Paddy and Robbo maybe right for Rd 1

[Joffa Burns]

A further update on this.
Roberton as I said earlier is now retired.
McCartin out indefinitely and getting external advice and testing on his brain independent from club.
In my opinion on what I’ve been told very unlikely to ever play again.

Thanks for sharing.

[The Fireman]

can the mods please stop Ted from starting threads ?

<1 day ban for commenting on a poster>

[degruch]

can the mods please stop Ted from starting threads ?

Well, he's on 'holiday' at the moment, so...technically, yes!

[The Fireman]

can the mods please stop Ted from starting threads ?

Well, he's on 'holiday' at the moment, so...technically, yes!

the relief is palpable

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

It's going to be a very sad for the ST KFC if Paddy and Robbo retire. Very sad.

Fingers crossed some reports are wrong. Fingers crossed but they have to do what is best for themselves.

Why do I only get banned for commenting on other poster(s) too?

[The Fireman]

sometimes I don't think holidays are long enough...

[SaintPav]

FFS.

Very sad for these guys.

Hopefully some compo coming Saints way.

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

sometimes I don't think holidays are long enough...

I am never on holiday Firey.

[saintsRrising]

can the mods please stop Ted from starting threads ?

You mean "Scoop" as he likes to be known. Though is more like the "Kiss of Death" with his scoops.

[The Fireman]

FFS.

Very sad for these guys.

Hopefully some compo coming Saints way.

we'll get zip...probably sympathy....another long year....lets just hope they dont screw this years number 1 pick up.

[The Fireman]

can the mods please stop Ted from starting threads ?

You mean "Scoop" as he likes to be known. Though is more like the "Kiss of Death" with his scoops.

forum clogger

[BackFromUSA]

Paddy should not play again - already taken one (maybe two) risks too many with his head injuries. Will be lucky now to escape with no long term impact on his life. Not personal opinion. A medical opinion. Club / AFL has taken this medical advice. Paddy devastated.

[asiu]

quite the day

[GilsAuPair]

It's going to be a very sad for the ST KFC if Paddy and Robbo retire. Very sad.

Fingers crossed some reports are wrong. Fingers crossed but they have to do what is best for themselves.

Why do I only get banned for commenting on other poster(s) too?

Ummm

You were up and about on Sunday night saying both Paddy and Dylan were totally fine and that you had the inside word.

You mocked and teased me mercilessly for saying otherwise and questing your information.

Do you have no shame?

Are you going to apologise to me?

Fairly obvious you were wrong and your inside source (T74) was telling you fibs.

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

?

[HitTheBoundary]

?

One of your better posts.

[GilsAuPair]

?


St Kilda pair Dylan Roberton and Paddy McCartin, who had health concerns that put them in hospital on Sunday night, remarkably remain hopeful that they could play round one of the season.

Fantasticdadoodle news!

Righto

[Scoop]

can the mods please stop Ted from starting threads ?

You mean "Scoop" as he likes to be known. Though is more like the "Kiss of Death" with his scoops.

[saintsRrising]

can the mods please stop Ted from starting threads ?

You mean "Scoop" as he likes to be known. Though is more like the "Kiss of Death" with his scoops.

LOL not you...but the poster that wants to be regarded as an ITK when he clearly is not. TIP as in who thought a certain 2 players would be ok for Round 1.

[samuraisaint]

I think the longer Paddy isn't able to play at senior level, the more likely it is that we won't see him play again this season at all. Once he loses his conditioning the more likely it is that he could get hurt again. This situation is not his fault but there is obviously a weakness there.