Is Paul Roos what we need .

felix · Post: # 1718699Post **felix** » Mon 09 Apr 2018 9:55pm

I'm torn but the guy has so much experience that Richo doesn't have. Would be a good mentor or head coach.

barneyboyz · Mon 09 Apr 2018 10:01pm

Unfortunately yes, and I thought he put in a pretty good speech tonight, the man knows his stuff.

If the AFL wants it, then I’m happy enough. We should have gone for Malthouse really though

samuraisaint · Mon 09 Apr 2018 10:14pm

No. I really couldn't go through another five years of defensive, negative football. I just couldn't. I'd rather stick with what we have now, to be honest.

SaintPav · Post: # 1718715Post **SaintPav** » Mon 09 Apr 2018 10:39pm

asiu · Post: # 1718716Post **asiu** » Mon 09 Apr 2018 10:42pm

no effen way

noddy04 · Post: # 1718717Post **noddy04** » Mon 09 Apr 2018 10:48pm

asiu wrote:no effen way

+1 and NO to Malthouse

fugazi · Post: # 1718718Post **fugazi** » Mon 09 Apr 2018 10:48pm

Roos is overrated.
Built a great culture at Swans....but didnt do much for Dees.
Past it...

SydneySainter · Tue 10 Apr 2018 12:17am

fugazi wrote:Roos is overrated.
Built a great culture at Swans....but didnt do much for Dees.
Past it...

I disagree. To say that the Dees have a lot more to be excited about then us is already an understatement.

mr six o'clock · Tue 10 Apr 2018 12:22am

No

We have enough car nuts around the club already

Waltzing St Kilda · Tue 10 Apr 2018 12:49am

NO.

Hates the Saints more than Blight.

Teflon · Post: # 1718750Post **Teflon** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 1:11am

no
finished
so is GT, Rodney Eade, Barry Cable and any other hack we roll out in times of despair
we need to really do some homework on who has the goods from assistant ranks - dare i say it.....find another Lyon ruthless but at least has a footy brain and not a corporate spin 'pleasing' rubbish brain.
Leigh Tudor has runs on the board wherever he goes....id look at him.

SydneySainter · Tue 10 Apr 2018 1:14am

Teflon wrote:no
finished
so is GT, Rodney Eade, Barry Cable and any other hack we roll out in times of despair
we need to really do some homework on who has the goods from assistant ranks - dare i say it.....find another Lyon ruthless but at least has a footy brain and not a corporate spin 'pleasing' rubbish brain.
Leigh Tudor has runs on the board wherever he goes....id look at him.

Agreed. The best out forward line has looked in the last decade was when Tudor was coach.

bigred · Post: # 1718754Post **bigred** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 1:23am

Screw that guy.

Teflon · Post: # 1718757Post **Teflon** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 1:27am

bigred wrote:Screw that guy.

Well we're being screwed by the current guy so may as well start a conga line...

freely · Post: # 1718773Post **freely** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 9:37am

Go after Caracella.

Con Gorozidis · Tue 10 Apr 2018 9:51am

freely wrote:Go after Caracella.

+1

samuraisaint · Tue 10 Apr 2018 10:14am

SydneySainter wrote:
fugazi wrote:Roos is overrated.
Built a great culture at Swans....but didnt do much for Dees.
Past it...
I disagree. To say that the Dees have a lot more to be excited about then us is already an understatement.

They haven't done anything yet. On paper they have a good list, but if they don't make top 4 this year I'd say they are underperforming. And if they don't make finals the year will be a disaster for them.

If they do a 2016 Bulldogs or 2017 Richmond, or 2005 Swans I'll buy in, but until then they're still the same as us and I'd rather keep the guy we've got. For now.

Plenty of teams can be May premiers, I'd like to see how the coaches we have dig our way out of this form slump.

samoht · Post: # 1718784Post **samoht** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 10:29am

The best recruiters is what we need.

The Demons struggled under Roos - but with the team they now have slowly assembled, they will do well under any coach.
It's all about recruiting - we need to pick the right players - and for this you need the best recruiters.

Forget the coaches - they are irrelevant and easily replaceable - but you only get one chance to recruit the right players, at every stage.

SaintPav · Post: # 1718786Post **SaintPav** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 10:41am

No, he's a flog..

Prefer others. eg Bernie Lomax would be better.

shrodes · Post: # 1718787Post **shrodes** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 10:55am

Did you see this?

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/p ... ca09b8f6bf

I was mostly onboard until

“But to have a strategy to get rid of Goddard, to get rid of Dal Santo, to get rid of McEvoy, to get rid of Jamie Cripps, it’s flawed.”

Cripps

spert · Post: # 1718788Post **spert** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 10:58am

A kangaroo would probably do a better job- Skippy for coach!

wally · Post: # 1718796Post **wally** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 12:00pm

I wonder whether you can spend too long as an assistant coach? And get too old and stop growing.
Would we have picked Bevo or Stuart Dew we went with someone like Chris Fagan (Bris) for stability
This time last year Hardwick was a hack
To me picking a coach is like draft pick no 1
I wont mention Watters & Watson

SydneySainter · Tue 10 Apr 2018 12:13pm

samuraisaint wrote:
SydneySainter wrote:
fugazi wrote:Roos is overrated.
Built a great culture at Swans....but didnt do much for Dees.
Past it...
I disagree. To say that the Dees have a lot more to be excited about then us is already an understatement.
They haven't done anything yet. On paper they have a good list, but if they don't make top 4 this year I'd say they are underperforming. And if they don't make finals the year will be a disaster for them.

If they do a 2016 Bulldogs or 2017 Richmond, or 2005 Swans I'll buy in, but until then they're still the same as us and I'd rather keep the guy we've got. For now.

Plenty of teams can be May premiers, I'd like to see how the coaches we have dig our way out of this form slump.

Fair point. But we also have a good list (not as good as Melbourne's IMO), good enough that we shouldn't be getting consistently flogged and we've been stuck in a form slump since Round 17, 2017.

saintact7 · Tue 10 Apr 2018 12:56pm

DEFINITE NO

Crossy66 · Post: # 1718810Post **Crossy66** » Tue 10 Apr 2018 1:13pm

RL.
Development work has been done, hes a melbourne boy, only has another 2 years on freo contract and we know he can be bought

Is Paul Roos what we need .

Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .

Re: Is Paul Roos what we need .