Membrey Injured

[MilneyMagic]

Membrey has injured his knee. Likely out 6-8 weeks. Surgery from what I’m hearing. Bad news indeed.

[skeptic]

And your source is?

Careful posting stuff like that here... Jaxons did it once and was run out by the pitchfork gang

[tony74]

Unfortunately there is a bit of truth here. Hurt his knee on Thursday and left the track early. Still unsure of the severity.

[Con Gorozidis]

Bring in Gilbo as a utility.

[prwilkinson]

Hope Battle gets a run.

[longtimesaint]

Hope Battle gets a run.

It would be a lot of inexperience having Coffield, Marshall. White and Battle with only 6 games between them.

[MC Gusto]

Sounds like paddy just got a 6 week run

Will be interesting as to who comes in...do we stay tall with battle or does Lonie get a run?

[Sainternist]

A friend with a reliable source also said the same thing this evening. This will be a big loss.

We'll now need Bruce and McCartin to both play out of their skin.

[longtimesaint]

Membery is very mobile so it’s hard to think who is best replacement since Weller also injured.
It might have to be Gilbert as Clark needs a run in the VFL.

[Sainternist]

Membery is very mobile so it’s hard to think who is best replacement since Weller also injured.
It might have to be Gilbert as Clark needs a run in the VFL.

Yeah not the popular choice, but I'd be going with the experience of Gilbert as well.

[saintbrat]

Membery is very mobile so it’s hard to think who is best replacement since Weller also injured.
It might have to be Gilbert as Clark needs a run in the VFL.

Yeah not the popular choice, but I'd be going with the experience of Gilbert as well.

Gilbo will also provide back up in the ruck meaning Bruce can stay forward.

[Sainternist]

Membery is very mobile so it’s hard to think who is best replacement since Weller also injured.
It might have to be Gilbert as Clark needs a run in the VFL.

Yeah not the popular choice, but I'd be going with the experience of Gilbert as well.

Gilbo will also provide back up in the ruck meaning Bruce can stay forward.

Absolutely. Giibo is at least quite versatile.

[skeptic]

My vote would be for Gilbo too

[spert]

I would play anybody over Gilbo- he is gone. Time for Battle to step up. Bad news about Membrey.

[prwilkinson]

Hope Battle gets a run.

It would be a lot of inexperience having Coffield, Marshall. White and Battle with only 6 games between them.

Fair point. I just like the kid.

[SaintPav]

Our season goes from bad to worse.

[DJ Higgins]

Play Battle. Lets be real we aren't likely to trouble Adelaide so put in a forward of the future to give him experience. If we put in Gilbo and get beaten we gain nothing

[saintsRrising]

EMERGENCIES

11 Hunter Clark
19 Sam Gilbert
25 Koby Stevens
34 Nathan Wright

[Bernard Shakey]

EMERGENCIES

11 Hunter Clark
19 Sam Gilbert
25 Koby Stevens
34 Nathan Wright

Gilbo it is then, because we won't be paying any fines.

[MilneyMagic]

And your source is?

Careful posting stuff like that here... Jaxons did it once and was run out by the pitchfork gang

My source is my source and what I know to be correct. Couldn’t give too hoots about what people think. I’ll post reliable information when I have it. This forum used to a good source for such things.

[fugazi]

Bugger....give Battle a chance.
He is the future.

[St Chris]

Teams change their emergencies all the time - have a read of Patrick Keane’s twitter feed. Geelong seem to do it every week.

Just replace one of the emergencies with Battle tomorrow morning, then replace Membrey with Battle pre-game.

[skeptic]

And your source is?

Careful posting stuff like that here... Jaxons did it once and was run out by the pitchfork gang

My source is my source and what I know to be correct. Couldn’t give too hoots about what people think. I’ll post reliable information when I have it. This forum used to a good source for such things.

No arguments MM...

Merely pointing out a forum double standard.

[Wayne42]

Put Battle in, i'd rather inexperience over incompetence, a facet Trout seems to love.

[Saintly66]

And your source is?

Careful posting stuff like that here... Jaxons did it once and was run out by the pitchfork gang

My source is my source and what I know to be correct. Couldn’t give too hoots about what people think. I’ll post reliable information when I have it. This forum used to a good source for such things.

Agree with that, this forum will either lick your arse for giving info, ignore your info or tell you “oh but such and such itk said that a while ago” and try to render your info useless.