceful the way the club failed to support him in the Murphy incident. In fact I reckon is was bad for player culture.

Personally, I like having Jake in the team, and love that he waves the flag old style. In fact I'd be delighted if he won the Norm Smith.

[devil saint]

If you think Caroline Wilson was critical of Jake's behaviour on the weekend, have a look at last night's ep of On the Couch and see Rooey's.
I have never seen him more scathing. Roo also claimed that Membrey was yelling out to Carlisle to stop.
Definitely not a good look.

[SaintPav]

Jeez, talk about getting stuck into someone.

Very harsh if you ask me.

[saynta]

Jeez, talk about getting stuck into someone.

Very harsh if you ask me.

Not at all balanced. That swine prick was using that gloved hand to belt into A very young King. What a prick.

[SaintPav]

Jeez, talk about getting stuck into someone.

Very harsh if you ask me.

Not at all balanced. That swine prick was using that gloved hand to belt into A very young King. What a prick.

It doesn't seem that he connected, Jake that is.

[saynta]

Jeez, talk about getting stuck into someone.

Very harsh if you ask me.

Not at all balanced. That swine prick was using that gloved hand to belt into A very young King. What a prick.

It doesn't seem that he connected, Jake that is.

No. Didn't look like it, did it?

[SaintPav]

Jeez, talk about getting stuck into someone.

Very harsh if you ask me.

Not at all balanced. That swine prick was using that gloved hand to belt into A very young King. What a prick.

It doesn't seem that he connected, Jake that is.

No. Didn't look like it, did it?

Nope. Probably more of a bad look than anything.

The comment about not handing back the ball was risible. Many players do that so they have time to get back in position. Is she going to point those incidents out as well? Doubt it.

The whole segment sounded over the top and a little vindictive to me. It's not like he killed anyone. She really was on a mission. She's such a hypocrite.

[Devilhead]

To me the kick that Jake half marked over the boundary was actually over the boundary - from the naked eye and the positioning of feet and bodies it looked well over

So Carlisle had every right to be disgusted that he didn't get the free kick for out on the full

Fk you ump ..... ball into boundary fence as we see many times during a game

Fk you Wilson for still not saying sorry to the players and club about getting it wrong re: a lying Duthie

Any chance she gets it's boot in like Rosa Klebb (Spectre no 3) in fact the resemblance is uncanny

[The Fireman]

Mick jagger played the part ?

[asiu]

looks like kenny

[samoht]

Jake is also a tad laconic, and often looks disinterested.

re: looking disinterested.
Looks can be deceiving?? .... Carlisle had a serious back injury.
The spirit may have been willing - but his back may have prevented him from going in 100% last year?