Would you do this?

[older saint]

If port offered 6 & 10 for 4 & 39

4= 2034
39 = 446
total 2480

6= 1751
10 =1359

Total =3110

difference 690 around pick 28.

I know its a deep draft but there seems to be a distinct top 4 so would probably say no as we are crying out for silk. If it was done i think it send a message they are looking at the King Boys.

With live picks something like this could happen draft night if one of the SA kids were at 4 and then Port may be desperate enough to make 39 65??

[saynta]

No.

Why would you want to improve port's playing list.

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

2 x top 10 picks is very tempting. Port want Rankine or Luckusious it seems. Would be funny if the Suns took both.

[Sainter_Dad]

Could happen if they are desperate on trade night - the joys of live trading

[bigred]

Depends who is available at pick 4.

Two picks in the top ten is pretty tempting.

[rodgerfox]

I absolutely would.


We're not one player away. We're still building our list.

If we can get two top tenners, that would unbelievable.

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Agreed. The top 20 runs very deep. We could snag 2 x gun mids. Add them to Clark and Coffield. Unbelievable. Thats 4 x top 10 picks.

[desertsaint]

who knows. if the hype is to believed (it rarely is) then no way trade a top four. if it's a normal draft then yes. the best player last year went six.
caveat emptor - we only got two decent players (but in no way future stars) at 7 and 8.
against that we got a shocker with our last number one, and an okay player at number 3. our only star from a top ten pick since goddard was traded for pick 5.
so again i'm back at who knows?

[ausfatcat]

our only star from a top ten pick since goddard was traded for pick 5.

who was that?

[desertsaint]

carlisle was traded for pick 5. our only clear win against the druggies, especially given what we did with the steak knives.

[derby Street]

We had 7 & 8 last year and would not say with any certainty that we nailed a gun. So no from me. We desperately need a quality mid.

[rodgerfox]

who knows. if the hype is to believed (it rarely is) then no way trade a top four. if it's a normal draft then yes. the best player last year went six.
caveat emptor - we only got two decent players (but in no way future stars) at 7 and 8.
against that we got a shocker with our last number one, and an okay player at number 3. our only star from a top ten pick since goddard was traded for pick 5.
so again i'm back at who knows?

I don't agree with that assessment one iota.

[DJ Higgins]

You are right with picks 7 & 8 but give them a chance, they are still kids and it is easier to shine in a good team which helps De Gooey and Higgins. it is a bit harsh on Cam Rayner and Andrew Brayshaw when there teams aren't really helping them out a lot.

I like to wait about 4 - 5 years before I pass judgement.

[skeptic]

Chris Judd is worth more to us than Ashleigh Sampi and James Bartel

[desertsaint]

who knows. if the hype is to believed (it rarely is) then no way trade a top four. if it's a normal draft then yes. the best player last year went six.
caveat emptor - we only got two decent players (but in no way future stars) at 7 and 8.
against that we got a shocker with our last number one, and an okay player at number 3. our only star from a top ten pick since goddard was traded for pick 5.
so again i'm back at who knows?

I don't agree with that assessment one iota.

not one iota?
stephenson the best?
clarke and coffield not near him?
paddy a shocker for a number one?
billings an okay player?
calisle our only star from a top ten pick?

not one of them? i reckon they're all fair calls. and i still have no idea if i'd do the hypothetical trade given our history either way.

[groupie1]

if they threw in Wingard I'd consider it... too late now

[Drew21]

A) I think hunter will be a very good player has poise and does not seem rushed

B) I would trade 4 for the 6 ,10 and 11 or next years first round
See how desperate they are on draft night

[Flagless]

A) I think hunter will be a very good player has poise and does not seem rushed

B) I would trade 4 for the 6 ,10 and 11 or next years first round
See how desperate they are on draft night

I agree on Hunter Clarke- he will be very good

[Goose is king]

I would do it in a heartbeat. We could very well get the player we are after at pick 6 and then a big upgrade with our second pick. Port may be desperate and offer it up on trade night. Hold tight till then

[Drew21]

A) I think hunter will be a very good player has poise and does not seem rushed

B) I would trade 4 for the 6 ,10 and 11 or next years first round
See how desperate they are on draft night

I agree on Hunter Clarke- he will be very good

Plus he has a frame that will bulk up nicely.
Wide shoulders