Jake Carlisle....good player...but...

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

...geez you do some stupid s*** on the field. Grow up. You are over 25 now!

[skeptic]

Try to be a good supporter and support your players

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

<edited by mods>

[Rubyjo]

f*** it chop him we won

[B.M]

Carlisle is overrated

[saint6709]

.......but the umps don’t like him ( FYI they don’t like the saints much either)

[saint6709]

.......but the umps don’t like him ( FYI they don’t like the saints much either)

[skeptic]

Had a decent last quarter and didn’t drop his bundle. Got to respect that at least

[The_Dud]

Is a hot head which does hurt him, and us.

[bigred]

Its a fine line.

Rather he flies the flag than not.

Was a shytty free kick.

[desertsaint]

very important player for us. could be better, should be AA if he had the head for improvng his game.

[Rubyjo]

Jesus he is still a little rusty chopped a guy in the throat who cares..

[The Fireman]

...geez you do some stupid s*** on the field. Grow up. You are over 25 now!

forum clogger

[Joffa Burns]

...geez you do some stupid s*** on the field. Grow up. You are over 25 now!

Great win tonight, no need to start potting players with your negativity.

Go Saints!

[skeptic]

...geez you do some stupid s*** on the field. Grow up. You are over 25 now!

Great win tonight, no need to start potting players with your negativity.

Go Saints!

Not referring to the op but I suspect some forumites aren’t really Saints fans

[ss1986]

...geez you do some stupid s*** on the field. Grow up. You are over 25 now!

Leave Jake alone.

I am sure Brett will sort it out.

Alan!? Alan!? Alan!? Steve!

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Fairdinkum. Forum...no words describe.

Win for the true believers tonight.

[BarryGrogan]

Carlisle is overrated

I think he's underrated.


And I also think his return this year after back surgery has been incredible.

Back surgery FFS!!! He's probably going at about 60% fitness.

[degruch]

Fairdinkum. Forum...no words describe.

Win for the true believers tonight.

A win for true believers in Jake? Geez, 'grow up', strong words, very negative...lucky he's not a Saints official or there'd be a 1 week ban!

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Saints only 1 game out of the 8.

Big game in Adelaide next week. Massive.

[The_Dud]

Yep, no good, if only he did more for the Saints like, let’s say, Hannerbry does!

[skeptic]

The criticism of Carlisle is tough...
He gave away a stupid free that cost us a goal
Failed with an abysmal attempt to spoil in the 1st
Was unlucky with a few marks that looked like they could have been paid that we’re costly

Ultimately though, he stood up in the last after an average game and he did a few nice things throughout the game.

He’s a good player and this part of the season is like a run up to the preseason for him. Cut him some slack

[B.M]

Can be lazy, undisciplined and is not the hardest bloke going around.

[BarryGrogan]

.... not the hardest bloke going around.

Standing under packs with broken ribs makes him pretty hard in my book.

[B.M]

How do you stand under a pack?

He’s 6’7”

Reckon he Stan’s above most packs.

I reckon he can make some pretty soft efforts for a guy his size, he an impressive athlete, good hands, good kick but he’s not a huge fan of contact