Daniel Menzel

[Tom_Sainter]

Surely this bloke is worth a go? Lacks a bit of forward pressure but has averaged 2 goals a game in the last few seasons. Really surprised Geelong delisted him. We seemed interested prior to trade week and have apparently our interest has cooled? Thoughts?

[bergsone]

IMO it would be either him or Membrey,take Membrey every time,so recruit him to play at sandi,no thanks

[guitars4]

Surely this bloke is worth a go? Lacks a bit of forward pressure but has averaged 2 goals a game in the last few seasons. Really surprised Geelong delisted him. We seemed interested prior to trade week and have apparently our interest has cooled? Thoughts?

So we don't have to give up anything but what do we have to pay him? We have a war chest apparently that we have to spend or we lose it so what the hell give him a 1 year contract with incentives he's gotta be better than Lonie that has just signed a 2 year contract IMO

[Joffa Burns]

Did not want him as a DFA or a trade, but wouldn’t be upset if we put him on rookie list on a one year deal.

[stonecold]

Did not want him as a DFA or a trade, but wouldn’t be upset if we put him on rookie list on a one year deal.

Trades are finished Joffa!!!!!

[Wayne42]

Did not want him as a DFA or a trade, but wouldn’t be upset if we put him on rookie list on a one year deal.

Trades are finished Joffa!!!!!

Yes but the Rookie draft hasn't started yet.

[chico2001]

Delisted free agent period in November though isn't there?

[Joffa Burns]

Did not want him as a DFA or a trade, but wouldn’t be upset if we put him on rookie list on a one year deal.

Comprehension is overrated little fella

[Waltzing St Kilda]

MIght as well take him.

Mind you, all it would take is some well-advertised interest from other clubs and we'll probably be spooked into taking him with our first pick.

[saint6709]

Prefer others

[evertonfc]

To be fair, given we are the worst team around goal in the league, I'd be signing him up.

Honestly, he and Hartung would be in our best 22.

[stonecold]

Did not want him as a DFA or a trade, but wouldn’t be upset if we put him on rookie list on a one year deal.

Comprehension is overrated little fella

Obviously, you mentioned 'Trade'!!!!!

[degruch]

If we were going to recycle anyone I'd be all over Tommy Sheridan ahead of another forward.

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Would rather take Neade from PA over Menzel.

[Joffa Burns]

Did not want him as a DFA or a trade, but wouldn’t be upset if we put him on rookie list on a one year deal.

Comprehension is overrated little fella

Obviously, you mentioned 'Trade'!!!!!

In the past tense little fella.

Did not want him as a trade, did not want to give up anything for him.

Did not want him as a FA where he might get tenure.

Happy if we gave him a one year rookie contract as there is little exposure.

Happy to pass.

[Joffa Burns]

If we were going to recycle anyone I'd be all over Tommy Sheridan ahead of another forward.

Agreed

[Sainternist]

Getting a player like Menzel would only keep a youngster like Josh Battle out of the team and rob him of valuable experience.

[Ghost Like]

If we were going to recycle anyone I'd be all over Tommy Sheridan ahead of another forward.

Agreed

+1

[terry smith rules]

Out of all the delisted players I would look at Dean Towers from Swans ,can play tall and should have got more games at the swans

[shrodes]

We have ruled ourselves out apparently.

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/cut ... 50btc.html

Delisted Geelong small forward Daniel Menzel is on the radar of up to five AFL clubs, according to his agent.

Menzel's manager Adam Ramanauskas says there remains interest in the goalsneak after reports cellar-dwellers Carlton, Brisbane and St Kilda have ruled themselves out as potential suitors.

[Linton Lodger]

Battle will play the position Menzel plays. Menzel is a gun, Battle will be and his defensive side is far more superior.

[wally]

I don't see what the upside is. We have young blokes that need games if he's getting a game someone misses out.
He may help win a couple of games but he's not long term.

[Winmar]

If the club is keen to get games into the young forwards then there isn't really a spot for someone like Menzel. Assuming they want McCartin, Battle, Membrey, Bruce and Marshall to be the forward option in a couple of years then it'd be a waste to give games to him.