Match Review Person ( Officer)- MRP / MRO 2018

[saintbrat]

JLT 1 vs Carlton
Shame Savage got pinged fir hitting the newbie and breaking his tooth-- which young person forgot the second rule of Football- WEAR your MOUTHGAURD = $2000

But Harry McKay Cleared from a hit on Geary - no realistic alternative

[CQ SAINT]

Over 28 years of senior footy I never wore one. Couldn't breath properly with one in. Lost 4 teeth and split both lips a few times though.

[saynta]

Someone's lucky. There were a few punches thrown in that melee.

[oh when the]

Nothing changes with MR
still wack a Saint

[saintbrat]

JLT 2
No incidents noted after review

[saintbrat]

Round 1 Vs Lions
NO Saints cited

Robinson was charged with striking St Kilda's Seb Ross during the fourth quarter at Etihad Stadium

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-26/b ... aging-fine

[St Chris]

Round 1 Vs Lions
NO Saints cited

Robinson was charged with striking St Kilda's Seb Ross during the fourth quarter at Etihad Stadium

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-26/b ... aging-fine

Fair enough too, was a dog hit. Hopefully there’s better footage, but I saw it at the ground and absolutely deserved a week.

[kosifantutti]

I was surprised Robinson was charged after Foxtel didn’t show any replays. I can only assume the umpire flagged it but he could have easily reported him on the day as it was pretty blatant.

[SaintPav]

Was that in the last quarter?

Wondered why the free kick wasn’t paid doesn’t the ground? Confusing.

[saintbrat]

Paddy cleared after Match day report
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-03-31/y ... e-roo-bump

[saintbrat]

From Rd 5

Dawson Simpson was cleared of contact on Jack Newnes while Lindsay Thomas was cleared of contact on Jack Henry.

[bigred]

Wait what...

Thomas? Are you f****** serious.

[The_Merchant]

Wait what...

Thomas? Are you f****** serious.

He got cleared for one hit. Straight to the tribunal for another and suspended for a punch.

[saintbrat]

Rd 7 saw some action
David Armitage can accept $1000 sanction, careless contact with umpire N Foot.
Nathan Jones can accept $1500 sanction, misconduct against J Newnes.
Jack Steele can accept $2000 sanction, striking M Gawn.

Hogan cleares of Diving

[saintbrat]

RD 8

Patrick Keane

Nat Fyfe cleared contact SRoss. Contact made by Fyfe's shoulder to Ross' upper chest. It was the view Fyfe executed the bump with contact to the body & could not have reasonably foreseen a clash of heads between the players. Fyfe's conduct was not unreasonable in circumstances.



Ed Curnow referred directly Tribunal, intentional contact umpire NWilliamson.
Jed Lamb can accept $1500, misconduct against MBaguley.
Charlie Curnow referred directly Tribunal, intentional contact umpire MStevic.

Jade Gresham can accept $1000, careless contact umpire JMollison

Jack Steven/Bailey Banfield can each accept $1000 for wrestling each other.

shame we aren't playing Carlton this week.

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2018-05-1 ... fe-cleared

[saynta]

RD 8

Patrick Keane

Nat Fyfe cleared contact SRoss. Contact made by Fyfe's shoulder to Ross' upper chest. It was the view Fyfe executed the bump with contact to the body & could not have reasonably foreseen a clash of heads between the players. Fyfe's conduct was not unreasonable in circumstances.



Ed Curnow referred directly Tribunal, intentional contact umpire NWilliamson.
Jed Lamb can accept $1500, misconduct against MBaguley.
Charlie Curnow referred directly Tribunal, intentional contact umpire MStevic.

Jade Gresham can accept $1000, careless contact umpire JMollison

Jack Steven/Bailey Banfield can each accept $1000 for wrestling each other.

shame we aren't playing Carlton this week.

http://www.saints.com.au/news/2018-05-1 ... fe-cleared

What a crock of the smelly steaming stuff.

Deliberte kicking in danger resulting in a concussion.Should at least be a fine.

[saint6709]

Can someone please explain - what 'reaches for the ball with his foot' means ??
An while your at it please further explain what that means in the context of a game of AFL football ?
Someone must have worked his/her brain all morning to come up with that complete rubbish - I bet they are hoping no one really notices what they have said.

After 50+ years I am really starting to go off the footy this year and agree with others that this year is worse than supporting the saints in the 80's which was mostly pretty tough

[felix]

Can someone please explain - what 'reaches for the ball with his foot' means ??
An while your at it please further explain what that means in the context of a game of AFL football ?
Someone must have worked his/her brain all morning to come up with that complete rubbish - I bet they are hoping no one really notices what they have said.

After 50+ years I am really starting to go off the footy this year and agree with others that this year is worse than supporting the saints in the 80's which was mostly pretty tough

Fyfe is so good as an assassin ..took out our best player on the day ..lined him up and wacked him ..least amount of action for most amount of damage ..dirty player.

[saintbrat]

Rd
Newnes $2000 - accidental tripping
Armo cleared on a hit

And it's Buddy's natural movement !@!!

[degruch]

How can you get fined for an accidental trip? If it's not a deliberate action, what part of the action attracts a sanction?

[saintbrat]

How can you get fined for an accidental trip? If it's not a deliberate action, what part of the action attracts a sanction?

my misreading
fined for ' Tripping"

[saintbrat]

Rd 10

ST KILDA defender Jake Carlisle has been offered a two-match suspension for his late spoil that concussed Richmond spearhead Jack Riewoldt.

Match Review Officer Michael Christian on Monday charged Carlisle with striking, grading his action as careless, high impact and high contact.

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2018-05-28/mat ... t-round-10

- ( Darling Dusty) Richmond's Dustin Martin ($1500) for misconduct against St Kilda's Jimmy Webster.

- Saint Jack Steven ($1000) for careless contact with umpire Dean Margetts.

- Tiger Shane Edwards ($3000) for striking Saint Hunter Clark.

[saintspremiers]

Eff that for a joke.

Carlisle was accidental contact.

At worst it was 1 week not 2, but being meek and mild we won’t take it to the tribunal.

I guess we are cooked and even with Jake we won’t beat either WCE or Sydney.

[saynta]

That is bulls***.

[CURLY]

Do that to one of the AFL franchise clubs MRP see the response. Collingwood Sydney and others just get away with murder.