Votes v Hawks

[George27]

6. Jack Steven
4. Jake Carlisle

2. Paddy McCartin.
1. Luke Dunstan
1. Seb Ross
1. Ben Long

[CURLY]

Webster was good.

[desertsaint]

don't know if i can find five?

webster
steven
carlisle
gilbert
hmmm...
geary

[portosaint]

5 votes for everyone that stuck to Richos plans

[kosifantutti]

Webster
Carlisle
McCartin
Steven
Dunstan

[desertsaint]

double post - no one deserves double votes.

[stonecold]

5 Votes BigBoy!!!!!;)

[saintbob]

5 Carlisle
5 Webster
3 Steele
2 Acres
1 Long

[saynta]

5. Webster
4. Carlyle
3. Gilbert
2. Long
1. Steele.

[bigcarl]

Gilbert, Geary, Carlisle, Steven, Dunstan

[Linton Lodger]

5: Carlisle

4: Webster

3: Gilbert

2: Steven

1: Dunstan

[8856brother]

5 Jake
4 Webster
3 Steven
2 Long
1 Gilbo

[freely]

Carlisle
Ross
Steven
Webster
Acres/Dunstan

[kell]

Carlisle, Steven, Dunstan, Paddy, Long

[MCG-Unit]

4 - Webster
3 - Steven
3 - Steele
3 - Savage
2 - Carlisle

[BringBackMadDog]

5 Carlisle
4 Gilbert
3 Webster
2 Steven
1 Dunstan

[Scollop]

Gresham ( smartest player in the team...how does he convince his coaches that he deserves his spot week after week)
Carlisle ( smart player in that just like Tom Stewart or Mackie before him who hardly have to defend, they somehow look good racking up posessions playing loose in the backline)
Billings ( GPS would be good, his efforts and his pressure are good - although he can't stick most tackles - and most importantly he is smart by kicking at least one goal when the game is done and dusted and there's no pressure or clutch goals required from him)
Newnes ( out of form due to concussion and yet convinces the coach to slip him back into the seniors after a week off. Newnes makes sure he is careful not to put his head over the footy or try and win it at times. His tap ons were Cyril like - except that Cyril doesn't tap it into the arms of the opposition)
Seb Ross ( another very smart player, who makes sure most weeks he stays as the second best mid in the side so he doesn't cop the tag the week after. His non-efforts are unforgiveable. I wonder if it was Steele who put his hand up at the mid week team meeting when they asked who would tag Mitchell instead of the coaches just telling Sebby; " it's your job son" )

I mean fair dinkum, I should be hanging it on the coaches not the players. The other thing I see out on the footy field at times is that we don't share goal scoring opportunities. Gresham is the worst offender. He has to be dropped next week.

[kosifantutti]

Gresham ( smartest player in the team...how does he convince his coaches that he deserves his spot week after week)
Carlisle ( smart player in that just like Tom Stewart or Mackie before him who hardly have to defend, they somehow look good racking up posessions playing loose in the backline)
Billings ( GPS would be good, his efforts and his pressure are good - although he can't stick most tackles - and most importantly he is smart by kicking at least one goal when the game is done and dusted and there's no pressure or clutch goals required from him)
Newnes ( out of form due to concussion and yet convinces the coach to slip him back into the seniors after a week off. Newnes makes sure he is careful not to put his head over the footy or try and win it at times. His tap ons were Cyril like - except that Cyril doesn't tap it into the arms of the opposition)
Seb Ross ( another very smart player, who makes sure most weeks he stays as the second best mid in the side so he doesn't cop the tag the week after. His non-efforts are unforgiveable. I wonder if it was Steele who put his hand up at the mid week team meeting when they asked who would tag Mitchell instead of the coaches just telling Sebby; " it's your job son" )

If they’re your best players from last night, you’re a worse judge than me.

If you just want to take a potshot at certain players, there are plenty of threads for that.

[St Lenny]

What is the criteria for best players? Not being smart, just wondering. Because most of the above had a decent amount of possessions, but their disposal was shocking. I can't put them in my top five except for Carlisle.

[Sainter_Dad]

54 Carlisle
36 Webster
30 Steven
18 Gilbert
9.5 Dunstan
7 Long
7 McCartin
7 Steele
6 Ross
5 Geary
5 Gresham
3 Billings
3 Savage
2.5 Acres
2 Newnes

Therefore:
5 Carlisle
4 Webster
3 Steven
2 Gilbert
1 Dunstan