Billings offered 900k a year for 2 years

[gone fission]

Ok so let's play Membrey in several different positions over the next 3 years and see how he goes

You are talking about one of our most important players structurally and you call him B grade Great supporter

Bruce would have stats better than Membrey if he was allowed to settle in the position he thrived in.

Why don't you tell that to Richo.....and to all those managers you know

So I'm not a good supporter because I think a player who has been average for years is considered a B grader?

Once you start getting personal I think you are out of ideas to support your suggestion that Josh Bruce should be on $800,000 PA.

Membrey plays up and down the ground as much as any forward.
Bruce is a key forward who chops out in the ruck a handful of times each game? where else do you think he has played in the past 4 years?

Which of these players has been allowed to settle into one position
A

B


If Josh Bruce gets an $800,000 contract, fold the club.

[samoht]

Roberton would be worth $600k, perhaps (if he didn't have his ailment).
He is a huge loss.

Bruce is an okay key forward who is important for structure and can take a spectacular mark and kick his 3-4 goals now and again - and maybe 40 goals over the year. He's carrying an injury at the moment.
When we beat Essendon, Bruce took 3 marks in total, and one spectacular one that made the highlight reel - while his opponent Hurley took a lazy 14 marks! That's 11 more.

Bruce has to be worth up to $400K - at a stretch?

[Scollop]

Ok so let's play Membrey in several different positions over the next 3 years and see how he goes

You are talking about one of our most important players structurally and you call him B grade Great supporter

Bruce would have stats better than Membrey if he was allowed to settle in the position he thrived in.

Why don't you tell that to Richo.....and to all those managers you know

So I'm not a good supporter because I think a player who has been average for years is considered a B grader?

Once you start getting personal I think you are out of ideas to support your suggestion that Josh Bruce should be on $800,000 PA.

Membrey plays up and down the ground as much as any forward.
Bruce is a key forward who chops out in the ruck a handful of times each game? where else do you think he has played in the past 4 years?

Which of these players has been allowed to settle into one position
A

B


If Josh Bruce gets an $800,000 contract, fold the club.

Now you're talkin'. This is good and I'm greatful for people to argue the point and make an effort to educate all of us. Now please let us know if the heat map is from a particular game, a particular year or for their whole careers (and can you please provide a source for the map if it's publicly available).

This was an exercise based on my opinion regarding who I thought were our most important players. I am just a punter with no vested interest on who gets paid what. The problem with some of the posters here on SS is they may not be. By the way, I think you started with the personal insult saying that I'd be laughed at

[King12]

You seem to be having a crack at a few different posters Scollop?

Are you in a bad place?

[Scollop]

Are you going fishing? Teddie troll or King12

And why choose to post a nothing question in this thread? Why not go the other thread where I am 'actually' having a crack? I'll tell you why...you're a troll...I wonder what your next nic is going to be?

What the f***? You are now the caring, empathetic newbie poster who asks if everyone's in a bad place? And then what do you do when they answer. Spare me your bs concern

[King12]

Are you going fishing? Teddie troll or King12

What the f***? You are now the caring, empathetic newbie poster who asks if everyone's in a bad place? And then what do you do when they answer. Spare me your bs concern you troll

I'm not a troll.

Just a concerned citizen, nicely reaching out to see if your ok?

Your theory is along way off the mark, I was trying to be nice really, but obviously no point being nice if you are going to throw untruths and abuse my way.

Thanks for your time.

[Scollop]

Are you going fishing? Teddie troll or King12

What the f***? You are now the caring, empathetic newbie poster who asks if everyone's in a bad place? And then what do you do when they answer. Spare me your bs concern you troll

I'm not a troll.

Just a concerned citizen, nicely reaching out to see if your ok?

Your theory is along way off the mark, I was trying to be nice really, but obviously no point being nice if you are going to throw untruths and abuse my way.

Thanks for your time.

So it was just a coincidence that you turned up just after ted put his new signature up saying he wouldn't engage with the HOH gang?

[King12]

Are you going fishing? Teddie troll or King12

What the f***? You are now the caring, empathetic newbie poster who asks if everyone's in a bad place? And then what do you do when they answer. Spare me your bs concern you troll

I'm not a troll.

Just a concerned citizen, nicely reaching out to see if your ok?

Your theory is along way off the mark, I was trying to be nice really, but obviously no point being nice if you are going to throw untruths and abuse my way.

Thanks for your time.

So it was just a coincidence that you turned up just after ted put his new signature up saying he wouldn't engage with the HOH gang?

Yeap, looks that way. What's the HOH gang?

Really not sure what your talking about tbh!

Anyway, good luck with your theory, but I ain't Ted.

I'm not even Roo, so I'm not Roo of Ted, or both put together.

Maybe you should just focus a little more on following the footy a little closer.

All the best to you.

[Scollop]

All the best to me? Spare me your bs manners

You just said in your previous post that there was no point being nice? Where's your integrity?

Anyhow...you are joining the ted nic and going on ignore

[King12]

OK thanks, your a charming happy little Saint. I'm not Ted, so once again your judgement is out, no surprise there though really! I won't be kind to you anymore, but hey, your ignoring me anyway, so I guess it doesn't matter!

Any wonder the 'C-man' doesn't rate ya, along with many others by the looks.

[The_Dud]

As I said, no club is overpaying 5 players $100k each.

Wow, thanks for the in depth and comprehensive counter argument, full of evidence and data, I am now convinced.

[King12]

As I said, no club is overpaying 5 players $100k each.

Wow, thanks for the in depth and comprehensive counter argument, full of evidence and data, I am now convinced.

Provide the evidence to your outlandish statement then, which club, not ours!

[King12]

Are you and Scollop the same poster?

[SaintPav]

Gawd..

[King12]

Gawd..

??

[SaintPav]

Lord

[SaintPav]

Crikey

[SaintPav]

Don’t have a blue luv

[The_Dud]

Are you and Scollop the same poster?

Again, great contribution.

[Sainter_Dad]

This is the problem when you set the benchmark of $800k for an ageing broken down DH.

He’s worth about $1.5M on that scale.

Yeah if we weren't paying Hannebry 800k Billings would stay for 400k.

Lol. Whatever Hannebery is on will not effect any contract negotiations for current players or bringing in any new players. Its amazing how Hanners or Richo nearly slip into every thread on here, no matter how obscure the link.

Of course it will have an effect - look at Adelaide's contract negotiation (McGovern and Gibbs) for proof.

[King12]

Are you and Scollop the same poster?

Again, great contribution.

So, that's not a no then!

I've been here 5 minutes and have worked out the relationship status of certain posters, pretty smart really.

[Jacks Back]

3 & 1/2 days and 50 posts already. Geez.

[King12]

51 now, so what, is there a limit?

[saintbob]

Sign him up now

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Are you and Scollop the same poster?

Probably not but they just about try to outdo each other on the plane of negativity regarding the Saints. If they were anymore negative they would flip the polar caps one day into the not too distant future.