Has Carlisle Given Clavarino His Chance

[ace]

Carlisle targeting slaps at Rampe hand (operated on earlier in the week but still playing).

[George27]

Carlisle targeting slaps at Rampe hand (operated on earlier in the week but still playing).

Yep I would think he will get time for that. Not a good look. Hopefully not as long a suspension as Stevie Baker got.

[Moods]

Surely just a fine

[CURLY]

It will be media driven if anything happens. Rampe shouldn’t be playing and definitely shouldn’t be involved in pushing and shoving if injured.

[The Fireman]

I liked it.. just like the good old days
remember someone doing it to the G Train ? no big deal.

[PADDLEPOP1001]

Shouldn’t play if you can’t take a slap on the hand! Rampe was giving King a hard time ,poor young bloke ,double standards much!

[Trev from the Bush]

In answer to the question, I think not.

[Devilhead]

Did he actually hit his hand?

Looked like he was slapping at air

Wonder what got him angry?

[fugazi]

Any other team it would be a fine...Carlisle will get a week.

Roberton in?

[Mr Magic]

Where was the vision of what Rampe was doing to Max King?
Repeatedly punching him off the ball

[Enrico_Misso]

Carlisle targeting slaps at Rampe hand (operated on earlier in the week but still playing).

Yep I would think he will get time for that. Not a good look. Hopefully not as long a suspension as Stevie Baker got.

Intentional - yes
Contact made - glancing at best
Force - negligible
"Look"- possibly not good
Reportable - definitely Not
Penalty - nothing

If you go into a game with an injury you are fair game to be targeted - no penalty
Otherwise, do you penalise someone for applying a legal tackle to an opponent carrying a shoulder injury?

But if you get injured during a game then it is unsporting to get targeted - that should definitely be reviewed for severity.

[Trev from the Bush]

Swans have a duty of care not to play injured players. Report them to Workcover.

[kosifantutti]

Same hand he was punching King with.

[Ghost Like]

Where was the vision of what Rampe was doing to Max King?
Repeatedly punching him off the ball

To be honest, I think King was trying to hit Rampe's hand to begin with. Great stuff kid!

[Ghost Like]

It will be media driven if anything happens.

Curly is spot on with this.

[The Fireman]

Will Rampe ever be able to play the piano again ?

[To the top]

Nothing in it

Media hype

Carlisle is a fierce competitor and was filthy at the 50, the mark he juggled over the boundary and one other contest where he was cranky with himself

Big Jake not happy is a sight

If you are on the ground you are fit and fair game

Carlisle was actually scrapping to get the Sydney player to let go of this jumper, then had a slap at the Sydney players other hand but missed

Nothing in it

[Mr Magic]

Where was the vision of what Rampe was doing to Max King?
Repeatedly punching him off the ball

To be honest, I think King was trying to hit Rampe's hand to begin with. Great stuff kid!

Gotta disagree
Rampe went for King before the first bounce and continued to do it most of the first quarter
It was a deliberate plan IMHO

[samuraisaint]

Well done Big Jake. If someone has a go at you, have a go right back. Dad's Advice 101.

[Enrico_Misso]

It will be media driven if anything happens.

Curly is spot on with this.

So our media unit should get on the front foot and put out a package of Rampe hitting King.

[Ghost Like]

It will be media driven if anything happens.

Curly is spot on with this.

So our media unit should get on the front foot and put out a package of Rampe hitting King.

That could work & not just for Carlisle but for King & St Kilda in the future.

[Otiman]

Not a good look ethically to be targeting injuries, but from a tribunal perspective should be a fine at most.

[bigcarl]

Rampe’s hand can’t be too sore going by the treatment he was trying to dish out to Max. The club should point this out if anything comes out of the Carlisle thing

[ace]

We could always suggest to the AFL that the club will punish him.
By making him kick 100 short passes that hit their target.
Probably will need 1,000 kicks.

[True Blue Sainter]

Not a good look ethically to be targeting injuries, but from a tribunal perspective should be a fine at most.

If they're playing, then they're fit - they're fair game.

I remember someone doing this to G Train many moons ago as well when he played with a broken finger or hand.

No issue as far as I'm concerned