Dear Jack Newnes

[ss1986]

Kindly take the best offer out there......

and ‘the F!!K out of this club.

[Junction Oval]

How this guy ever got a 2 year extension, I will never know. It just tells us where the Club is at - going nowhere !

[To the top]

Why stop at Newnes?

The only players I would view as required are Coffield, Carlisle, Steven, Gresham, Ross, Dunstan, Acres, Steele, Hannebery, Clark, King, Billings, Roberton, Marshall, Bytel, Austin, Battle, Bruce, Membrey, McCartin, Clavarion and Wilkie.

There are doubts over Steven, Roberton and McCartin

We need to get full pre-seasons into some others

We have a First Round Draft Pick with currency.

And the rest can aspire to playing in State Leagues or suburban competitions.

[ss1986]

I really struggle to see what others do in Acres.

Yes, might’ve been mismanaged A LOT - but in the cases where he does get given the opportunity, all I’ve ever felt is let down and/or underwhelmed.

As for everyone else - I would say not a single player on our list apart from Hunter Clark and Rowan Marshall are untouchable.

For the RIGHT value, I would consider everyone tradeable.

[Wayne42]

Can't wait for the Trade/Free Agency period to begin.

[Yorkeys]

A new coach or the last couple of weeks will withdraw the offer, surely.

[wally]

If he hasn't snapped it up yet, perhaps he feels he's worth more or does have a better offer.

[ss1986]

If he hasn't snapped it up yet, perhaps he feels he's worth more or does have a better offer.

I’m not sure he’s had a chance to glance away from the mirror just yet.

[prwilkinson]

I hope the contract was a real low ball (hint, hint f**k off Jack) that any team could match. The guy’s a hack and doesn’t give a shiteee

[BarryGrogan]

Why stop at Newnes?

The only players I would view as required are Coffield, Carlisle, Steven, Gresham, Ross, Dunstan, Acres, Steele, Hannebery, Clark, King, Billings, Roberton, Marshall, Bytel, Austin, Battle, Bruce, Membrey, McCartin, Clavarion and Wilkie.

There are doubts over Steven, Roberton and McCartin

We need to get full pre-seasons into some others

We have a First Round Draft Pick with currency.

And the rest can aspire to playing in State Leagues or suburban competitions.

Dunstan can't bend over and can't kick.

He's a liability.

[silverhalo]

I really struggle to see what others do in Acres.

Yes, might’ve been mismanaged A LOT - but in the cases where he does get given the opportunity, all I’ve ever felt is let down and/or underwhelmed.

As for everyone else - I would say not a single player on our list apart from Hunter Clark and Rowan Marshall are untouchable.

For the RIGHT value, I would consider everyone tradeable.

Agree with you on Acres, a WA boy and we should be looking to package him up in the Hill deal. Been at the club for a few years and just doesn't seem to be able to take the next step.....move him on for the right price.

[SaintPav]

Why the f*** would Freo want Acres?

Plays about 5 good games a year.

[Teflon]

Newnes is the type that needs to go must go

[Greg T]

Take the other witches hat Sinclair with him as they shut the door

[Greg T]

Take the other witches hat Sinclair with him as they shut the door

[Special]

I hope the contract was a real low ball (hint, hint f**k off Jack) that any team could match. The guy’s a hack and doesn’t give a shiteee

Careful. Some posters on here will have a hissy-fit, report the post and the proloteriate will ban you for saying nasty things (albiet true) about Saints players. Das ist Verboten!

[Special]

Why the f*** would Freo want Acres?

Plays about 5 good games a year.

Because we massively overrate players that aren’t much good for us but are somehow worth a second round pick elsewhere.

Please someone remind me what we got for Mav, H Goddard & Minchington?

How did those trio go at their clubs??

Were they worth more than delisted FA’s that they were?

[Saintly66]

He’s a gossip merchant at the club and thinks his s*** doesn’t stink, so kindly leave ASAP Jack.

[SaintPav]

Is the 2-year offer official?

[Ghost Like]

Why the f*** would Freo want Acres?

Plays about 5 good games a year.

Those 5 good games puts him well ahead of a few others on the list.

[SaintPav]

Why the f*** would Freo want Acres?

Plays about 5 good games a year.

Those 5 good games puts him well ahead of a few others on the list.

5 good games might have been a little generous...

[Ghost Like]

Why the f*** would Freo want Acres?

Plays about 5 good games a year.

Those 5 good games puts him well ahead of a few others on the list.

5 good games might have been a little generous...

No, you're probably spot on SP.