Votes v Tigers

[George27]

5. Jade Gresham. Worked hard, finished really well. A shining light.
4. Billy Longer. Tireless display in the ruck, against a bloke who has had a very strong season.
2.Luke Dunstan. Continued his late- season resurgence. Missed a couple of early goals, which is very disappointing, but I think was still in our best.
2. Koby Stevens. Has had a very good first season for us. Unlucky with illness and injury, but has become very important, and again today provided some inside grunt.
1. Jack Billings. As always can frustrate with his misses, but has continued his upward trend today, and showed his class a lot.
1. Nick Riewoldt. As he has done for every single game of his career, he worked his guts out to present for his teammates. Watching him from the top deck of the stand, I just marvelled again at his running ability. He butchered a few disposals, but today we can forget that and embrace a man who gave every drop till the last minute.

[perfectionist]

5. Jade Gresham - a class act
4. Jake Carlisle - another class act
3. Billy Longer -this year's great improver - could be a real champ
2. Luke Dunstan- hard worker but his complete one sidedness is a problem
1. Nick Riewoldt - ran and marked as usual, our best tall on the forward line today

Boos for the blokes who turned it over so often - Jack Billings (4 goals), Jack Steven (2 goals) Jack Lonie ( 1 goal) and Seb Ross ( 2 goals). They scored 14 goals from turnovers - most of which were not under direct pressure. They only kicked 5 goals from there own good play.

[carn_sainter]

5 - Gresham - God knows we need to kick goals
4 - Carlisle - Was a veritable dam wall down there. Would have been far uglier without him.
3 - Longer - Commendable around the ground too. Cracked in harder than anyone else early.

I'm struggling to give votes after these three. Some okay performances from Dunstan and Steele, but we got murdered in the middle. Billings kicked a nice goal but otherwise just racked up silly 1-2 handballs. Acres did some nice work but is that enough? Rooey worked hard to no avail, as did Membrey.

Pretty disappointing performance across the board.

[Proph3t of egan]

5: Carlisle - controlled the defense and the only one who stopped usbfrom getting destroyed
4: Gresham - fixed his yips and was the classiest player of ground
3: Longer - another dominating performance even kicked a goal
2: Dunstan - continued a good run of form and tried hard all day
1: Roo - ran hard all day and clunked a nice mark that brought a tear to my eye in the last quarter

[bergsone]

5 Gresham
4 Carlise
3 Longer


2 Sinclair
1 Dunstan


Sorry Roo couldnt get you in........Champ

[Linton Lodger]

5: Gresham

4: Dunstan

3: Sinclair

2: Carlisle

1: Steele

[GregPackhamsHeadband]

5. Gresham

4. Carlisle

3. Steele

2. Dunstan

1. Sinclair

[Sainternist]

Gresham
Longer
Carlisle
Steele
Dunstan

[desertsaint]

Gresham
Carlisle
Longer
Dunstan
Billings

[SemperFidelis]

5. Gresh
4. Billy
3. Jake
2. Robbo
1. Dunstan

[kosifantutti]

Gresham
Carlisle
Dunstan
Billings
Steele

[avid]

3 Gresham
3 Steele
3 Dunstan
2 Carlisle
2 Billings
2 Longer

[terry smith rules]

5 steele
4 gresham
3 dunstan
2 billings
1 longer

[spert]

5. Gresham..a class above the rest of his teammates.
4. Carlise..saves us from being totally smashed on the scoreboard.
3. Longer..serviceable against pretty poor oppositon rucks.

the rest...crap and soft as.

[Teflon]

Gresham
Carlisle
Billings
Longer
Dunstan/Steele

[saintbob]

5 Gresham
4 Sinclair
3 Dunstan
2 Carlisle
1 Steele

[8856brother]

5 Gresh
4 Steele
3 Billy
1 Billings
1 Dunstan
1 Carlisle

Sent from my SM-T210 using Tapatalk

[dals_da_bomb]

5 Gresham
4 Steele
3 Carlise
1 Billings
1 Membrey
1 Ross

Ill miss doing this each week. Thanks for organising it

[StPeter]

5 Carlisle
4 Gresham
3 Dunstan
2 Steele
1 Sinclair

[freely]

Gresham
Dunstan
Carlisle
Sinclair
Ross

-1 Lonie, Weller. Unbelievable.
(Yes - thanks, Sainter Dad! I'll miss it too - though there've been many weeks I've wanted to record the minus points, not just this one!!)

[MCG-Unit]

3 - Longer
3 - Steele
3 - Dunstan
3 - Gresham
2 - Billings
1 - Sinclair


0 - El Tigre crowd

[saynta]

5. Carlisle
4. Gresham
3. Dunstan
2. Longer
1. Ross

[Sainter_Dad]

And for the last time this season:

102 Gresham
66 Carlisle
43.5 Dunstan
43 Longer
29.5 Steele
15 Billings
14 Sinclair
3 Riewoldt
3 Ross
2 Stevens
2 Roberton
1 Membrey

Therefore:
5 Gresham
4 Carlisle
3 Dunstan
2 Longer
1 Steele

[George27]

Many thanks as always , Sainter Dad. The fact that 12 blokes got votes - which is pretty typical for us- shows that we do not all see the game the same way, but your collating of the votes is greatly appreciated.

[freely]

Will there be an aggregate, Sainter Dad? I'd like to know who topped our votes for the year.