Team v Giants

[kosifantutti]

GWS Giants v St Kilda
GWS Giants - P.Davis, I.Cumming in for L.Whitfield (injured), M.Buntine.
St Kilda - D.Joyce, J.Marsh, R.Marshall, H.Clark in for N.Brown, B.Longer, J.Lonie (injured), J.Steven (Mental Health).

[saynta]

A bigger side.

[Special]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

<1 day ban for demeaning a Saints official>

[twirlyhair]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

Not sure you would have the courage to say that to the coaches face but that's another matter. As for Clark in and not Hind, would they be like for like swaps, or where do you think Hind should play?

[saynta]

B:


Jimmy Webster Darragh Joyce Shane Savage

HB:


Ben Paton Josh Battle Daniel McKenzie

C:


Ben Long Sebastian Ross Jack Newnes

HF:


Jack Billings Josh Bruce Dean Kent

F:


Jonathon Marsh Tim Membrey Jade Gresham

FOLL:


Rowan Marshall


Jack Steele


Jack Sinclair

I/C:


Blake Acres Hunter Clark Matty Parker Callum Wilkie

[The_President]

Young named as an emergency

[saintsRrising]

.
St Kilda - D.Joyce, J.Marsh, R.Marshall, H.Clark in for N.Brown, B.Longer, J.Lonie (injured), J.Steven (Mental Health).

Well on the positive side that makes us a quicker team.

[saintsRrising]

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

Suspect that means that Gresh will push more forward this week taking over Lonie role.

Clark to play the role that Gresh has mainly been playing this year.


Will not surprise me if Bruce is a late out.

[Otiman]

Is Brown injured? He's playing his best footy right now.

[fugazi]

Why is Brown dropped?
Not great last week, but been good most of the year.

[St Loxton]

Brown is way too slow for Cameron, Joyce not a bad choice.

[saynta]

No, he is an emergency

Emergencies


22 Nathan Brown
30 Ed Phillips
40 Nick Hind
41 Robbie Young

[saynta]

Brown is way too slow for Cameron, Joyce not a bad choice.

Yeah, agree with you there.

[stkfc1]

Brown cant go with Cameron. Joyce makes sense. Will need Wilkie roaming free to intercept and DMac to shut down Greene.

[saintsRrising]

Brown is way too slow for Cameron, Joyce not a bad choice.

Yes agree. Horses for courses.

PLUS it is good to get games into Joyce.

[Special]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

Not sure you would have the courage to say that to the coaches face but that's another matter. As for Clark in and not Hind, would they be like for like swaps, or where do you think Hind should play?

Whatever twirlyhead. Hind is versatile and can play half forward flank or backline. Clark was way too soft last time and needs to harden up a lot at AFL level.

[BringBackMadDog]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

anyone else see the irony in a person sitting at a keyboard anonymously calling the coach gutless?????

[BringBackMadDog]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

Not sure you would have the courage to say that to the coaches face but that's another matter. As for Clark in and not Hind, would they be like for like swaps, or where do you think Hind should play?

Whatever twirlyhead. Hind is versatile and can play half forward flank or backline. Clark was way too soft last time and needs to harden up a lot at AFL level.

Have you ever seen Hind play at half forward? Played every game for Essendon at half back. And you can say what ever you want about Clarkes ability but soft he aint

[Special]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

Not sure you would have the courage to say that to the coaches face but that's another matter. As for Clark in and not Hind, would they be like for like swaps, or where do you think Hind should play?

Whatever twirlyhead. Hind is versatile and can play half forward flank or backline. Clark was way too soft last time and needs to harden up a lot at AFL level.

Have you ever seen Hind play at half forward? Played every game for Essendon at half back. And you can say what ever you want about Clarkes ability but soft he aint

Sorry was a typo I meant half back flank and backline.
Hunter was soft in his last game vs Freo. Come on mate, he lasted one game and didn’t go in hard. Rewatch the tape.

[Scollop]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

Not sure you would have the courage to say that to the coaches face but that's another matter. As for Clark in and not Hind, would they be like for like swaps, or where do you think Hind should play?

Whatever twirlyhead. Hind is versatile and can play half forward flank or backline. Clark was way too soft last time and needs to harden up a lot at AFL level.

Have you ever seen Hind play at half forward? Played every game for Essendon at half back. And you can say what ever you want about Clarkes ability but soft he aint

Sorry was a typo I meant half back flank and backline.
Hunter was soft in his last game vs Freo. Come on mate, he lasted one game and didn’t go in hard. Rewatch the tape.

Don't jump the gun on Hunter. He's very young. Two years ago we still had doubts on Billings.

Middle of last year there were some posters that thought Billings was a bit like Fiora.

Now those same posters are hoping like hell that we resign JB and we've all seen that he's finally arrived as an A grade footballer in 2019. The boxing and fitness work he's done with Sam Soliman means JB is now taking the physical punishment required to succeed and bodylining the footy. Heck, he's even taking contested marks.

[Scollop]

Brown cant go with Cameron. Joyce makes sense. Will need Wilkie roaming free to intercept and DMac to shut down Greene.

Cameron is back to his best. I don't think there's too many in the whole league that can go with him. If Rance was fit and the Tigers midfield was getting thrashed he'd still probably score a bag. I'd have had Brown playing and just coathanger him in the first quarter...take one for the team... but that's just me

[guitars4]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

Not sure you would have the courage to say that to the coaches face but that's another matter. As for Clark in and not Hind, would they be like for like swaps, or where do you think Hind should play?

Whatever twirlyhead. Hind is versatile and can play half forward flank or backline. Clark was way too soft last time and needs to harden up a lot at AFL level.

Have you ever seen Hind play at half forward? Played every game for Essendon at half back. And you can say what ever you want about Clarkes ability but soft he aint

Sorry was a typo I meant half back flank and backline.
Hunter was soft in his last game vs Freo. Come on mate, he lasted one game and didn’t go in hard. Rewatch the tape.

Don't jump the gun on Hunter. He's very young. Two years ago we still had doubts on Billings.

Middle of last year there were some posters that thought Billings was a bit like Fiora.

Now those same posters are hoping like hell that we resign JB and we've all seen that he's finally arrived as an A grade footballer in 2019. The boxing and fitness work he's done with Sam Soliman means JB is now taking the physical punishment required to succeed and bodylining the footy. Heck, he's even taking contested marks.

IMO Clark is a good player who has the smarts & the ability to be a A grader in a few years.

[twirlyhair]

Kent stays. No surprise given how gutless Richo can be.

Not happy about Clark in the side. Should be Hind.

Not sure you would have the courage to say that to the coaches face but that's another matter. As for Clark in and not Hind, would they be like for like swaps, or where do you think Hind should play?

Whatever twirlyhead. Hind is versatile and can play half forward flank or backline. Clark was way too soft last time and needs to harden up a lot at AFL level.

Twirlyhead...hehe...got me there hey? Nice one! As for Hind, does his form in the seconds warrant selection?

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Good ins but we will struggle big time against a good GWS.

[Cairnsman]

Good ins but we will struggle big time against a good GWS.

Teddles we were not travelling so well last year when we scratched out a draw. GWS fear us.