Votes v Cats

[George27]

Again hard to find four-quarter contributors

6. Dunstan . He did go hard all day
3. Brown. Beat Hawkins all day
3. Carlisle
2. Geary .
1. Coffield . Much quieter in the second half, but his poise and ball use were rare highlights.

[Milne]

Geary lol

[congorozides]

If you are giving Geary votes that sums up the shitness of this club.
Under 12s coaches award s***.
Geary was putrid. Yes he tries hard.
But this is the AFL ffs.

[Scollop]

Carlisle
Dunny
Blake
Longy
Rowan

[WellardSaint]

If you are giving Geary votes that sums up the shitness of this club.
Under 12s coaches award s***.
Geary was putrid. Yes he tries hard.
But this is the AFL ffs.

How good was that 35m kick lace-out to a Pussycat?
Brilliant, Harvey-like.

[fugazi]

No-one

[howlinwolf]

1.Carlisle
2.Geary (Great captain's game)
3.Steven
4.Dunstan
5.Brown

[Milne]

If you are giving Geary votes that sums up the shitness of this club.
Under 12s coaches award s***.
Geary was putrid. Yes he tries hard.
But this is the AFL ffs.

BUT HE TRIES REALLY HARD CMON

[desertsaint]

5. Dunstan - by a country mile.
2 Brown
2. Carlisle
1. Savage
1. Geary
1. Long (just for the goal - at least it gave us something to cheer).
no more votes to give.

[kosifantutti]

Dunstan
Brown
Steele
Coffield
Geary

[saynta]

5. Dunstan
4. Carlisle
3. Steele
2. Geary
1. Brown

[George27]

If you are giving Geary votes that sums up the shitness of this club.
Under 12s coaches award s***.
Geary was putrid. Yes he tries hard.
But this is the AFL ffs.

Yeah, it is not great, is it Con? Apart from Dunstan , it was hard to find those for whom to vote. Coffield was a bit of a coaches award too, because he was pretty quiet after half time, but he does show poise.

As to Geary, well that turnover to which WellardSaint refers was truly putrid. However, overall I thought he cut off a lot of their attacks, and was in our top 5. I knew when I put him in that it would draw some ire from some folks on this website. However, that is my opinion, and my votes will be counted by the ever-reliable Sainter Dad , as will yours .

Cheers

[bergsone]

Carlise
Dunstan
Brown
Coffield
McCartin

[Bernard Shakey]

5 Dunstan
4
3 Paddy
2
1Marshall

[MCG-Unit]

5 - Dunstan
3 - Geary
3 - Savage
1 - Steele
1 - Carlisle
1 - Hickey
1 - Coffield

[avid]

5 Dunstan
3 Geary
3 Savage
2 Steele
2 Hickey

[Choppa]

Carlisle
Dunstan
Long
Marshall
Steven

[St Chris]

5 Dunstan
4 Long
3 Geary
2 McCartin
1 Brown

[The Fireman]

I thought brown was ordinary

[RODOS]

dunstan
long
carlisle
mccartin
coffield


roma for a half

[Scollop]

I vote for All the players being schnitzelled

I vote for Richo to be schnitzelled.

I vote for a meeting where All Saints staff that feel responsible should be putting their hand up to be schnitzelled

I vote for the board and for the footy department under Lethlean to be schnitzelled for allowing asssitant coaches to be missing during game day

I vote for some accountability and some consequences for coaches and assistants and players and for more schnitzelling sessions if they don't turn things round soon

[saynta]

I vote for All the players being schnitzelled

I vote for Richo to be schnitzelled.

I vote for a meeting where All Saints staff that feel responsible should be putting their hand up to be schnitzelled

I vote for the board and for the footy department under Lethlean to be schnitzelled for allowing asssitant coaches to be missing during game day

I vote for some accountability and some consequences for coaches and assistants and players and for more schnitzelling sessions if they don't turn things round soon

I agree 100 % with your second last point. Makes the club look very unprofessional.

[freely]

dunstan
paddy
carlisle
long
savage

[older saint]

5- Dunstan
4- Carlisle
3- Brown
2- Geary
1- Steven

[stonecold]

5.Dunstan
4. Carlisle
3.Brown
2. Long
1. Paddy