Monster deal for Dylan Shiel

[chico2001]

looking at it another way, Jack Steven would be on $600 for the next 2 years thats a rough guess. Hannebery comes and gets a reported $800k for 3-5 years. Shiel arrives and gets $1.3mill a year for 5 years. That means he is getting $700k a year more than J.Steven. Jack Steele who is on the up would be on $440 a year. Seb Ross- who knows what he is on but guess $500k a year and from most reports Shiel's kicking is a bit up and under and certainly not an accurate kick for goal as one poster pointed out. So where does that leave these guys. If I was Jack Steven I know what I would be doing right now.

You do the maths

[stonecold]

looking at it another way, Jack Steven would be on $600 for the next 2 years thats a rough guess. Hannebery comes and gets a reported $800k for 3-5 years. Shiel arrives and gets $1.3mill a year for 5 years. That means he is getting $700k a year more than J.Steven. Jack Steele who is on the up would be on $440 a year. Seb Ross- who knows what he is on but guess $500k a year and from most reports Shiel's kicking is a bit up and under and certainly not an accurate kick for goal as one poster pointed out. So where does that leave these guys. If I was Jack Steven I know what I would be doing right now.

You do the maths

Well for starters, we won't be paying all Dan's wage, Sydney will be paying some, as for Jack's wage, you think that is correct do you ($600k)?????

As much as I like Stuv, Shiel's is a better player, one of not many last night that had time and composer!!!!!

So, you do the Math's!!!!!

[Devilhead]

Shiel is a good player but not worth our first rounder

Averaged 25 possessions 3 marks 3 tackles and kicked 6.14 this year

Also averaged 1 goal assist and 1.5 one %

Sure good player but mid to late first round at very best

Tom Mitchell went for pick 14 and a swap of later picks

That's $1.3 mill a year staring you right in the face....what a joke.

Ah yes but we have 105% salary cap to fill up next year or we lose that 5% extra bonus - can someone confirm?

Probably best to fill it and front load a few contracts which will give us space further down the line but I am more worried about paying overs in terms of draft picks

We needed a few big name free agents to come our way but that's not happening due to our poor year - they would only cost us cap space and not picks

If we made finals this year then Gaff could have been a possibility but now we are scrambling for contracted players to fill the cap space hoping that maybe at the end of next year if we have a good season we can lure a few FAs or top shelf uncontracted players our way

[chico2001]

With Jack Steven I said it was a guess, so if you know then enlighten us. Then tell us how much Sydney is paying..." some " could mean anything. Shiel may be a better player but $700k better, I dont think so. You might need to read my post in its entirety and then do the maths again if you are capable because you obviously didnt do it the first time.

[Devilhead]

looking at it another way, Jack Steven would be on $600 for the next 2 years thats a rough guess. Hannebery comes and gets a reported $800k for 3-5 years. Shiel arrives and gets $1.3mill a year for 5 years. That means he is getting $700k a year more than J.Steven. Jack Steele who is on the up would be on $440 a year. Seb Ross- who knows what he is on but guess $500k a year and from most reports Shiel's kicking is a bit up and under and certainly not an accurate kick for goal as one poster pointed out. So where does that leave these guys. If I was Jack Steven I know what I would be doing right now.

You do the maths

Well for starters, we won't be paying all Dan's wage, Sydney will be paying some, as for Jack's wage, you think that is correct do you ($600k)?????

As much as I like Stuv, Shiel's is a better player, one of not many last night that had time and composer!!!!!

So, you do the Math's!!!!!

Well the maths says Shiel went at 50% DE yesterday - with all that time and composure you think he would have found more targets

[Scollop]

You're going to confuse him with logic, reasoning and common sense. He wants to just focus on maths for now

[stonecold]

You're going to confuse him with logic, reasoning and common sense. He wants to just focus on maths for now

You want to have a go Cowboy?????

<warning for bullying>

[stonecold]

looking at it another way, Jack Steven would be on $600 for the next 2 years thats a rough guess. Hannebery comes and gets a reported $800k for 3-5 years. Shiel arrives and gets $1.3mill a year for 5 years. That means he is getting $700k a year more than J.Steven. Jack Steele who is on the up would be on $440 a year. Seb Ross- who knows what he is on but guess $500k a year and from most reports Shiel's kicking is a bit up and under and certainly not an accurate kick for goal as one poster pointed out. So where does that leave these guys. If I was Jack Steven I know what I would be doing right now.

You do the maths

Well for starters, we won't be paying all Dan's wage, Sydney will be paying some, as for Jack's wage, you think that is correct do you ($600k)?????

As much as I like Stuv, Shiel's is a better player, one of not many last night that had time and composer!!!!!

So, you do the Math's!!!!!

Well the maths says Shiel went at 50% DE yesterday - with all that time and composure you think he would have found more targets

No worries Warrior!!!!!

Onya Sonya!!!!!

[Devilhead]

looking at it another way, Jack Steven would be on $600 for the next 2 years thats a rough guess. Hannebery comes and gets a reported $800k for 3-5 years. Shiel arrives and gets $1.3mill a year for 5 years. That means he is getting $700k a year more than J.Steven. Jack Steele who is on the up would be on $440 a year. Seb Ross- who knows what he is on but guess $500k a year and from most reports Shiel's kicking is a bit up and under and certainly not an accurate kick for goal as one poster pointed out. So where does that leave these guys. If I was Jack Steven I know what I would be doing right now.

You do the maths

Well for starters, we won't be paying all Dan's wage, Sydney will be paying some, as for Jack's wage, you think that is correct do you ($600k)?????

As much as I like Stuv, Shiel's is a better player, one of not many last night that had time and composer!!!!!

So, you do the Math's!!!!!

Well the maths says Shiel went at 50% DE yesterday - with all that time and composure you think he would have found more targets

No worries Warrior!!!!!

Onya Sonya!!!!!

Just stating the facts Helen ..... just settin you straight and statin facts!!

[BenLong#21]

Whitfield is also better than Shiel

[chico2001]

Certainly based on that effort the other night, he was a star

[asiu]

You're going to confuse him with logic, reasoning and common sense. He wants to just focus on maths for now

You want to have a go Cowboy?????

WTF

















where are the exclamation marks agro !!!!!

[stonecold]

You're going to confuse him with logic, reasoning and common sense. He wants to just focus on maths for now

You want to have a go Cowboy?????

WTF

















where are the exclamation marks agro !!!!!

Didn't use any, in case some took offence, guess what, still got a warning, go figure!!!!!

Maybe it was the 'C' word I used?????

Cowboy, haha!!!!!

Guess what, I'm old school, I swear, I tell it how it is and I f****** well will continue to do so!!!!!

Some on hear squat for The National Anthem, I'll continue to Stand!!!!!

[MC Gusto]

I’ve got a feeling he’ll go to Syd

They are def up to something - clearing the decks and making space in their cap

Just a hunch, no rumour or inside word to go by

[saint-stu]

I'm not at all convinced that Shiel is better the Stuv. I rarely see Shiel play, but he was pretty ordinary in that final. You will very rarely see Stuv play such a poor game.

Stuv's averages were better than Shiel's last year also.

[Train9]

Hello everyone,

First time poster, long time reader of this forum.

With Dylan Shiel, I have some information.
We have put a godfather offer to him which is nearly too good to refuse. But if he does entertain the idea, he wants questions answered in regards to which way the club is going etc.

5 weeks ago Sydney were on the box seat which has only just come to media attention as he does love living in Sydney.

I’m not a “ITK” or anything like that, but with this the source is pretty spot on

Be a few interesting weeks coming up!

Go Saints

[DJ Higgins]

I'm not at all convinced that Shiel is better the Stuv. I rarely see Shiel play, but he was pretty ordinary in that final. You will very rarely see Stuv play such a poor game.

Stuv's averages were better than Shiel's last year also.

True but imagine two players of similar skills playing together. All of a sudden Stuv isn't the only outside option in the middle and get less attention and will start having even better games

[samoht]

Hopefully his poor/average disposal is because he's adventurous with his kicking and kicks the ball long.
Our recruiters are probably thinking (regarding his average disposal)..... "No worries. Shiel be right, mate. Close enough is near enough."

[Yorkeys]

Shiel has a wonderful CV/footy profile. I don't want to get my hopes up but I am. I think he would be a significantly better buy than Gaff. Shiel and Steele and Dan (Steely Dan) in the middle - be still my heart. Paddy and Membrey would think its Christmas - some class to do the "Dirty Work".

[The Real Numpty]

Guess what, I'm old school, I swear, I tell it how it is and I f****** well will continue to do so!!!!!

Some on hear squat for The National Anthem, I'll continue to Stand!!!!!

Mr Austin you are a true patriot, the truest of patriots, just like my very great friends Park Avenue Sainter and Mr Huggins. And nobody knows truest patriots like I do, believe me! Only black marxist Mexican taliban towelheads like To The Tulips and Sunflower Saint refuse to stand for the national anthem. And that's a disgrace! I always stand! I love 'Waltzing Matilda'. (And see loves my long and splendid fingers, and other parts, believe me. ) #makingstandingpatriotsandMatildagreatagain

[fugazi]

Hello everyone,

First time poster, long time reader of this forum.

With Dylan Shiel, I have some information.
We have put a godfather offer to him which is nearly too good to refuse. But if he does entertain the idea, he wants questions answered in regards to which way the club is going etc.

5 weeks ago Sydney were on the box seat which has only just come to media attention as he does love living in Sydney.

I’m not a “ITK” or anything like that, but with this the source is pretty spot on

Be a few interesting weeks coming up!

Go Saints

Welcome Train 9
Interesting first post. Any idea what the proposed exchange might be if he was to accept the Godfather deal?

[BenLong#21]

Hello everyone,

First time poster, long time reader of this forum.

With Dylan Shiel, I have some information.
We have put a godfather offer to him which is nearly too good to refuse. But if he does entertain the idea, he wants questions answered in regards to which way the club is going etc.

5 weeks ago Sydney were on the box seat which has only just come to media attention as he does love living in Sydney.

I’m not a “ITK” or anything like that, but with this the source is pretty spot on

Be a few interesting weeks coming up!

Go Saints

Welcome Train 9
Interesting first post. Any idea what the proposed exchange might be if he was to accept the Godfather deal?

My guess
Giants would want pick 4. But they could give us 23 back.
That would value DS at pick 13 which I think is fair value.

[Train9]

Hello everyone,

First time poster, long time reader of this forum.

With Dylan Shiel, I have some information.
We have put a godfather offer to him which is nearly too good to refuse. But if he does entertain the idea, he wants questions answered in regards to which way the club is going etc.

5 weeks ago Sydney were on the box seat which has only just come to media attention as he does love living in Sydney.

I’m not a “ITK” or anything like that, but with this the source is pretty spot on

Be a few interesting weeks coming up!

Go Saints

Welcome Train 9
Interesting first post. Any idea what the proposed exchange might be if he was to accept the Godfather deal?

I’m not sure what a trade looks like or anything like that. But I do know someone very close to the family and it will be interesting to see how it plays out.

[MC Gusto]

https://www.3aw.com.au/gws-gun-priority ... -st-kilda/

[BenLong#21]

GWS, Hawks, Essendon or Blues.

We arent even in the game.