Match/Torch Thread Saints v Cats Round 17 2019

[B.M]

Must be Richo’s fault we are in front, because it will be his fault when we lose.

On McKenzie, Barry

Ridiculous decision akin to Armo at HB the other week

2 possessions at HT and he is the second lowest ranked player on the ground.

[Jacks Back]

Acres 1 touch, McKenzie 2 & Membrey not doing much. Come on guys, lift!

[HardSaint]

Frees 12 to cats & 9 to Saints

And that's probably about right
How is that 2 sides in a game should have parity in frees?
I'm happy with the umpiring tonight

[Teflon]

Great effort thus far
It’s amazing though.......it’s crisis time down at one of the toughest gigs to play and they produce that?
Play at home against Lions......and they’re not there....
Can’t rely on crisis to produce effort - good sides don’t.
Be interesting to see if we can keep it up for 4 qtrs....Cats will come

[SuperDuper]

I’d seriously like to know the thinking behind McKenzie playing Forward?

0 possessions, never played there, doesn’t know what he’s doing?!

May as well have a natural forward (Parker or Young)
Even Rice who has Forward craft and strong hands

If McKenzie can’t get a gig as a defender he should be at Sandy

Totally Disagree.

At the very least, it's worth a try.

He's excellent overhead, and won't cause too much hurt when he turns it over.


The season is over. The only thing we have, is tje opportunity to see what guys are capable of.


I'd be appalled if the club is still playing for short term gains.

then why do we snub Brendan White week after wee after week when he is Sandy's best week after week

Richo cant even spot a good footballer when staring him in the face,,
Picks Newnes and McKenzie because they have got big tanks. Might as well draft from the athletic tracks rather than the football field

give White an extended run at it FFS!!!

[CURLY]

Frees 12 to cats & 9 to Saints

Pay that free to Lonie and we’re 15 up.

[CURLY]

I’d seriously like to know the thinking behind McKenzie playing Forward?

0 possessions, never played there, doesn’t know what he’s doing?!

May as well have a natural forward (Parker or Young)
Even Rice who has Forward craft and strong hands

If McKenzie can’t get a gig as a defender he should be at Sandy

Totally Disagree.

At the very least, it's worth a try.

He's excellent overhead, and won't cause too much hurt when he turns it over.


The season is over. The only thing we have, is tje opportunity to see what guys are capable of.


I'd be appalled if the club is still playing for short term gains.

then why do we snub Brendan White week after wee after week when he is Sandy's best week after week

Richo cant even spot a good footballer when staring him in the face,,
Picks Newnes and McKenzie because they have got big tanks. Might as well draft from the athletic tracks rather than the football field

give White an extended run at it FFS!!!

How do you know what has been asked of White? I reckon McKenzie at least tries to hold up his end of the bargain. Not sure White does.

[HardSaint]

Frees 12 to cats & 9 to Saints

Pay that free to Lonie and we’re 15 up.

Ping Dunstan for holding and the score line is 3


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[mullet]

Frees 12 to cats & 9 to Saints

Pay that free to Lonie and we’re 15 up.

51 tackles to 40 our favour. Much better stat

[SuperDuper]

I’d seriously like to know the thinking behind McKenzie playing Forward?

0 possessions, never played there, doesn’t know what he’s doing?!

May as well have a natural forward (Parker or Young)
Even Rice who has Forward craft and strong hands

If McKenzie can’t get a gig as a defender he should be at Sandy

Totally Disagree.

At the very least, it's worth a try.

He's excellent overhead, and won't cause too much hurt when he turns it over.


The season is over. The only thing we have, is tje opportunity to see what guys are capable of.


I'd be appalled if the club is still playing for short term gains.

then why do we snub Brendan White week after wee after week when he is Sandy's best week after week

Richo cant even spot a good footballer when staring him in the face,,
Picks Newnes and McKenzie because they have got big tanks. Might as well draft from the athletic tracks rather than the football field

give White an extended run at it FFS!!!

How do you know what has been asked of White? I reckon McKenzie at least tries to hold up his end of the bargain. Not sure White does.

yes, clearly the wrong questions are being asked. that is my point. Why not ask him to play well?
Pretty simple

[skeptic]

Incredible quarter

Well done boys. Considering what we’re up against it’s our best effort in a year IMO

[The Barometer]

Must be Richo’s fault we are in front, because it will be his fault when we lose.

On McKenzie, Barry

Ridiculous decision akin to Armo at HB the other week

2 possessions at HT and he is the second lowest ranked player on the ground.

Nothing like Armo. Coffield and Clarke need to play back right now . Don’t see much wrong with trying McKenzie elsewhere.

[desertsaint]

great effort.. many were expecting a parrallel with the gold coast v crows smashing.

[The_Dud]

Does Gresh ever not kick round his body?

[B.M]

Missed tackles

[Enrico_Misso]

Wasting chances

[The_Dud]

Nice kick Billings

[B.M]

Sinclair, Acres, Membrey need to lift

No influence whatsoever

[HardSaint]

Needs to be dead on
Dead off


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[SaintPav]

Big deal.. ignore it.

We ARE St Kilda supporters.

Back at ya mate. Why are you bothered by people having a crack at Curly? Ignore it. Curly is, by any standards, obsessed about the umpiring.

Why?

Because he is sometimes right.

Right back at you, maate

Pointing out that you’re complaining about others complaining.

Which you’re doing yourself.

Hate to get personal, but as you started it...you’ve gone from poster, to mod, to self imposed ban and now back to posting again.

A little lost are we, Byron?

[George27]

0.3 to 1.0 since half time. Must convert

[HardSaint]

Good pressure Saints

[The_Dud]

Sinclair, Acres, Membrey need to lift

No influence whatsoever

Is Acres playing a defensive role? Would love to see him in at centre bounces.

[CURLY]

FFS that’s a double 360 degree tackle called play on.

[CURLY]

Sinclair, Acres, Membrey need to lift

No influence whatsoever

Is Acres playing a defensive role? Would love to see him in at centre bounces.

Yes on Stewart.